Showing posts with label Passing off. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Passing off. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 23, 2011

Coffee wars plunge into shape protection

In the early hours of every morning, this Kat performs a ritual which will be very familiar to some readers. She (a) takes her clean cafetiere from the cupboard; (b) adds two big scoops of ground Italian coffee; (c) adds boiling water; (d) pushes the plunger down and, (e) hopes for the best. Accordingly, she has been reading with interest the recent decision in Australia concerning an alleged case of misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off between two manufacturers of cafetieres.

Peter Bodum A/S ('Bodum'), a Danish company, was founded in 1944. Since at least April 1986, Bodum widely advertised the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger (BCCP) and made substantial sales in Australia. The BCCP possessed a number of readily identified and reasonably distinctive features, being marked with the Bodum name in a number of places. When sold it also bore a prominent sticker on which the Bodum logo appeared.

DKSH Australia Pty Limited ('DKSH'), an Australian
company, was a subsidiary of a Swiss company DKSH Holdings Ltd. DKSH imported into Australia, and sold by wholesale, homeware and kitchen products including the Euroline Coffee Plunger. The Euroline Coffee Plunger possessed almost all the same physical features as the BCCP but is not marked in the same way. When sold it carried a sticker on its base which says 'Made in Taiwan'.

Not surprisingly, Bodum was far from pleased by DKSH's Euroline Coffee Plunger product on account of its similarities to the BCCP. It commenced actions for misleading and deceptive conduct under ss 52 and 53 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 and for passing off in the Federal Court. In particular, Bodum contended that the BCCP is packaged for sale in packaging that prominently depicts a photograph of the coffee plunger, thus giving prominence and emphasis to the design features of the plunger within, rendering, it is said, the packaging, in a practical sense, transparent to the consumer. According to Bodum, it had acquired a substantial and valuable reputation in the features and distinctive shape of the BCCP -- which meant that the sale in Australia of coffee plungers which embody those features (or a significant number of them) and the shape signifies to consumers that such a coffee plunger is the BCCP or is otherwise authorised by Bodum. Finally, Bodum contended that (independent of trade marks) a secondary meaning or independent reputation can subsist in the features and shape of an article or the get-up for a product which operates to associate products of that shape or those features in the mind of consumers with a particular trader although it is not necessary that the consumer knows the name of that trader.

At first instance in the Federal Court Justice Middleton found that DKSH had not engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or passing off by marketing and selling its Euroline coffee plunger: Playcorp Group of Companies Pty Ltd v Peter Bodum A/S [2010] FCA 23. At [82] he stated:
'I should state from the outset that while I am of the view that the Bodum brand itself has a significant reputation in the homewares/ housewares market, I do not consider that Bodum has the secondary meaning or reputation in the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger ... features it identifies. I consider that Bodum’s reputation is distinctly tied to its products being properly labelled and sold in conjunction with reinforcing packaging and, significantly, by reference to the Bodum name. Bodum’s reputation does not exist in the naked Coffee Plunger features ... (without its logo in place) alone. If I am wrong about this, and if Bodum does have a secondary reputation in the features alone, then I am not satisfied that the accused products ... in the way they are packaged or exposed to potential customers in Australia are sufficiently similar to give rise to the misrepresentation alleged by Bodum'.
Bodum appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, being was critical of Middleton J's findings that the BCCP had not acquired a secondary meaning or independent reputation. In particular, it submitted (at [66]) that Middleton J 'did not look at the vast body of advertising material put in evidence and relied upon by Bodum as the foundation of its secondary meaning or independent reputation for the features of the product'.

A majority of the Full Federal Court (Greenwood and Tracey JJ; Buchanan J in dissent) reversed the decision of Middleton J and found in favour of Bodum: Bodum v DKSH Australia Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 98.

So what changed?

Writing the majority judgment, Greenwood J reviewed the relevant advertising material and was satisfied (at [197]) that
'the evidence establishes a very significant secondary reputation in the features of the Bodum Chambord Coffee Plunger associated in the mind of consumers with Bodum as the manufacturer of the product and, with respect to the primary judge, that reputation is not “distinctly tied” to Bodum in the sense that in the absence of the name Bodum there cannot be a secondary reputation in the features of the product'.
On this basis, according to Greenwood J (at [198]), the real question in the case is 'whether DKSH has done enough having regard to all the relevant differentiation factors to distinguish its rival product from the Bodum product'. Greenwood J answered the question in the negative. His Honour considered that:
  • The BCCP enjoyed a substantial or significant reputation by reference to its features and shape (at [220]).

  • 'Sales' of the BCCP were substantial, 'dwarfing the respective sales of ... DKSH' (at [222]).

