Showing posts with label Hargreaves review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hargreaves review. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Digital Opportunity Knocks ...

Yesterday was the hors d'oeuvres, today the main course -- and in the future we will no doubt receive our just desserts. The IPKat is of course talking about something that has been giving us food for thought for some time, something which many individuals and organisations have found hard to stomach, at least in prospect: the British government's response to Digital Opportunity, the somewhat rushed review of some bits of IP in the digital era by Professor Ian Hargreaves and his colleagues [IPKat summary of the Top Ten recommendations here; responses to Hargreaves here and here; Parliament debates Hargreaves here].

Yesterday's hors d'oeuvres was the report in the Guardian with the headline "Vince Cable: government plans to block illegal filesharing sites unworkable: Business secretary to intervene in Digital Economy Act debate in speech and expected to overhaul restrictive rules on file copying". It predicted confidently:
"Vince Cable, the business secretary, will say on Wednesday that government plans to block illegal filesharing websites under the controversial Digital Economy Act are in effect unworkable.

Outlining the government's response to the Hargreaves report on the future of UK copyright law, Cable is also expected to announce legislation to sweep away restrictive rules on file copying and parody works. ...

Cable will row back on one of the act's most contentious measures – introducing legislation to block access to copyright-infringing websites – and instead suggest that the existing Copyrights, Design and Patents Act is powerful enough.

That follows last week's landmark high court ruling [noted by the IPKat here and by the 1709 Blog here], which forced BT to cut off access to Newzbin2, a site found to be infringing copyright "on a grand scale".

Cable's intervention comes as ministers struggle to implement anti-piracy measures outlined by the Digital Economy Act rushed through by the Labour party at the end of its time in office.

The first warning letters to be sent to Britons accused of illegal filesharing are now not due until the second half of 2012 – more than a year later than originally planned.

A series of legal challenges have meant that cutting off the internet connections of serial pirates is unlikely to begin until 2013 at the earliest.

Cable is also expected to announce a "scoping review" into the viability of a setting up a digital copyright exchange [which will "never happen", per Andrew Orlowski, in The Register], one of the key proposals of the Hargreaves report published in May – in effect kicking the idea into the long grass. ...

Would protection of parodies and spoofs
extend to humorous and out-of-context
deployment of artwork, such as an
'Opportunity Knocks' photo to illustrate
the title of this blogpost?
The government is anticipated to legislate to sweep away many of the UK's archaic intellectual property restrictions that make it technically illegal to transfer content from CDs or DVDs to other formats, such as iPods. The reforms will also make it legal for Britons to burn copies of music and video files for family members to use, and give legal protection to spoof works [They already have protection as original copyright works: this refers to protection from the owner of the 'spoofed'(?) work]. ...

Cable is expected to outline further changes to the DEA, including how costs are apportioned between rights holders and ISPs. The judicial review ruled in April that ISPs should not foot the bill for setting up an appeals body....".
Today, the Intellectual Property Office has posted on its website the news that the government accepts all ten of Hargreaves' recommendations. The full response can be downloaded, parodied and file-shared here. According to the operative parts of the accompanying press release
"... Ministers have accepted the recommendations made in an independent review which estimate a potential benefit to the UK economy of up to £7.9 billion.

