Showing posts with label US patent infringement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US patent infringement. Show all posts

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Breaking News: US Supreme Court rejects Microsoft in i4i battle

The AmeriKat has been a busy bee ever since her flight from California's INTA 2011 madness touched its wheel's onto Heathrow's tarmac two weeks ago. Since then the AmeriKat has watched helplessly as not one, not two, but three patent decisions rolled out of the US Supreme Court over the past few days. But thankfully, this evening AmeriKat was able to momentarily lift her whiskers from the stack of bundles and papers circulating her desk at the moment, to bring you breaking news of the US Supreme Court's decision in the epic battle between i4i and Microsoft (see previous AmeriKat reports here). She has not and will not have time to digest the yummy decision from Justice Sotomayor until the weekend, but she sets out below a brief summary of the court's decision. (picture, left - with no time for a Kat nap for this kitten, the AmeriKat rests her chin one of her stacks of papers)

Background

The four year epic patent infringement battle between Canadian software company, i4i, and Microsoft, involved i4i’s US Patent No 5.787, 449 (“449 Patent”) which related to markup languages and Extensible Markup Language (“
XML”) used in electronic documents. In 2007, i4i filed a patent infringement action against Microsoft in the Eastern District of Texas. Microsoft claimed that i4i's '449 patent was invalid because an earlier version of i4i’s software had anticipated the claim ("on-sale bar" under section 102(b) of the Patent Act 1952). However, this earlier software, S4, had been destroyed ten years prior to the case so the USPTO Patent Examiners never had the opportunity to examine the i4i’s patent application in light of this alleged prior art. Because the S4 data had been destroyed, Microsoft argued that they never had an opportunity to provide “clear and convincing evidence” of invalidity. The trial jury found in i4i’s favor, Microsoft appealed to the Circuit Court of Appeals who upheld the lower court’s finding and then appealed to the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The US Court of Appeals upheld the Circuit Court’s ruling and so Microsoft appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court granted certiorari in the case November 2010.

The Arguments

Microsoft argued that the evidential standard to invalidate a patent should be one of a “preponderance” and not of the higher “clear and convincing” standard. i4i argued that Section 282 (the section that deals with the burden of establishing invalidity)is not silent on the burden of proof requirement. It uses language that has a settled meaning - that of a “clear and convincing” standard which is itself settled by Federal Circuit and Supreme Court case law , i.e., section 282 codified the existing evidential standard. In addition, this heightened standard of proof has specifically been used in cases dealing with prior-use claims of invalidity, such Microsoft's claim in this case. Most of i4i's argument is devoted to the stronger underlying public policy argument of maintaining the heightened evidential standard, i.e., promoting strong and stable patent rights to protect the incentives for innovation and investment. A weaker standard, such as the preponderance standard, would arguably have the counter-effect as well as weakening the powers and judgment of the USPTO. (picture, left - Justice Sotomayor who delivered the opinion of the court)

The Question

The question before the Supreme Court was thus:


Under section 282 of the Patent Act of 1952, "[a] patent shall be presumed valid" and "[t]he burden of establishing invalidity of a patent or any claim thereof shall rest on the party asserting such invalidity." Does section 282 require that a defence of invalidity be proved by a "clear and convincing" standard or a "preponderance of the evidence" standard?
The Supreme Court's Answer

In an
unanimous decision (save for Justice Roberts who recused himself due to his ownership of some $100,000 in Microsoft shares), the "clear and convincing" standard is the standard of proof for a party to meet when arguing a defence of patent invalidity under section 282.

The Court held that Congress had indeed prescribed the governing standard of proof in section 282 - that of a clear and convincing standard. Although there was no express articulation of that standard in the statute itself, Congress did use a common-law term in the section, i.e. "presumed valid". Where Congress uses a common-law term in statute, then the Court must assume that the term "comes with a common law meaning" (Safeco Ins Co of America v Burr )(2007)). With this common law meaning comes "nearly a century of case law" where the courts have held that the presumption that a patent is valid should not be overthrown except by clear and cogent evidence. The Court found Microsoft's arguments that decisions prior to the 1952 Patent Act supported the clear and convincing standard were limited to only two instances and their arguements to be unpersuasive.

The Supreme Court also did not find favor with Microsoft's argument that a preponderance standard must apply where evidence was not before the PTO during the patent's examination process. Although the Court agreed that the rationale behind the presumption of validity for granted patents is weakened in such cases (KSR Int'l co v Teleflex), it nevertheless remains that Congress still specified the applicable standard of proof even in these circumstances. Nothing in section 282's text suggests that this standard should be departed from in these circumstances and indeed the Supreme Court has applied the clear and convincing standard irrespective of whether the prior-art evidence has been before the PTO examiner (Smith v Hall).

Despite both camps, especially i4i's, extensive policy arguments advancing their respective positions, the Supreme Court stated that the Court was in



"no position to judge the comparative force of the parties' policy arguments as to the wisdom of the clear-and-convincing evidence standard that Congress adopted."
In short - "we don't care, take your complaints to Congress." ["Love it!" - says the AmeriKat]

The Reaction

The real winner in this case is not i4i itself, but patent owners generally (including you, Microsoft!) and of course the
USPTO who can continue to glow under their crown of "assumed validity".

