Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Every Lidl helps? A blueprint for Europe's IP

Sacré bleu! 
Merciless to the end, the European Commission waited till every Kat was out at work, toiling on other pressing projects, before releasing today's bombshell -- the announcement of a new blueprint for IP rights to boost innovation. This was a subject that cried out for a rapid response, but no Kats were there to rapidly respond (or, says the ever-pedantic Merpel, to respond rapidly in the case of those readers who are squeamish about split infinitives).  The Commission's press release, duly annotated by this Kat, is reproduced here and reads like this:
"IP/11/630
Brussels, 24 May 2011
Commission sets out "blueprint" for
IP Rights to boost creativity and innovation
[Cringeworthy introduction deleted in its entirety, together with quotes from  Internal Market Commissioner Michel Barnier and Algirdas Šemeta, Commissioner responsible for Customs].
The IPR Strategy sets out a series of short- and long-term key policy actions in various areas which include:
Patents: the Commission already launched proposals in April for a unitary patent protection under enhanced cooperation (see IP/11/470). Meanwhile, work will continue on proposals relating to the creation of a unified and specialised patent court for the classical European patents and the future European patents with unitary effect. This would considerably reduce litigation costs and the time it takes to resolve patent disputes. It would also increase legal certainty for business [Nothing new and unexpected here, though the Kat continues to ask how there is more business certainty for a patent owner whose patent is either valid or invalid, or infringed or non-infringed, in the entire EU, rather than on a country-by-country basis: he still has to make business decisions before he knows the outcome of these questions].
Trade marks: while trade mark registration in the EU has been harmonised in Member States for almost 20 years and the Community trade mark was established 15 years ago, there is an increasing demand for more streamlined, effective and consistent registration systems. The Commission intends to present proposals in 2011 to modernise the trade mark system both at EU and national levels and adapt it to the Internet era [No surprise here either, given the recent publication of the Max Planck's study, commissioned by the Commission, on these very issues.  The point to note is that proposals are expected this year. The rumour at INTA this month was that proposals were more likely in the Spring of 2012 than in the previously-touted October 2011].
Geographical indications (GIs): GIs secure a link between a product's quality and its geographical origin. However, there is currently no such system available at EU level for the protection of non-agricultural products such as Carrara marble or Solingen knives [Indeed there isn't]. This leads to an unlevel playing field in the Single Market. The Commission will therefore carry out an in-depth analysis of the existing legal framework in the Member States as well as the potential economic impact of protection for non-agricultural GIs in 2011 and 2012 [This is important since, while the playing field is unlevel, there's not a lot of anecdotal evidence that people are playing on it. Evidence-based proposals would be good]. Depending on the outcome of an impact assessment, these could eventually be followed up by legislative proposals.
Multi-territorial copyright licensing: While the substantive scope of copyright has been largely harmonised, rights are still licensed on a national basis. In view of the digital Single Market, streamlining copyright licensing and revenue distribution is one of the most important challenges that must be addressed. In the 2nd half of 2011, the Commission will submit a proposal to create a legal framework for the efficient multi-territorial collective management of copyright, in particular in the music sector. It will also establish common rules on the transparent governance and revenue distribution. In the second half of 2011, the Commission will also launch a consultation on the various issues related to the online distribution of audiovisual works [A couple of points to note here: (i) any changes must comply with the Berne Convention requirements, or Berne itself must change; (ii) given the role of the internet in the sale and supply of musical and audiovisual products, the Commission must be mindful of the interface between EU licensing provisions and those of the rest of the world, given the fact that the internet remains doggedly international].
Digital libraries: The creation of European digital libraries that preserve and disseminate Europe's rich cultural and intellectual heritage is key to the development of the knowledge economy. To facilitate this, the Commission is also tabling today a legislative proposal that will enable the digitisation and online availability of so-called "orphan works" (works like books and newspaper or magazine articles that are still protected by copyright but where the right holders are not known or cannot be located to obtain copyright permissions) – see MEMO/11/333. Concurrently, the Commission looks forward to concluding a Memorandum of Understanding amongst libraries, publishers, authors and collecting societies to facilitate licensing solutions to digitise and make available out-of-commerce books [Merpel notes how carefully crafted this is, referring to old-fashioned things like newspapers and books which are heading for archives: the words 'photograph' and 'photographer' don't appear. Is there a reason why this might be so ...?].
IPR violations: [Usual statistics on infringement deleted] The Commission is set to intensify its efforts in this area. Firstly, the Commission has tabled a regulation today that is to reinforce the European Observatory on Counterfeiting and Piracy, which it launched in 2009, by entrusting its tasks to the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM). This will allow the Observatory to benefit from OHIM's intellectual property expertise and strong record of delivery in trade marks and designs. [The Kat remains totally baffled as to what the fact that OHIM delivers trade marks has to do with the war against infringements.  Midwives are great at delivering babies, but that doesn't qualify them to bring up children. Also, he has often heard businesses complaining about deficiencies in the way rights are enforced, by them by in the public sector, but in 15 years he has yet to hear any business say "If only we had a European Observatory!"] The Regulation now passes to the European Parliament and the Council for consideration. Secondly, in Spring 2012, the Commission will propose to revise the IPR Enforcement Directive (see IP/04/540). The Directive provides for civil law measures allowing right holders to enforce their intellectual property rights but should be adapted, in particular to meet the specific challenges of the digital environment.
IPR enforcement by customs: Customs supervise all trade crossing EU external borders: they carry out controls for many purposes and have an essential role in fighting the trade in IPR infringing goods. [Horror statistics omitted] Whilst the majority of goods intercepted are counterfeit or pirated, customs' unique position at the border allows for the enforcement of a wide range of intellectual property rights. As part of today's overall IPR strategy, the Commission also proposes a new customs regulation, to further reinforce the legal framework for customs' actions. The proposal also aims to tackle the trade in small consignments of counterfeit goods sent by post as the overwhelming majority of these goods results from internet sales." [The Kats struggle to see in these words anything like "The Commission proposes to make it possible for customs to seize counterfeit goods which are passing through the territory of the EU, even if the people who profit from this trade and those who purchase such goods have the good fortune to be outside the EU, especially where it's not that difficult for such goods to slip undetected into the European marketplace"].
Says Merpel, other proposals which are missing, in no particular order, are