... Announcing the Government's response to the review, Business Secretary Vince Cable said:
"The Government is focused on boosting growth and the Hargreaves review highlighted the potential to grow the UK economy. By creating a more open intellectual property system it will allow innovative businesses to develop new products and services which will be able to compete fairly in the UK's thriving markets for consumer equipment. 
We are accepting the recommendations and will now set about reforming the UK's intellectual property systems. Opening up intellectual property laws can deliver real value to the UK economy as well as the creators and consumers."
Among the recommendations that have been accepted are:
Get your digits exchanged here!
  • The UK should have a Digital Copyright Exchange; a digital market place where licences in copyright content can be readily bought and sold. The review predicted that a Digital Copyright Exchange could add up as much as £2 billion a year to the UK economy by 2020. A feasibility study will now begin to establish how such an exchange will look and work. The Government will announce arrangements for how this work will be driven forward later in the year [This Kat bets it will cost more to run, in terms of setting up and administering the system, legal advice and uncertainty among rights owners and prospective users, than it will ever save or earn -- unless it could conveniently have extraterritorial effect so that holders of copyright licences who put licensed material online won't end up being sued in France, for example, for copyright infringement]. 
  • Copyright exceptions covering limited private copying should be introduced to realise growth opportunities. Thousands of people copy legitimately purchased content, such as a CD to a computer or portable device such as an IPod, assuming it is legal. This move will bring copyright law into line with the real world, and with consumers’ reasonable expectations [Whether this proposal is enacted or not is unlikely to make much difference in terms of the £7.9 billion potential boost to the British economy, since it only legalises what people already do and don't get sued for]. 
  • Copyright exceptions to allow parody should also be introduced to benefit UK production companies and make it legal for performing artists, such as comedians, to parody someone else's work without seeking permission from the copyright holder. It would enable UK production companies to create programmes that could play to their creative strengths, and create a range of content for broadcasters. [While the Kat is pleased with this, he wonders how much of an economic impact it's likely to make. Are there any sums? How much is spent in negotiating licences to parody a work under the existing law?]
  • The introduction of an exception to copyright for search and analysis techniques known as 'text and data mining'. Currently research scientists such as medical researchers are being hampered from working on data because it is illegal under copyright law to do this without permission of copyright owners. The Wellcome Trust have said that 87 per cent of the material housed in the UK's main medical research database is unavailable for legal text and data mining, that is despite the fact that the technology exists to carry out this analytical work. [The recommendations don't explain what exactly is meant by this term, so readers should refer to the original Hargreaves review, which they may find more helpful than the more technical Wikipedia entry for it]
  • Establishing licensing and clearance procedures for orphan works (material with unknown copyright owners). This would open up a range of works that are currently locked away in libraries and museums and unavailable for consumer or research purposes. []
  • That evidence should drive future policy [this isn't a finding, but a mantra which has been chanted regularly since the Gowers Review in 2006]- The Government has strengthened the Intellectual Property Office's economics team and has begun a programme of research to highlight growth opportunities. One report has already shown that investments made by businesses in products and services that are protected by intellectual property rights (IPRs) are worth £65 billion a year [This isn't evidence, this is speculative maths. The government should make it plain that it is willing to entertain factual evidence even if it is presented by representative bodies and make it plain that it won't be barred from consideration as an exercise in "lobbynomics". Some groups -- Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises among them -- don't have the resources to spend their time endlessly compiling evidence for government reviews, reports and initiatives].
Alongside the Government response, a new intellectual property crime strategy [which in the long term is probably far more important than the headline-hitting news about home copying] and international strategy for intellectual property have been published.

The crime strategy outlines how the Intellectual Property Office will continue to enforce IP crime issues domestically. Counterfeit goods often use other company’s trade marks or infringe their copyright, which can lead to financial losses. The international strategy sets out the UK's five year vision to get the international IP framework in the best possible shape to support innovation and growth. Patent backlogs cost the global economy up to £7.4 billion a year" [This Kat has always taken a cynical view of assessments of how much the patent backlog costs the global economy -- though that's not a reason for leaving things as they are. Patent Prosecution Highways, shared examinations, and applicants filing more intelligible applications can all contribute to this].
This Kat will be pleased to hear readers' responses. He plans a follow-up -- and he won't be surprised at all if his fellow Kats plan to do some blogging of their own on this hot topic.

Some landmarks in the Land of Digital Opportunity
Ofcom's first consultation on the "three strikes" approach to file-sharers here
Proposal on how to split enforcement costs between ISPs and copyright owners here
Attempt by BT and TalkTalk to get a judicial review of the Digital Economy Act 2010 here
Newport State of Mind here and here

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Summer surprise -- British MPs to debate IP today

Here's a piece of hot news for a hot, sticky summer's day: the United Kingdom's Alliance Against IP Theft has just told the IPKat that a parliamentary debate on IP and the Hargreaves Review will take place at 14.30pm in Westminster Hall today.

