Showing posts with label epo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label epo. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Wednesday Whiskers

Miracles do happen, it seems. Despite several hurdles and a legislative calendar that was drowning in debt-related issues, the long-awaited US patent reform legislation passed the Senate vote on Monday. The Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA) was passed unamended by the US Senate with a 89-9 vote (see previous AmeriKat and IPKat posts here). Once signed into law by President Obama, the bill will introduce several changes to the US patent system including harmonizing its first-to-invent system to a first-to-file system and ending fee diversion. AIA has been criticized by many as being overly burdensome to small independent inventors, will increase the number of provisional applications being made to the USPTO and would allow the Appropriations Committee to unduly control the fees generated by the USPTO. USPTO Director David Kappos heralded the passage of the bill, claiming that it will "...drive down the backlog of patent applications, and expedite the issuance of high quality patents - all without adding a dime to the deficit." Director Kappos proceeded to then walk on water.... Joking aside, the AmeriKat is excited about this new act and will be back on Sunday to report on the fall-out and commentary surrounding its passage.



The Rolls Building is nearing its opening day. For those IP litigators, like this Kat, the new £300 million Rolls Building will soon become a home-away-from-home as the Patents Court moves from the resplendent Royal Courts of Justice to its new home. You needn't spend long in the RCJ chambers and filing offices to hear comments about the new building - a mixture of views mostly punctuated by comments of how small the court rooms are, how some are being dragged across to Fetter Lane kicking and screaming and how no one will know where anything is [cue wandering judges and barristers looking for their lost court rooms, Merpel remarks cattily]. Then there is the elevator problem - only 3 public lifts (i.e. fitting only one clerk with the first set of disclosure bundles for your standard Chancery case - promises of e-filing be damned). The AmeriKat is more worried that, as with many new buildings, the air conditioning system will be out of control and set on a level that only pacing barristers can endure. There are rumors floating around about who will be the first IP case to grace the Rolls Building, but no concrete word until the doors first open this fall. The IPKat says that whoever gets there first should give the rest of us tips about managing the new building - flaws, free wi-fi, and all!


8+3 =11 big problems for HathiTurst, a partnership of research libraries and universities, including the University of Michigan . On Monday, the 11 strong contingent of authors' groups and individual authors including the Authors Guild filed a copyright infringement suit in the Southern District of New York against the libraries and universities claiming that their initiative to digitize millions of books without authorization constituted copyright infringement and posting the books online. The claim also objects to the partnership self-designating works as "orphan works" and thus self-permitting the digitization and use of those works. So far 9.5 million books and journals have already been digitized with around 30% of those works being in the public domain. The twist in the story is that the executive director of the partnership, John Wilkin, stated that the digitized works were provided by Google. IPKat readers will remember that last March, Judge Denny Chin rejected the proposed settlement in the Google Books litigation (more here) in a similar dispute. A hearing is schedule for tomorrow in the Google Books case.


On Tuesday, IPR2, better known as the EU-China Project for the Protection of Intellectual Property Rights, between the European Commission, EPO, OHIM and the Ambassador of the People's Republic of China to the EU formally came to a close. The closing ceremony of IPR2 comes at the end of a four-year 16 million Euro joint project. Under IPR2 European and Chinese officials, judges, legislators, experts and academics implemented technical assistance and training activities across China. The parties have agreed to continue their cooperation [what else would you expect?, says Merpel] Would you like to see the what 4 years and 16 million Euros can get you? Well you can't, at least not yet... But while the database is being built, there is a collection of a hodge-podge of documents from the project here.