However, patent owners want strong patents that are able to withstand weak invalidity challenges, but they also want to ensure that bad patents are able to be easily invalidated, especially when prior-art evidence is not in front of the examiner during examination proceedings. Microsoft was therefore essentially arguing for and against their interests at the same time - an impossible task that looked destined to fail at some point.

In a statement, Microsoft
stated that


“While the outcome is not what we had hoped for, we will continue to advocate for changes to the law that will prevent abuse of the patent system.”
Now it remains to be seen how i4i will spend their
$290 million damages award

For more information please see this article in the Financial Times.

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Letter from AmeriKat: From Sea to Shining Sea

The AmeriKat was travelling again this past week. Irrespective of the past 25 years of frequent flying transatlantic-ally, continentally, transpacific-ally, and more, she is always surprised to find herself in a completely new location after seemingly no time at all. Leaving behind one established life and role and trading it in for a new role, set of contacts and friends has always given the AmeriKat a bit of a thrill. She can discard her "American lawyer in London" role when she steps off the plane in Dallas and just be someone welcomed home by immigration officials. Entering immigration in other ports her role is constantly transformed by a stamp in the passport to tourist, visiting family, attending a conference, here for business, or "living and working here". The only constant in these travels, from country to country and coast to coast, is her trusty Coach luggage, who has seen her across hundreds of thousands of miles, over-head bins and immigration authorities and is the subject of her first story this week.

Jo-Ann Fabrics sued for infringing fabric by Coach

In most isolated strip malls in U.S. cities from sea to shining sea, usually in between a dry-cleaners and a cell-phone retailer, is a Jo-Ann Fabrics where soccer-moms, crafters, and all in between go to purchase a multitude of fabrics, zippers, buttons and threads. Last Monday, Jo-Ann Fabrics was sued for trade mark, trade dress and copyright infringement in Chicago federal court by New York-based high-end leather goods manufacturer and AmeriKat favorite, Coach. Coach is complaining about a fleece fabric being sold by Jo-Ann Fabrics in store and on-line which is infringing Coach's signature "C" trade mark, associated trade dress rights and copyright in the signature "C" trade mark design (picture, right). Coach is asking the court for $2 million per each infringing mark, additional damages, attorney fees, and an injunction restraining future sales of the infringing product.

The "C" trade mark and insignia is on several of Coach's signature lines of bags, wallets, belts, shoes, hats, scarves and the lining therein and was registered as a U.S. trade mark in September 2002. You can even spot the AmeriKat in Holborn by the violet Coach scarf with the trade mark double "C" pattern that she carries on her Coach bag. However, the "C" insignia and pattern is a prime target for counterfeiters and counterfeit Coach bags (see AmeriKat report on previous action taken by Coach in Chicago) and the market is rife with copycats. According to the complaint Coach sells more than $3 billion products annually and has filed more than 500 trade mark infringement suits since 2010.

According to the complaint the fabric (picture, left) was designed and supplied to Jo-Ann Fabric by the named co-defendant, Feldman Co. and together with Jo-Ann Fabric are accused by Coach of trying to benefit from the "incalcuable goodwill" associated with Coach's C trade mark by selling the allegedly infringing fabric. Coach also argue that consumers will be confused as to the source of the fabric - the AmeriKat does not disagree, but there are some differences between the two fabrics. The "C"s on Jo-Ann's Fabric fabric are almost closed, looking more like "O"s than the clearly differentiated "C"s on Coach's fabric. The AmeriKat believes these differences not to be fatal and also believes that although a consumer would be able to recognize the difference after closer study of the fabric, initial interest confusion is nevertheless present.

Had the Amerikat seen the fabric in a Jo-Ann's Fabrics store her immediate reaction would first be "Why is Coach allowing their signature print fabric to be sold in Jo-Ann's Fabrics?"- a reaction that goes first to the pure dilution argument as argued by the complaint. Her next reaction would be one dealing with tarnishment of the mark - "Why is Coach allowing their signature print fabric to be printed on fleece and sold in Jo-Ann fabrics?". As far as the AmeriKat knows from the Coach range, they have never used their signature print on fleece - a fabric that is not associated with the up-market silk and leather ranges produced by Coach. Of note Jo-Ann Fabrics does sell fabrics with trade mark names and logos, namely for major league sports teams such as the New York Yankees and licensed fabrics from Disney. The AmeriKat does not anticipate this case going all that far and expects it to settle quite quickly given the similarity of the designs and strength of reputation in Coach's mark, however it acts as a warning to fabric buyers not to skate so closely to the edge of trade mark infringement.