  • Making the level playing field of the single European market even more level by annexing Switzerland;
  • Enabling providers of intellectual property legal services throughout the EU to compete more fairly with one another by ensuring that Court of Justice rulings and opinions, as well as OHIM Board of Appeal decisions, were available in all the major languages of the European Union;
  • Judicial decisions should be made uniform throughout the EU: French judgments should be more reasoned; German judgments should be less reasoned; English judgments should be shorter, and so on;
  • The Directorate-General for Competition should be disbanded and the control of all competition matters placed in the hands of Tesco or Lidl, these being among the few enterprises in Europe that really know about competition ...

Anne Hathaway Sexy Breasts with Exhibition

Here's Anne Hathaway sexy look .. really really enticing ..
Anne Hathaway looking especially with little to show the breasts daranya .. waOow .. Anne Hathaway turns .. milknya truly every man's dream, including me .. so ..! hahhaha ...
Anne Hathaway milknya perfect packing .. pass .. shape, color, smoothness ..









WOW .. Photos Syahrini Hot Latest

Naughty photos circulating on the Internet Syahrini

Jakarta recently Syahrini naughty photos circulating on the Internet. In one photo, breast chanter 'I'm Not Normal' is seen held by Daniel Mananta.

Syahrini is seen posing with three men, one of which Vj Daniel. In fact, Daniel seemW to hold breast Syahrini.
Besides Daniel, Syahrini also seemed to pose with the singer, Barry Manilow.

Not only that, in one of the photos seen former duet partner Anang Hermansyah is posed as if exhausted bath. Body and Hair Syahrini was wrapped in white towels.

Meanwhile, in another photo, Syahrini seen posing on the bed. She looks sexy wearing blue lingerie.
Some photos also show the younger brother as well as managers Syahrini, Aisyahrani. In fact, Rani photos look more bold. Rani looks're kissing with a man on the mattress.

Some photos sexy actress hot even the middle Syahrini clubbing with her ​​sister, Aisyahrani widespread on the internet. Approximately eight photos featuring former duet partner Anang Hermansyah was posing quite tempting even erotic.

Some photos show scenes Syahrini pose with a number of country artists, you name it Daniel or Daniel Mananta DJ and singer Barry Manilow. And a number of men and women who are not so publicly known.

The photo spread with the title 'Wild Hot Photos Scandal Syahrini clubbing Together Some Men' is also featured Daniel poses a hug right chest Syahrini. Other photos also appear Syahrini sister was kissing the lips with a man.