  • DKSH had not undertaken any retail advertising of its Euroline Coffee Plunger during 2008 or 2009 (at [223]).

  • BCCP's features were 'strikingly similar' to the EuroLine Coffee Plunger (at [225]). Further, 'for all practical purposes, the overall appearance of the two products is the same' (at [227]).

  • The Euroline Coffee Plunger had no branding, such as symbol, name or logo, on the product itself (at [231]). The branding was only on the packaging and this was not sufficient.

  • The Euroline brand was 'not well known', being an 'unknown brand' (at [235]). It was 'not distinctive' and was thus 'very likely to be regarded as an abbreviated description of a product having a provenance as a product within a line of European products' (at [236]).

Having regard to these factors Greenwood J found (at [236]) 'it difficult to accept that DKSH has distinguished its product'.

This Kat says this decision should be welcomed by those seeking to rely on misleading and deceptive conduct and passing off claims to protect their product designs or 'get up'. However, he wonders whether the decision could mark the start of a slippery slope for seeking quasi protection for shapes rather than obtaining a registered trade mark or design.

Merpel, rather cheekily, questions whether the following cartoon (as shown on the Bodum website when trumpeting its success against DKSH) is the best way to encapsulate the majority decision of the Full Federal Court...

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Plane users can't tell airlines from airways, rules court

This wasn't quite what the IPKat
meant about an inside story ...
One reason why patent cases are usually easy to blog about than trade mark cases is that the names of the parties are generally quite different from each other.  Woe to the blogger who gets the parties the wrong way round, as was the danger in United Airlines Inc v United Airways Limited, not yet on BAILII, a decision from last Friday in the High Court (Chancery Division), England and Wales.  If you find the identities of the parties here a little confusing, that's because they are -- as Mr Justice Vos so held.

So what happened here to cause Vos J -- the only judge in the Chancery Division, and one of only two judges in the entire High Court, to possess a three-letter surname -- to reach this conclusion? The story goes like this.  United Airlines is a well-known US airline.  United Airways Bangladesh Limited, to give the company's full name, is a less well-known Bangladeshi airline.  Said United Airlines, United Airways was both passings itself off and infringing its UNITED and UNITED AIRLINES trade marks by employing the abbreviated term UNITED AIRWAYS, in either English or Bengali script, on its seven-aircraft fleet in flights between Dhaka and London from 2009.

Leaving no trade mark stone unturned, United Airlines sought summary judgment and alleged pretty well every kind of infringement known to European man -- same mark/same services; similar mark/same services and a likelihood of confusion and takng unfair advantage of its reputed marks without due cause, thereby diluting them.  No way, said United Airways: the marks didn't look alike; the airlines were different, flew different routes and had different point-of-sale outlets; consumers wouldn't be confused and in any event could do their own research if they wanted to check, and so on.

Vos J granted United Airlines' application for injunctive relief straight off on the basis that there was no way that any defence to the action could succeed.  In his view it was obvious that the parties' respective marks were not truly identical since the bits after the word "United" were different.  However it has to be asked whether, on a global appreciation, the differences were so insignificant that they might go unnoticed by the average consumer, this being a question of fact [how good it is to see that, after over 20 years of harmonised trade mark law in the EU, there are still questions of fact and that this test has not been relentlessly hammered into a question of law]. "AIRLINES" and "AIRWAYS" were not synonymous but, when looked at from the point of view of an average consumer, they effectively conveyed the same meaning. This being so, the average consumer, being unconcerned with corporate identity, would be as likely as not to consider that the Bangladeshi operation was United Airlines' subsidiary. Accordingly, viewed as a whole, the differences between the signs were so insignificant that they would go unnoticed by the average consumer and the two marks therefore sufficiently identical for a same marks/same services action under the Trade Marks Act 1994, s.10(1) to succeed.  Oh, and there was one small issue concerning identity of services too: the fact that airlines fly different routes doesn't make them different services for trade mark purposes.

Regarding the similar marks/identical services claim under s.10(2) of the same Act, evidence of actual confusion was not conclusive, and rarely significant [Not much point in adducing it then? But evidence of lack of actual confusion is equally inconclusive and insignificant ...]. The average consumer was likely to be confused if, lacking intimate knowledge as to the difference between "AIRLINES" from "AIRWAYS", he relied on the imperfect picture he had of the marks and signs in his mind. The same would apply if he reached the Bangladeshi airway's website.

United Airways couldn't say they were merely using their own name when they had picked a name that had been well-established for decades -- particularly since they offered no reason why they should have chosen it.  Its conduct was unfair and was caught by the unfair advantage provisions of s.10(3).