Many of the IPKat's beloved readers will be in or journeying to Baveno, Italy for this year's annual MARQUES conference (Kat Jeremy is currently stalking the Italian venue.) Today's MARQUES conference agenda, for those Kats and readers who are not so lucky to travel to Italy this week, is premised on "Reality Checks" - reality check on costs, reality check on trends and reality checks on function. The last check is a topic being discussed after lunch entitled "Reality Function" and is promoted as an "update on legal analysis on the trade mark function." For those attendees whose brain activity does not decrescendo following a hearty pasta and foccacia lunch, please let the Kat know what panel suggest is "the trade mark function" in European trade mark law.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

EPO: Filings rebound after crisis

The European Patent Office (EPO) announced its statistics for 2010 last Tuesday. After a slump in filings in 2009, the number of filings has rebounded and surpassed the pre-crisis level; in fact, the 235,000 applications received in 2010 constitute the largest number of applications filed ever in the 34-year history of the EPO.

43% of applications resulted in granted patents (obviously not of the applications filed in 2010...).

The number of patents granted per country of residence of the applicant also shows a familiar picture (see the IPKat's take on the 2009 statistics here). The top ten nations in terms of patents granted are Germany (12,553), USA (12,506), Japan (10,580), France (4,536), Switzerland (2,389), Italy (2,287), UK (1,857), the Netherlands (1,725), Sweden (1,467), South Korea (1,392) and Canada (730).

While granted patents are an imperfect measure of the innovative force of a country's economy (and the numbers for Japan and Germany inflated because of peculiar employee-invention laws), it is nonetheless striking how large the differences between similarly situated European countries can be. While France's population (65 million) and Gross Domestic Product ($ 2.5 trillion) are roughly 50% larger than Spain's (46 million and $ 1.4, acc. to CIA Factbook), France was granted 4,536 patents in 2010, while Spain (better: applicants from Spain) received a mere 393. That's less than 10% of France's rate. And don't tell me it's all due to the fact that Spanish is not an official language at the EPO... or compare Norway (4.7 million, $ 413 billion) to Switzerland (7.6 million, $ 522 billion). Both are well-off European nations with a similar per capita GDP. But Switzerland received 314 patents per 1 million inhabitants, Norway 39. Let's hope that oil lasts for a while...

Finally, the top ten applicants.


Many more tables and graphs on the EPO's website.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Small matter, big problem: the story of the average sized particle

Now where the deuce did that nanomouse go?
The IPKat has frequently been preoccupied with interesting questions that have no obvious answer. Classic examples include "how long is a piece of string?", "where do celebrities go when they want some privacy?" and "why aren't all the Court of Justice opinions and decisions translated into English?" Today he has been pondering a new question, thanks to a decision of a Technical Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office: "how big is an average sized particle?" This was the issue at the heart of T-1819/07 Nanosized catalyst/ GENERAL ELECTRIC, decided on 15 March 2011 but only now disturbing the Kat's grey cells.

Without going into too much detail, it appears that the claims in General Electric's patent application referred to a
"copper catalyst precursor selected from the group consisting of copper metal, copper (I) oxide, copper (II) oxide, copper (I) chloride, copper (II) chloride, copper (I) carboxylates, copper (II) carboxylates, other copper salts, and mixtures thereof, having an average particle size from about 0.1 to about 600 nanometers".
This would have been fine for the Kat, because he's not what the Americans call the PHOSITA (Pussycat having ordinary skill in the art) it's all the same to him where in the range of 0.1 to about 600 nanometers this average particle size happened to be.  However, since the claims did not unambiguously state either the type of average involved (volume, surface, number) or a method for determining it, the examiner was none too impressed and refused the application.

Dismissing GE's appeal, the Technical Board affirmed that the claims were unpatentable for lack of clarity. It rejected the argument that the necessary clarity was provided by a statement in the specification that the preferred embodiment was to use particles prepared according to the method of an identified co-pending patent application, which did contain a description of a method of measuring size. This was because the terms of that reference, relating only to the method of making the particles, did not make the disclosure of the method of measuring the particles' size part of the disclosure of the present application.

Wonders the IPKat. is this one of those miserable cases where we all really know what the applicant means but have to penalise him for not having clearly and explicitly said it? Or is it a case of a crafty applicant trying to gain a little extra edge over anyone putting the invention into effect by being less than specific? Merpel says,   I think this case is only being discussed here because it's about a Katalyst.

Nano stuff here
Nani stuff here
Nana stuff here