Kirana Larasati Foto Circulating on the Internet

Not to let up on the hot stories Hot Photos Mey Chan, again heard the news that circulated nude photos Lara Kirana. Even the nude photos has been circulating widely on the Internet and easily available. There are 2 kinds of Kirana pose in the nude photos. The first photo emperlihatkan she was photographed in a state of a place to sleep on her back wearing only underwear. In the photo, we can see that sexy body Kirana berbalutkan only a very minimal fashion. While the second photo looks he took it himself in a naked state. His breast he was covered with beautiful long hair that he sibakkan forward. This reminds us of Shireen Sungkar porn video some time ago.
To respond to this was unclear because of nude photos are indeed still very controversial. We know soap opera star in Isabela such as the girl who never aneh2 in attitude. Indeed there are indications that the nude photos Lara Kirana is just a manipulation of the prankster. At first glance looks a fine piece in the photo. This we can see the neck and other body parts. Not yet obtained separately from Kirana comments regarding the circulation of nude photos involving her name is.

Should the UDRP be reformed? Don't go there, says WIPO

The Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) of ICANN, which is binding for all registrars and, by virtue of being incorporated into the domain name registration agreement, on anyone registering a domain name in a generic top level domain (notably .com, .net and .org, the others play a small role), provides since 1999 for a dispute resolution process if a trade mark owner feels that a domain name infringes his rights. Assuming IPKat readers will be roughly familiar with the policy, I shall spare you the details (some background here).

ICANN is cautiously posing the question whether the UDRP should be reformed, and has received a resounding "NO, PLEASE DON'T" from WIPO. The main arguments of WIPO, as summarized in a Webinar held on 10 May 2011, are the following:

  • The UDRP has been offering an effective solution for trademark owners, domain name registrants, and registration authorities.
  • By accommodating evolving norms and practices, the UDRP has proven to be a flexible and fair dispute resolution system.
  • With vast DNS growth around the corner and untested new RPMs in development, the time is wrong to revise the UDRP.
  • Institutionally stacked, an ICANN revision process would likely end up overburdening and diluting the UDRP.
  • Fundamental questions about the business and DNS beneficiaries of cybersquatting must be addressed before targeting the very mechanism intended to address this practice.

Instead of allowing the UDRP to be placed in the dock, ICANN should first fairly address the following issues:
  • the relationship between cybersquatting and the activities, revenues and budgets of DNS actors; the incidence of UDRP cybersquatting findings in relation to wider trademark abuse in the DNS overall, with filed UDRP cases merely representing the tip of the iceberg; and
  • the degree of proportionality between trademark rights enforcement and domain name registration opportunities in the DNS.

From the user's side, Aimee Gessner, Senior Trademark Counsel at the BMW Group, adds:

  • The real problem is not the UDRP: Other practices since the launch of the UDRP in 1999 have contributed largely in encouraging cybersquatting:
  • Domain name tasting
  • Increasing domain parking sites / pay per click sites
  • Drop-catching
  • Use of privacy registration services to hide identities of cybersquatters
  • Establishment of bogus “registrars” that have no purpose other than to cybersquat

    • Summary:
      • The UDRP is working fairly and efficiently for its intended purpose
      • There are many other causes today for the steady increase in cybersquatting which ICANN should rather review
      • Brand owners are concerned at this time with what the expansion of the DNS will cause in terms of cybersquatting and other forms of rights infringement system at such a critical time
      • Unwise to review and possibly compromise UDRP system at such a critical time

Attorneys acting for complainants point out that the trade mark owners bear the entire cost of the UDRP system and suggest that a "loser pays" system may be fairer. Respondents warn against further streamlining a system that may cease to be considered fair.

The registrars have some technical issues with the UDRP, notably

  • The meaning of “Maintaining the Status Quo” in Section 7 is not clear: No explanation of “Legal Lock” mechanisms and when they go into effect or when they should be removed.
  • Policy does not provide guidance on what a registrar is to do if a claim is stayed or suspended: Is the legal lock to be removed or remain in place?
  • Policy does not address Privacy and Proxy Registrations or require complaining party to amend complaint once infringing party identified.
  • No explanation on what a registrar should do when a UDRP decision conflicts with an injunctive order issued by a of local jurisdiction.

It should be possible to implement these rather technical issues without breaking the system, this Kat thinks. As far as the message of WIPO is concerned, it couldn't be clearer: don't go there (they literally state this in an open letter to ICANN).