Organic farmers sue Monsanto over genetically modified seeds

From Illinois to New York now. Two weeks ago, the Public Patent Foundation (PUBPAT), a non-for profit legal services organization based out of the Cardozo School of Law, filed a pre-emptive lawsuit in Manhattan federal court on behalf of 60 plaintiff family farmers, seed businesses and organic agricultural organizations against agricultural biotechnology company Monsanto challenging their patents on genetically modified seed. The lawsuit was pre-emptive in order to protect the class from anticipated patent infringement suits should their crops ever be contaminated by Monsanto's genetically modified seed. The AmeriKat has read about the 60 plaintiffs and noted that they included three farmers and seed producers from her home state of New Mexico, Chispas Farms, in Albuquerque, Jardin del Alma from Monticello and farmer Paul Romero from Espanola - a reminder that patent litigation does not just impact big businesses in Silicon Valley, but your neighbors.

PUBPAT's Executive Director and law lecturer at the Cardozo School of Law, Dan Ravicher, stated that the case
"asks whether Monsanto has the right to sue organic farmers for patent infringement if Monsanto's transgenic seed should land on their property. It seems quite perverse that an organic farmer contaminated by transgenic seed should be accused of patent infringement, but Monsanto has made such accusations before and is notorious for having sued hundreds of farmers for patent infringement, so we had to act to protect the interests of our clients."
For anyone who has seen Food, Inc., you will be aware about such legal issues involving Monsanto (click here for an excerpt of Food, Inc. about Monsanto) and the case of Percy Schmeiser. Genetically modified seed are alleged to contaminate and destroy organic seeds when they enter organic crops. Further, legally speaking, as with what happened with Schmeiser, when genetically modified seed enters a neighbouring crop and grows and/or cross pollinates with a farmer's crop the farmer can be held to be infringing the patent of that seed. PUBPAT is thus asking the court to declare that if organic farmers are contaminated by Monsanto's seed they need not fear of being threatened with patent infringement proceedings.

PUBPAT are also arguing that Monsanto's genetically modified patents for seeds are invalid because they do not meet the "usefulness" criteria under section 101 of the Patent Act. An invention is "useful" under section 101 if it is capable of providing some identifiable benefit. The complaint cites Justice Story's dicta in Lowell v Lewis (1817) which stated that inventions that are "injurious to the well being, good policy, or sound morals of society" are unpatentable. Ravicher's argument is that genetically modified seed has negative economic and health effects, and the promised benefits and usefulness of the seed, namely increased production and decreased herbicide use, are false. (picture, right - alfalfa)

Monsanto stated that the lawsuit was a "publicity stunt" and that Monsanto is committed to never suing farmers over the inadvertent presence of their genetically modified seed in their fields - (the AmeriKat wonders how does one even prove or disprove inadvertent presence of GM seeds?) Monsanto also stated that the validity of their patents was without question and supported by legal precedent. Monsanto stated that:
"The plaintiffs' approach is a publicity stunt designed to confuse the facts about American agriculture. These efforts seek to reduce private and public investment in the development of new higher-yielding seed technologies. This attack comes at a time when the world needs every agricultural tool available to meet the needs of a growing population, expected to reach 9 billion people by 2050. While we respect the views of organic farmers as it relates to the products they choose to grow, we don't believe that American agriculture faces an all-or-nothing approach."
The suit comes soon after the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) fully deregulated genetically modified strains of alfalfa. The USDA has also allowed farmers to plant genetically modified sugar beets without restrictions while it completes its Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) on that crop. The timing of the lawsuit suggests that the plaintiffs groups may feel that the time is right to take action before an increasing number of GM crops are deregulated by the USDA and before the alleged impacts of GM crops on organic crops become more serious.

The AmeriKat will be watching this fight with anticipation. Although it is unlikely that PUBPAT will be able to create much of a dent in such a powerful organization, like Monsanto, she is interested in any attempt to try to address the balance of power created by the patent system in the agricultural industry. But what do readers think - is it a hopeless publicity stunt, or are the invalidity arguments with merit?

The AmeriKat recommends this recent interesting article by Anna Lappe in The Atlantic about the issues surrounding GM, Monsanto and food production.

Byrne settles with Crist over Talking Heads song use

From New York, we fly south to Florida where Florida's former Governor Charlie Crist settled (picture, left) a copyright infringement lawsuit last week brought against him by Talking Heads' David Byrne after Crist used the 1985 Talking Heads's song "Road to Nowhere" in a political attack ad during his Senate campaign last year. Crist's campaign failed to seek permission from Byrne, the Talking Heads or Warner Brothers when they used the song in the Senate campaign video published on YouTube attacking Crist's Republican opposition, Marco Rubio. Byrne sued Crist for $1 million. Byrne said last year that the lawsuit was
"not about politics...It's about copyright and about the fact that it does imply that I would have licensed it and endorsed him and whatever he stands for."
Rubio himself was also on criticized for using The Steve Miller Band's "Take the Money and Run" in an attack ad against Crist. Rubio, however, was not sued. AmeriKat readers may recall past political song problems, such as in 2008 when Jackson Browne sued then presidential candidate John McCain for unauthorized use of his song "Running on Empty". Browne's lawyer, Lawrence Iser, also represented Byrne and stated in the initial complaint that it was "extraordinary" for another Republican campaign to misappropriate another artists's work without permission.

Another lesson that party politics and rock music do not mix.