The debate was secured by the All Party IP Group Vice Chair, former Runrig star and current Scottish Nationalist Pete Wishart MP, and is an opportunity for Members of Parliament from across the political spectrum (i) to highlight the contribution IP-rich industries make to jobs and UK economic growth, in their constituencies and across the country [difficult, but not impossible, says Merpel], and (ii) to ensure Minsters are aware of potential unintended consequences of some of the Hargreaves recommendations before the Government response is published this summer [Hmm. Better get Wallace and Gromit onside first ..  One Minister who presumably will have to listen through the keyhole is the Minister for IP, Baroness Wilcox, who does not sit in the House of Commons]. 

There's more to come:
Ahead of the debate, Vice Chair of the All Party IP Group, Pete Wishart MP, said:
“This is a very important debate and I am delighted to have secured it on behalf of the 2.7 million people whose jobs depend on the creative industries alone and countless others whose livelihoods depend on IP in other ways. It is great that the Government is taking a keen interest in IP but I am concerned that so many issues relating to IP seem to be piling up in the Government’s inbox at the moment, from the implementation crucial sections of the Digital Economy Act, to its response to Hargreaves. This debate is a chance for the Government to hear our concerns and reassure the House that its response will be accompanied by a clear action plan and allow for proper consultation.”
Susie Winter, Director General of the Alliance Against IP Theft said:
“UK IP law has proved excellent in supporting existing business transfer into the digital world and also allow for new digital entrants to the market. However, counterfeiting and piracy remain a huge drain on investment, creativity and innovation and, crucially, jobs. It is therefore very encouraging to see MPs from all sides of the House interested in this issue and keen to put their points to Ministers.”
The Westminster Hall debate takes place between 1430 and 1730 today.  Sadly, this Kat is spending a large chunk of that time being deliciously fed and watered.  He therefore urges readers who might be in the vicinity (i) to attend, and (ii) to email him their recollections and opinions, using the subject line "IP in Parliament".  Debates on IP in Parliament are about as rare as speeches by Gromit ...

Monday, May 30, 2011

Hargreaves: some further thoughts and comments

The sad fate of British reviews of intellectual property
The dust has not yet settled on Digital Opportunity: a review of intellectual property and growth (the main recommendations of which are noted here), the fabled Hargreaves Review of how to make money from your own intellectual property and other people's, so it's high time for a brief round-up of responses to it (an earlier review of very swift responses to Hargreaves was posted on the 1709 Blog here).

