Showing posts with label trade marks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trade marks. Show all posts

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Autumn a golden season for Interflora

Pumpkin by Flowers by Walter
As summer gives way to autumn and the golden leaves tumble, the prettiest flowers are those that come the florists -- which brings the IPKat on to today's decision in Case C-323/09 Interflora Inc and Interflora British Unit v Marks & Spencer plc and Flowers Direct Online Limited, a reference to the Court of the European Union (ECJ) for a preliminary ruling from the High Court of Justice of England and Wales.

Essentially, the problem here was that Marks & Spencer bought the word 'interflora' as a keyword for Google's AdWord paid referencing service, so that people who were looking for the world-famous Interflora flower delivery service would find an advertisement for Marks & Spencer's rival service at the top of the non-organic, paid-for search results. This did not make Interflora very happy since (i) they were proprietors of the hugely famous INTERFLORA trade mark, (ii) internet users who keyed in "interflora" as a search term were obviously looking for their website and not Marks & Spencer and (iii) worst of all, this was just before the onset of St Valentine's Day, which is one of the biggest events of the year for the flower trade. This just had to be trade mark infringement, said Interflora. The ECJ's ruling in Google France that neither the sale nor the use of terms protected by trade marks as keywords constituted a per se trade mark infringement didn't help them -- but that was a "5(1)(a)" case, where same goods/same mark (double identity) infringement was alleged. Here Interflora had a '5(2)' argument, based on a use which allegedly damaged the mark's reputation or distinctive character without due cause.

The trial judge, Mr Justice Arnold, painstakingly analysed both the relevant law and the facts, before referring a raft of ten questions for preliminary rulings. Following some helpful correspondence between the referring judge and the ECJ's registry, the ten questions were pruned down and clarified to a miserly four.

Today the Court of Justice ruled as follows:
"1. Article 5(1)(a) of ... Council Directive 89/104 ... and Article 9(1)(a) of Council Regulation ... 40/94 ... must be interpreted as meaning that the proprietor of a trade mark is entitled to prevent a competitor from advertising – on the basis of a keyword which is identical with the trade mark and which has been selected in an internet referencing service by the competitor without the proprietor’s consent – goods or services identical with those for which that mark is registered, where that use is liable to have an adverse effect on one of the functions [which raises the interesting question of how many functions a trade mark has. The Court has identified four by name, but it was reported last week in the MARQUES conference that up to 17 have been identified] of the trade mark. Such use:

– adversely affects the trade mark’s function of indicating origin where the advertising displayed on the basis of that keyword does not enable reasonably well-informed and reasonably observant internet users, or enables them only with difficulty, to ascertain whether the goods or services concerned by the advertisement originate from the proprietor of the trade mark or an undertaking economically linked to that proprietor or, on the contrary, originate from a third party;

– does not adversely affect, in the context of an internet referencing service having the characteristics of the service at issue in the main proceedings, the trade mark’s advertising function; and

– adversely affects the trade mark’s investment function if it substantially interferes with the proprietor’s use of its trade mark to acquire or preserve a reputation capable of attracting consumers and retaining their loyalty.

2. Article 5(2) of Directive 89/104 and Article 9(1)(c) of Regulation No 40/94 must be interpreted as meaning that the proprietor of a trade mark with a reputation is entitled to prevent a competitor from advertising on the basis of a keyword corresponding to that trade mark, which the competitor has, without the proprietor’s consent, selected in an internet referencing service, where the competitor thereby takes unfair advantage of the distinctive character or repute of the trade mark (free-riding) or where the advertising is detrimental to that distinctive character (dilution) or to that repute (tarnishment).[this looks like good news for Interflora ...]