United Airlines' argument based on passing off was also irresistable. Goodwill in the company's marks was established on the evidence, as was the fact that members of the public would believe, on the basis of the similarity, that the Bangladeshi business was connected with the US one. The argument that the public could carry out research and discover that there was no link between the parties must fail [If it succeeded here, we could all kiss goodbye to the tort of passing off, since it would succeed on every occasion].

Funnily enough, after coming across this decision, whom should the IPKat bump into at the AIPPI UK Garden Party yesterday evening but a very sunny Isabel Davies, virtuoso trade mark litigator and now Consultant to Boyes Turner, the firm which acted for the victorious United in this very case. Pressed by the Kat to spill the beans on all the behind-the-scenes information that makes these cases so much fun, Isabel would not be drawn into anything less discreet than the tactful observation that "the judge looked very carefully at the evidence when he came to this conclusion, granting summary judgment. He refused leave to appeal on the basis of his view on the case".  Merpel wonders whether, even if leave had been granted, United Airways might spend its money more beneficially in changing its offending livery.

The Damned United here

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Use of financial services sector mark in City of London of 'more than local significance;

The Fortress Participations BV logo
The extent to which the scope of use of an earlier mark which is cited in aid of a Community trade mark opposition or cancellation is becoming an increasingly lively topic.  It was no surprise to the IPKat, therefore, when his friend Roland Mallinson (Taylor Wessing) just happened to wonder whether the readers of this weblog might be interested in a recent decision of the OHIM Board of Appeal in Case R 355/2009-2 Fortress Investment Group LLC and Fortress Investment Group (UK) Ltd v Fortress Participations BV, a decision of 8 March 2011 which, at the time of checking, was not yet available online -- but you can read it here.  Let Roland (who acted for the two applicants/appellants, 'FIG') take up the story:
"FIG had sought to cancel FP's two Community trade marks for the mark FORTRESS (one a word and the other a device) on the basis of an earlier UK passing off right. The OHIM Cancellation Division rejected the applications for cancellation but the OHIM Board of Appeal has reversed these decisions.  Since the two mirror each other, I'll just deal with one of them here. In each case the Board accepted the evidence of the prior passing off right that had previously been rejected at first instance.

In terms of interesting law: 
• Use of a mark on financial services in the City of London was held to be use of "more than mere local significance" and so could give rise to a prior right to be relied upon in an objection under Article 8(4) of the Community Trade Mark Regulation (CTMR). The test is not just geographic but also economic. London is the seat of all government institutions and bodies and the City is one of the leading financial centres of the world (para 46). The same could presumably be true in other sectors which may have limited or very focused geographic markets (perhaps diamonds and Amsterdam?). 
• The Board held that its discretion to admit additional evidence at appeal stage is broader than in oppositions due to public policy considerations; unlike an opposition, a cancellation action is a final process. It also helped in this case that the new evidence merely corroborated and confirmed the previous evidence (para 33). 
• Contrary to the decision of the Cancellation Division, there is no obligation under Article 8(4) to show use of the brand relied upon during the five year period prior to filing the cancellation action. The Board distinguished reliance on a prior (unregistered) passing off right to reliance on a prior CTM or national mark. However, the Board nevertheless still ruled that use of the prior mark had to be shown not only for the period prior to the CTM filing date (in order to establish the earlier unregistered right) but also that the use had to be continuous right up the date of filing the cancellation action (para 44). This requirement was stated to be independent of national law. It seems to derive from the CTMR, perhaps from Article 8(4) itself, but the Board does not make this clear. Article 8(4) requires the prior mark relied upon to be "used in the course of trade". Does the passive past participle "used" mean the use has to be right up to the date of filing the opposition/cancellation action or just previously used in the past? The Board referred also to Rule 19(2)(d) CTM Implementing Regulations. However, this just requires the submission of evidence of the "acquisition, continued existence and scope of protection" of the prior right. Under English law, the "continued existence" today of a prior passing off right doesn't require use today. It is possible to sue in reliance on historic or residual goodwill in a brand that has not been used for some years (cf Ad-Lib Club v Granville [1972] RPC 673). In fact, in this case, it didn't matter since it was accepted that FIG was still using the brand".
If anyone fancies answering these questions, this weblog makes itself available for that very purpose.

Flying fortress here
Fortress Europe here

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Walking fingers in Azerbaijan irrelevant to British action, rules judge

Sometimes, if you listen carefully, you can almost hear the sound of inflated expectations being deflated. Here is one such case.  There was only going to be one winner in the proceedings mentioned here, and it wasn't going to be any of the defendants: by name, Yell Ltd v Louis Giboin and others [2011] EWPCC 009, 4 April 2011, a decision of Judge Birss QC in the Patents County Court (PCC), England and Wales.