To boldly go .. LOCOG prepares to take on AdWords

The Locogosaurus engages with the
Googleraptor in a fight to the death for,
er, the right to tale other people's money
Don't despair -- if you own a beloved trade mark but can't stop those dreadful folk at Google selling it to enemy aliens as an AdWord, watch this space and see whether someone else can, this being the London Organising Committee of the Olympic Games (LOCOG).  According to the Kats' information,
"The London Organising Committee of the Olympic Games (LOCOG) will crack down on brands that breach its advertising restrictions online, including bidding against trade mark terms on Google, in the run-up to and during next year’s Olympic Games.

LOCOG heavily restricts the use of specific trade mark terms such as “London 2012”, “Olympic” and “Paralympic” in any marketing activity by anyone other than its commercial partners. These include Coca-Cola, McDonald’s and Visa. But competitor brands will be able to bid against these phrases on Google if the search engine maintains its current trade mark policy. For the past three years Google has allowed rival brands to buy trade mark terms.

LOCOG has yet to announce its formal online advertising policy ahead of the Games, but a spokesman told Marketing Week sister title New Media Age [which broke this story first] it was aware of Google’s trade mark rules. “We’re aware of the Google AdWords policy,” he said. “We take all attempts to ambush the London 2012 brand seriously and we deal with any incidents on a case-by-case basis.”

Since its decision to relax its rules, Google has come under fire from brands that say it’s breaking trade mark rules. However, last year the European Court of Justice (ECJ) said Google was doing no such thing [see the IPKat here, among other places]. Instead, in March this year the advocate general of the ECJ advised that it was advertisers themselves that should be found liable for trade mark infringement if they bought Google AdWords ads against rival trade marked brands [this sounds like the Interflora opinion, here].

Henry Ellis, Tamar associate director for social media, said brands must be careful if they associate themselves with the Games. “LOCOG and the Government are incredibly protective of the Olympic brand and would look to make an example of any advertiser that breaks their rules,” he said".
Thank you, veteran reader Lee Curtis, for the lead!

Source: "LOCOG to protect Olympic trademark search terms", by Will Cooper, Marketing Week, 11 May 2011

Monday, May 23, 2011

Small matter, big problem: the story of the average sized particle

Now where the deuce did that nanomouse go?
The IPKat has frequently been preoccupied with interesting questions that have no obvious answer. Classic examples include "how long is a piece of string?", "where do celebrities go when they want some privacy?" and "why aren't all the Court of Justice opinions and decisions translated into English?" Today he has been pondering a new question, thanks to a decision of a Technical Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office: "how big is an average sized particle?" This was the issue at the heart of T-1819/07 Nanosized catalyst/ GENERAL ELECTRIC, decided on 15 March 2011 but only now disturbing the Kat's grey cells.

Without going into too much detail, it appears that the claims in General Electric's patent application referred to a
"copper catalyst precursor selected from the group consisting of copper metal, copper (I) oxide, copper (II) oxide, copper (I) chloride, copper (II) chloride, copper (I) carboxylates, copper (II) carboxylates, other copper salts, and mixtures thereof, having an average particle size from about 0.1 to about 600 nanometers".
This would have been fine for the Kat, because he's not what the Americans call the PHOSITA (Pussycat having ordinary skill in the art) it's all the same to him where in the range of 0.1 to about 600 nanometers this average particle size happened to be.  However, since the claims did not unambiguously state either the type of average involved (volume, surface, number) or a method for determining it, the examiner was none too impressed and refused the application.

Dismissing GE's appeal, the Technical Board affirmed that the claims were unpatentable for lack of clarity. It rejected the argument that the necessary clarity was provided by a statement in the specification that the preferred embodiment was to use particles prepared according to the method of an identified co-pending patent application, which did contain a description of a method of measuring size. This was because the terms of that reference, relating only to the method of making the particles, did not make the disclosure of the method of measuring the particles' size part of the disclosure of the present application.

Wonders the IPKat. is this one of those miserable cases where we all really know what the applicant means but have to penalise him for not having clearly and explicitly said it? Or is it a case of a crafty applicant trying to gain a little extra edge over anyone putting the invention into effect by being less than specific? Merpel says,   I think this case is only being discussed here because it's about a Katalyst.

Nano stuff here
Nani stuff here
Nana stuff here