Advertising on the basis of such a keyword is detrimental to the distinctive character of a trade mark with a reputation (dilution) if, for example, it contributes to turning that trade mark into a generic term.["for example"opens the door to a large categories of actually or arguably genericising uses. This will be a litigation growth area, predicts Merpel]

By contrast, the proprietor of a trade mark with a reputation is not entitled to prevent, inter alia, advertisements displayed by competitors on the basis of keywords corresponding to that trade mark, which put forward – without offering a mere imitation of the goods or services of the proprietor of that trade mark, without causing dilution or tarnishment and without, moreover, adversely affecting the functions of the trade mark with a reputation – an alternative to the goods or services of the proprietor of that mark". [while this is expressed as a general principle, the Kat thinks that, in practice, it will become a narrow exception].
This IPKat team member is going to give this some further thought to this ruling and test it out a bit over a refreshing pint of Badger when the opportunity arises. In the meantime, he's quite struck with the relatively intelligible mode of expression of the Court's ruling which seems to him, prima facie, to be about as good as we can hope for when applying twentieth-century pre-internet trade mark legislation to a set of facts that is not provided for by the Directive and Regulation and which is scarcely within the radar of the Recitals.

Tuesday, August 23, 2011

Coffee wars plunge into shape protection

In the early hours of every morning, this Kat performs a ritual which will be very familiar to some readers. She (a) takes her clean cafetiere from the cupboard; (b) adds two big scoops of ground Italian coffee; (c) adds boiling water; (d) pushes the plunger down and, (e) hopes for the best. Accordingly, she has been reading with interest the recent decision in Australia concerning an alleged case of misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off between two manufacturers of cafetieres.

Peter Bodum A/S ('Bodum'), a Danish company, was founded in 1944. Since at least April 1986, Bodum widely advertised the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger (BCCP) and made substantial sales in Australia. The BCCP possessed a number of readily identified and reasonably distinctive features, being marked with the Bodum name in a number of places. When sold it also bore a prominent sticker on which the Bodum logo appeared.

DKSH Australia Pty Limited ('DKSH'), an Australian
company, was a subsidiary of a Swiss company DKSH Holdings Ltd. DKSH imported into Australia, and sold by wholesale, homeware and kitchen products including the Euroline Coffee Plunger. The Euroline Coffee Plunger possessed almost all the same physical features as the BCCP but is not marked in the same way. When sold it carried a sticker on its base which says 'Made in Taiwan'.

Not surprisingly, Bodum was far from pleased by DKSH's Euroline Coffee Plunger product on account of its similarities to the BCCP. It commenced actions for misleading and deceptive conduct under ss 52 and 53 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 and for passing off in the Federal Court. In particular, Bodum contended that the BCCP is packaged for sale in packaging that prominently depicts a photograph of the coffee plunger, thus giving prominence and emphasis to the design features of the plunger within, rendering, it is said, the packaging, in a practical sense, transparent to the consumer. According to Bodum, it had acquired a substantial and valuable reputation in the features and distinctive shape of the BCCP -- which meant that the sale in Australia of coffee plungers which embody those features (or a significant number of them) and the shape signifies to consumers that such a coffee plunger is the BCCP or is otherwise authorised by Bodum. Finally, Bodum contended that (independent of trade marks) a secondary meaning or independent reputation can subsist in the features and shape of an article or the get-up for a product which operates to associate products of that shape or those features in the mind of consumers with a particular trader although it is not necessary that the consumer knows the name of that trader.

At first instance in the Federal Court Justice Middleton found that DKSH had not engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or passing off by marketing and selling its Euroline coffee plunger: Playcorp Group of Companies Pty Ltd v Peter Bodum A/S [2010] FCA 23. At [82] he stated:
'I should state from the outset that while I am of the view that the Bodum brand itself has a significant reputation in the homewares/ housewares market, I do not consider that Bodum has the secondary meaning or reputation in the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger ... features it identifies. I consider that Bodum’s reputation is distinctly tied to its products being properly labelled and sold in conjunction with reinforcing packaging and, significantly, by reference to the Bodum name. Bodum’s reputation does not exist in the naked Coffee Plunger features ... (without its logo in place) alone. If I am wrong about this, and if Bodum does have a secondary reputation in the features alone, then I am not satisfied that the accused products ... in the way they are packaged or exposed to potential customers in Australia are sufficiently similar to give rise to the misrepresentation alleged by Bodum'.
Bodum appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, being was critical of Middleton J's findings that the BCCP had not acquired a secondary meaning or independent reputation. In particular, it submitted (at [66]) that Middleton J 'did not look at the vast body of advertising material put in evidence and relied upon by Bodum as the foundation of its secondary meaning or independent reputation for the features of the product'.