This logo was still accessible on
Sunday 10 April, here
In short, Yell was the registered proprietor of the YELLOW PAGES trade marks, one of which was a word mark and the other a device mark containing the words YELLOW PAGES.  These marks are well-known, both by the public and by unsuccessful litigants of various descriptions. The defendants' websites -- www.zagg.eu and www.transport-yellow-pages.com -- used the words "transport yellow pages" and a "walking fingers" device in a truck motif (right) in respect of an online directory of transport business and other services.

The defendants agreed that they had used Yell's trade marks but, they said, this was no problem: after all, their websites were not UK-based. Didn't the judge know that they were outside outside the court's jurisdiction?

Now that the PCC has its smart new set of teeth, Yell obviously hoped there would be someone, or something, to bite.  The company was not disappointed.  Even without its new cutting-edge rules, the PCC was well equipped to deal with this claim.  Judge Birss QC found that the average consumer of the defendants' services within the UK would regard their websites as being directed at them for (among other things) services which could be bought in the UK and which were being supplied in the UK.  Not only was there trade mark infringement under the Trade Marks Act 1994, sections 10(2) [similar marks and services plus a likelihood of confusion] and 10(3) [taking unfair advantage, without due cause of the reputation of YELLOW PAGES], but there was passing off too: while Yell's marks were undoubtedly associated with a paper directory service, the British public associated them with UK directory services in whatever form they were delivered --including online.

Says the IPKat, an interesting diversion in this actions was caused by an attempt to raise the defence that the "walking fingers" had become generic, at least when used online. This brave attempt was based on US case law as well as on evidence submitted in respect of Australia and Azerbaijan. Thus
"Mr Giboin relied on a judgment of the United States' Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (the CAFC) dated 26th July 1995 in BellSouth Corporation v DataNational Corporation and others case 91-1461. The case was heard by Chief Judge Archer and Circuit Judges Rich and Mayer. BellSouth appealed from the decision of the Trade Mark Trial and Appeal Board of the United States PTO sustaining an opposition against their application to register a walking fingers logo as a design mark for classified telephone directories. The CAFC held that the "walking fingers" logo was a generic identifier of classified telephone directories in a (large) part of the USA.".
Alas for the defendants, both this submission and evidence that "walking fingers" online directories existed in Australia and Azerbaijan was fatally flawed by the fact that this dispute had to be determined in the UK, under British law and in relation to the mindset of the British consumer.

Merpel notes with interest that the word "numpty" appears in the judgment. As the judge explained:
"Yell also relied on the evidence of Luke Humble. He is a specialist in online marketing and website design. He is independent of Yell. He drew Yell's attention to the defendants' websites in the first place. The purpose of this evidence from Yell's point of view is that it submits Mr Humble was misled by the defendants' websites into associating them with Yell. ... Mr Giboin described him as a numpty. For those without the benefit of a Scottish education, a numpty is a derogatory expression referring to an ignorant stupid person. ...".
This is not actually the first time the n-word has been used in British litigation. It can be found, in the plural ("numpties") in Sheffield Wednesday Football Club Ltd and others v Hargreaves [2007] EWHC 2375 (QB), a Queen's Bench ruling of Richard Parkes QC, sitting as an additional High Court judge. Merpel observes that it is only necessary to explain the meaning of this word in County Court proceedings, since those engaged in High Court litigation, being better informed and probably able to converse with one another in Latin, are probably familiar with this term of art. Curiously, since the word is said to be Scottish, a search of the Scottish Courts database reveals no use of the n-word, either in its singular or plural form.

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Irish paper folds, but it's no O'Rigami ...



In "'Mail' sued over 'Tribune' cover" the Irish Times reports that the Irish Mail on Sunday is being sued for passing off over its alleged “brazen and outrageous” publication last month of a fake copy of the Sunday Tribune, only days after the latter went into receivership.  Lawyers for the receiver say the newspaper is to seek damages, including “exemplary damages” over this “direct attack” on the goodwill of the Sunday Tribune.

The Irish Mail on Sunday however described the Sunday Tribune as “a dead man walking, if it was even walking” at the time of the disputed publication in early February, claiming that the goodwill of the Sunday Tribune was not even worth the €40,000 cost of the libel insurance which would have been necessary to publish it.

Mr Justice Peter Kelly has said that he would transfer the proceedings to the Commercial Court since the action was admissible within the rules relating to passing off cases, there no longer being a monetary threshold for passing off actions.  The trial has been listed for 21 March.

The IPKat, aided by legions of amicable Irish IP enthusiasts, of which Gemma O'Farrell is not the least to be reckoned with, suspects that he will have more to report to readers of this weblog in due course.

Origami here
Irish origami, or what to do with your newspaper when it folds, here