A majority of the Full Federal Court (Greenwood and Tracey JJ; Buchanan J in dissent) reversed the decision of Middleton J and found in favour of Bodum: Bodum v DKSH Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 98.

So what changed?

Writing the majority judgment, Greenwood J reviewed the relevant advertising material and was satisfied (at [197]) that
'the evidence establishes a very significant secondary reputation in the features of the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger associated in the mind of consumers with Bodum as the manufacturer of the product and, with respect to the primary judge, that reputation is not “distinctly tied” to Bodum in the sense that in the absence of the name Bodum there cannot be a secondary reputation in the features of the product'.
On this basis, according to Greenwood J (at [198]), the real question in the case is 'whether DKSH has done enough having regard to all the relevant differentiation factors to distinguish its rival product from the Bodum product'. Greenwood J answered the question in the negative. His Honour considered that:
  • The BCCP enjoyed a substantial or significant reputation by reference to its features and shape (at [220]).

  • 'Sales' of the BCCP were substantial, 'dwarfing the respective sales of ... DKSH' (at [222]).

  • DKSH had not undertaken any retail advertising of its Euroline Coffee Plunger during 2008 or 2009 (at [223]).

  • BCCP's features were 'strikingly similar' to the EuroLine Coffee Plunger (at [225]). Further, 'for all practical purposes, the overall appearance of the two products is the same' (at [227]).

  • The Euroline Coffee Plunger had no branding, such as symbol, name or logo, on the product itself (at [231]). The branding was only on the packaging and this was not sufficient.

  • The Euroline brand was 'not well known', being an 'unknown brand' (at [235]). It was 'not distinctive' and was thus 'very likely to be regarded as an abbreviated description of a product having a provenance as a product within a line of European products' (at [236]).

Having regard to these factors Greenwood J found (at [236]) 'it difficult to accept that DKSH has distinguished its product'.

This Kat says this decision should be welcomed by those seeking to rely on misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off claims to protect their product designs or 'get up'. However, he wonders whether the decision could mark the start of a slippery slope for seeking quasi protection for shapes rather than obtaining a registered trade mark or design.

Merpel, rather cheekily, questions whether the following cartoon (as shown on the Bodum website when trumpeting its success against DKSH) is the best way to encapsulate the majority decision of the Full Federal Court...

Monday, July 4, 2011

When Edge is on the brink ...

Overwhelmed by the sheer excitement of living-- and by the pile of examination scripts which piteously mew "let me pass, let me pass!" -- this Kat has only just got round to writing up the decision of Mrs Justice Proudman, of the Chancery Division (England and Wales) in Future Publishing Ltd v Edge Interactive Media Inc, Edge Games Inc and Dr Timothy Langdell [2011] EWHC 1489 (Ch), the sort of case which makes this Kat at any rate very pleased he doesn't have to deal with litigants in person (as was the third defendant in this case), despite his fabled patience. The Kat would probably have left it for a bit longer, were it not for a nudge from Mike Lynd (Mark & Clerk).

The facts go back a long way, almost to the dawn of computer games.  Future published various computer gaming magazines, one of which was EDGE.  A popular read with the British games community since its launch in 1993, EDGE bore a logo in which the two letters 'E' extended the cross bar on the left hand side, with a corresponding shortening on the right, and there was a sharp scalpel-like point at the edge of the extension (you can see what it looks like here, on the right). EDGE had a large circulation and its website was visited by over 400,000 visitors every month. Many jobs in the computer gaming industry were advertised in its pages, it had many corporate subscribers and it won a number of awards over the years, including Games Magazine of the Year 2008’.

But now we're jumping the gun. Returning to the 1980s and early 1990s one Dr Timothy Langdell -- who exclusively controlled the first and second defendant companies (EIM and EGI) -- ran a business which composed games software initially as Softek and subsequently as Edge. Langdell was at that time well known for pursuing third parties who used the name ‘Edge’ and sought payment of licence fees, failing which he pursued them for damages for trade mark infringement [Says Merpel, are you trying to tell me that there were trade mark trolls even back in the previous century?]. Langdell was a United States resident and the first and second defendant companies were incorporated in the United States.

In 1993 Langdell commenced passing-off proceedings against Future, alleging that he held unregistered rights in the trade mark EDGE and, in 1994, Langdell applied to register the word EDGE in the UK as a trade mark for printed matter, including gaming magazines, in Class 16. The action was stayed pending payment by Langdell of security for costs and the proceedings were settled by an agreement dated 4 December 1996, by which time Future, as well as EIM, had applied to register the word EDGE for printed matter in Class 16.

Under this agreement EIM would keep its registered mark and would be given Future’s trade mark application in return for a royalty-free licence under which Future would be permitted to use the mark EDGE in relation to EDGE magazine in any form; Future was also to pay EIM £20,000. In return, EIM agreed not to publish or license any other party to publish a magazine substantially similar to EDGE magazine under the name EDGE or under any colourably similar mark. In addition, EIM agreed not to assert the existence of any association or connection with EDGE magazine or with Future save that, in response to an unsolicited request, EIM could confirm that it had licensed the mark EDGE to Future in relation to EDGE magazine.

Cat on the edge, or is it the e***?
As the success of EDGE magazine grew, Langdell’s behaviour became increasingly burdensome to Future, which sought to abrogate the licensing agreement and to buy all the necessary trade marks from the defendants. The mechanism for achieving this was a Concurrent Trading Agreement (the ‘CTA’) between Future on the one side and EIM and Langdell on the other, and a separate deed between the same parties. The main effect of these instruments was to assign to Future those parts of the trade marks owned by EIM which included the word EDGE, and which covered EDGE magazine. The assignment included all rights in the agreed part of the trade marks, including all goodwill attaching to the use of the agreed part of the trade marks and all rights of action, powers and benefits arising from ownership of the agreed part. The CTA defined 'trade marks' as including not only registered trade marks but also all unregistered trade mark rights of EIM in relation to those marks. Under Clause 2.4 of the CTA, EIM undertook not to permit the use by any other person of any of the trade marks in a way which was or could reasonably cause confusion with Future’s use of them.

Langdell, EIM and EGI subsequently used three versions of an EDGE logo, each of which was based on a stretched version of the Franklin Gothic or Helvetica fonts. In all three cases, the slashed middle bar of the 'E' was retained, as well as the stretching effect of the letters. Future accordingly commenced proceedings against all three defendants, claiming breach of contract, infringement of copyright and passing off.

In this action Mrs Justice Proudman was asked to determine among other things, (i) whether the breaches of the CTA and the deed by EIM and Langdell were fundamental breaches of contract and, if so, whether Future had accepted the repudiation. That was an important issue since the claimant was restricted by the CTA from using the mark EDGE for any purpose other than the publication of computer game magazines and certain ancillary uses, (ii) whether Future’s passing off claim was justified and (iii) whether all of EIM’s registered trade marks were invalid for non-use under the Trade Marks Act 1994, s.46.

Proudman J allowed all Future's claims.

First, she concluded that the breaches of contract by the defendants were fundamental and entitled Future to repudiate: they had been deliberately calculated to cause confusion, which necessarily caused substantial damage to Future's reputation. The assignment to Future of the goodwill and registered trade mark rights in the name EDGE and the payments made by Future to EIM and Langdell did not prevent termination of the CTA so far as the future (with a small 'f') was concerned: each side was entitled to retain the benefits which it had already received. By its conduct, Future, having accepted the breaches as being repudiatory in their nature, was thus entitled to treat the contract as being at an end on account.

The passing off claim succeded too.  The judge was content to assume the existence of damage where the goodwill associated with Future’s title was being used and eroded by the defendants’ actions. On the facts, Langdell had sought to appropriate for his own business the goodwill associated with EDGE magazine by making statements which led the public to believe that EIM was responsible for that magazine or that EIM’s games were in some way approved or authorised by it.  Accordingly the pleaded breaches of the CTA which were committed within the jurisdiction of the court also comprised acts of passing off as representations which were likely to lead to confusion. Additionally, being associated with EIM was likely to cause serious damage to Future and to EDGE magazine.

The copyright infringement claim was also upheld.  All three versions of the EDGE logo used by the defendants were copies which infringed Future’s copyright. Langdell’s defence was that he had in fact invented the EDGE logo in 1991. That claim would be rejected on the basis that the evidence given by Future’s creative director that he had designed the logo for the magazine in the course of his employment and that he had been unaware of the existence of any logo used by Langdell at that time. This evidence had not been seriously challenged in cross-examination.

Since the defendants' infringing acts had taken place within the jurisdiction of the court and Langdell had continued to threaten to infringe copyright through use of the EDGE logo, an injunction was both justified and appropriate.

Finally, since on the facts there was no cogent evidence that the defendants had any presence in the United Kingdom market during the relevant period for the purposes of non-use of a trade mark over a continuous period of five years, the defendants' mark would be revoked.

The IPKat believes that every creator of a brand or trade name is entitled to protection against its misappropriation by others, but is deeply saddened by litigation such as this which results from the apparent abuse of the mechanism of a concurrent trading live-and-let-live agreement.

Are you living too close to the edge? here
Timothy Langdell and trade mark trolling here, here, here and here

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Laughing all the way to the Banksy? Graffiti guru opts for tapioca trade mark

Banksy's cat -- or is it a rat? 
Love him or loathe him, the mysterious Banksy is an entertaining and provocative feature of the modern art scene. His highly contemporary, politically pointed and generally well-executed graffiti -- often containing his signature rat -- are a vibrant, satirical contribution to debate and a great way to force us all to confront our own prejudices and cherished beliefs.

Every popular cultural icon -- and Banksy is no exception -- has to face a choice between the following options:
  • cash in on one's output and exploit it commercially;
  • ignore the commercial dimension of one's reputation and output and refuse to be part of the system that creates this commerciality;
  • dabble in the protection and commercialisation of one's name and reputation, but justify it on moral, not commercial, grounds.
Banksy's own position can be seen from the statement on his website:
"You're welcome to download whatever you wish from this site for personal use. However, making your own art or merchandise and passing it off as ‘official’ or authentic Banksy artwork is bad and very wrong.

Banksy neither produces or profits from the sale of greeting cards, mugs or photo canvases of his work. He is not represented by any of the commercial galleries that sell his paintings second hand and cannot be found on facebook/twitter/myspace etc.".
Notwithstanding this, Banksy (who trades under cover of Pest Control Office Limited), has been busily filing for trade mark protection with the UK's Intellectual Property Office (many thanks go to the Kat's friend Edward Smith for spotting this). This company secured, back in 2008, registration of the word BANKSY in no fewer than 20 Classes of goods and services, for, among other things
"Class 03: Cleaning, polishing, scouring and abrasive preparations [Merpel notes how handy these goods can be for, er, removing graffiti];
Class 19: statues and sculptures of stone, concrete or marble [good idea: Banky goes in for sculpture too -- witness The Drinker, parodying Rodin's The Thinker, stolen here]; floor tiles, wall tiles.
Class 20: goods of horn, bone, ivory, whalebone [Ooh, not an animal rights man, is he? Particularly after getting into trouble for elephant abuse], shell, amber, mother-of-pearl, meerschaum and substitutes for all these materials, or of plastics.
Class 29: edible oils and fats [BANKSY edible fats will literally run off the shelves, predicts Merpel].
Class 30: tapioca, sago [one member of the Kat family, having experienced these products in his youth, has always been puzzled as to why they've been classed as foods. In his opinion, this could be one of those rare cases in which the goodwill in the mark is damaged by the badwill in the product to which it is attached -- good luck with this one, Banksy]".
Graffiti men at work here

Saturday, May 14, 2011

GIPI3: how do you rate?

Recently this Kat was fortunate to attend the launch of the Third Report of the Global Intellectual Property Index (GIPI) at the London office of European law firm Taylor Wessing. After a helpful introduction by team leader Roland Mallinson, there was then a lively discussion of the findings of the survey, with key team members from Taylor Wessing on hand to answer specific questions.

For those unfamiliar with the concept of GIPI, it is an evaluation of the attractiveness of 24 national jurisdictions for obtaining, exploiting, enforcing and attacking the key IP rights (trade marks, patents, copyright and designs). In a new twist, this year the survey also considers personal data requirements for the first time. The survey combines and weights 43 instrumental factors from 14,000 individual responses. It functions to give a better insight on doing business in a particular jurisdiction rather than relying on anecdotal evidence such as ‘trials of patents in Country A take years’ or ‘it is quick to register a trade mark in Country B than Country C’. In doing so, it hopes to create a melting pot of empirical evidence to encourage better laws for doing business in those jurisdictions.

In theory, five kinds of rights, across 24 jurisdictions according to 43 instrumental factors would be enough to strike fear into the hearts of most Kats. However, to their credit, the team at Taylor Wessing has produced a highly readable report. In particular, it provides a number of tables which group jurisdictions into five tiers of competitiveness for each individual right as well as an interesting commentary on significant changes since GIPI2.

The key table is:

Some important insights from this table include:
· Germany scored three 1st positions in the individual IP indices but last for the personal data index.· Russia has pulled away from the other BRIC countries.
· Common law countries made up seven of the top 11 jurisdictions.
· India ranked last overall in three of the five indices.
· Apart from Australia, all six of the top tier jurisdictions ranked consistently well for all individual IP indices except for the personal data index. This in turn raises the concern that data regimes in these countries are weighted too much against business.
In addition to the detailed discussion of the individual IP rights, some general overarching themes also emerged from the survey. These include:

  • 62% of respondents said that they had spent more time on IP issues over the last three years.
  • 60% of respondents felt that IP law needs updating to keep up with technological and online business developments.
  • Value for money is increasingly important for businesses in choosing where to litigate.
  • There are improved perceptions of EU harmonisation: 8% decrease in variance between the lowest and highest ranked EU Member States.

The IPKat says that the team at Taylor Wessing are to be congratulated for collating, analysing and presenting such an important and accessible report. He looks forward to GIPI4 to see whether the laws of individual jurisdictions have responded to the interesting questions raised in GIPI3.

Merpel wonders whether the UK could score as highly in the Eurovision Song Contest as it does in the GIPI3.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Hours and minutes: the Advocate General speaks

The Court of Justice of the European Union is being kept very busy by intellectual property matters these days. Today's batch of Curia posts includes the Advocate General's Opinion in Case C‑190/10 Génesis Seguros Generales Sociedad Anónima de Seguros y Reaseguros (GENESIS) v Boys Toys SA and Administración del Estado, a reference for a preliminary ruling from Spain.

The question has been published in English:
"May Article 27 of Council Regulation ...40/94 ... on the Community trade mark be interpreted in such a way as to enable account to be taken not only of the day but also of the hour and minute of filing of an application for registration of a Community trade mark with OHIM (provided that such information has been recorded) for the purposes of establishing temporal priority over a national trade mark application filed on the same day, where the national legislation governing the registration of national trade marks considers the time of filing to be relevant?".
The AG's Opinion alas, is in a smattering of Euro-tongues, including Latvian -- but again not in English. The French version reads like this:

«En l’état actuel du droit de l’Union, l’article 27 du règlement (CE) nº 40/94 du Conseil, du 20 décembre 1993, sur la marque communautaire, exclut qu’il soit tenu compte, au‑delà du jour de dépôt de la demande de la marque communautaire, également de l’heure et de la minute dudit dépôt.»
With the aid of Google's translation service this reads:

"In the current EU law, Article 27 of Regulation (EC) No 40/94 of 20 December 1993, the CTM, it does not take into account beyond the date of filing of the CTM, also an hour and minute of that deposit".
We get the message.  Merpel adds, this was no easy question, it seems.  The AG needed nearly 80 paragraphs and over 40 footnotes ...