Duncan Calow (partner and digital media specialist, DLA Piper) expressed relief the fact that there wasn't anything hugely radical in it:
“Suggestions that Professor Hargreaves would propose sweeping new changes in copyright law have proved to be nonsense. Instead he has chosen to revisit some of the more sensible proposals from previous work. As a journalist and academic, Professor Hargreaves knows that in a digital world of clouds, networks and user-generated content we are all both users and owners of digital rights [This Kat, who has had some experience of both academe and journalism, wonders whether -- though there be exceptions -- both groups benefit more from free and easy access to others' works than from the protection of their own]. So despite the talk of copyright wars, fair and effective rules require thoughtful and proportionate change, not hyperbole".
His partner Simon Levine however added a word of caution, based on the fact that the internet is global, copyright is fraught with international obligations, but anything the UK even thinks of doing is going to be somewhat parochial unless everyone else does it too:
“...  if businesses are ever going to be able to fully exploit the opportunities that the internet offers as a global channel to market, it is essential that we focus on how international IP laws can be harmonised accordingly. This is acknowledged in the report ... The Hargreaves report contains some very sensible and well-considered proposals. However, it remains to be seen how these will be translated at an international level – and it is this that will dictate its true impact” [It's not just a question of international law, says the Kat, it's a question of diplomacy: for as long as it's profitable for rogue states to remain rogue states, the problems will be shifted around but not eliminated].
More caution comes from the Federation Against Software Theft (FAST), which was not slow to express concern over the uncertainty of what exactly will be taken forward and how quickly.
"Key findings of the Report include the suggestion of a ‘Digital Copyright Exchange’, where the intention is to promote growth by having an efficient, open and effective digital market where rights can be can be speedily licensed and effectively protected. The intention is noble. However, it is yet to be seen how this could work in practice or whether it is intended or even desirable for the software industry to participate [The software industry in Europe has a modified statutory version of the digital copyright exchange, says Merpel -- it's called the interoperability and reverse engineering provisions of the Software Directive. The software industry wasn't given much of a choice as to whether to participate, but doesn't seem to have died from it]. : 
A more telling cautionary note from FAST comes from its contrasting the recommendations of Hargreaves with those of its predecessor, the Gowers Review:
“In 2006, Gowers recommended that the enforcement regime should be ‘effective and dissuasive’ and arguably it is not when simply a licence fee can be paid if an infringer is caught on the hop; the Gowers sentiment should not be forgotten. [It hasn't been forgotten, says Merpel. It has been ignored]”
The metaphor of "destinations without routes" is that chosen by Andrew Sharples (partner and head of EIP Life) to epitomise Hargreaves in his review here. The Review acknowledges that it is “focused upon the main issues, at the risk of ignoring important points of detail” -- but the main issues have to be seen as targets that can somehow be achieved: the detail helps us understand how to get there as well as letting us know which recommendations are too ambitious to be achieved at all. He too focuses on the Digital Copyright Exchange (DCE), which would be
" ... a common, standardised platform for licensing works. ... However, the Review also acknowledges that to encourage uptake there will need to be disadvantages to not being part of the exchange; suggestions include greater damages for infringement of works included in the exchange; applying sanctions under the Digital Economy Act only in relation to works included in the exchange; giving creators the right to withdraw from publishing agreements where the publishers do not place works on the exchange; and perhaps most controversially, treating works not placed on the exchange as “orphan works” ... [Expect an avalanche of holiday snaps and wedding photos if this idea ever gets accepted, warns Merpel] The Review does not advocate that the government creates the DCE (so as to avoid “a nightmare of IT procurement followed by the birth of a white elephant”) but instead brings together interested parties to find ways of overcoming divergent interests. How these divergent interests are to be overcome is not clear though, and almost as soon as the Review was published criticisms were made of the viability of this proposal. Certainly the goal of establishing the DCE by the end of 2012 seems optimistic".
Orphan works also come in for his attention. Can the UK do its own thing regarding such works, given that works 'freed up' for use under emancipating legislation may still be regarded as infringing copyright everywhere else in the world:
"The problem of orphan works, i.e. works for which the rights holder cannot be identified, is addressed, the suggestion being that after a diligent search to locate the owner, orphan works should be deemed to be licensable for a nominal fee. This would free up the use of large bodies of works in the national archives. However, it is suggested that a diligent search would simply require checking if a right is contained in the DCE, and, if not, treating it as an orphan work. This could effectively introduce a requirement for copyright registration, and it is questionable whether this would be consistent with the UK’s obligations under the Berne Convention to provide copyright without a registration requirement [Article 5(2) of the Berne Convention states that "The enjoyment and the exercise of these rights shall not be subject to any formality". Merpel says, I'm no lawyer and I'm pretty informal -- but this looks like a formality to me ...]".
A more encouraging view of the DCE comes from Maxine Horn (CEO of Creative Barcode -- a company that neither creates new designs nor uses other people's, but provides digital watermarking by which use of designs can be monitored and licensing thus rendered more effective). After analysing the proposal she concludes:
"A Digital Copyright Exchange implemented in a robust whilst non-complex manner would serve the creative industries and innovation focused businesses very well. Those who feel that an open-source or ‘freeconomy’ based on free access to use, replicate, re-mix or build on others knowledge and work is the only route to innovation growth are perhaps not considering the rights of the creative industries to earn a living from their original works. IP, particularly pre-commercialised, does not need to be restrictive to be effective [This is the problem, says the Kat: we all know what 'restrictive' means, but 'effective' carries no single shared meaning -- and we're talking about the conflicting interests here]. A fair model that recognises respects and remunerates the professional idea generators, creators and solution-led creative consultancies should surely open up innovation not restrict it".
Creative Barcode gets a nod in the Forbes Blog's comment on Hargreaves, "Copyright and Related Laws Hold Back Innovation and Growth, Say British", which views the UK from a distant US perspective and says:
"This is not exactly a call for a new type of creative commons, though CC licensing has clearly aided the growth of services like Flickr and platforms like WordPress. What the British want to see is a Digital Copyright Exchange, a market where digital rights can be processed rapidly and cheaply [Says Merpel, processing digital rights sounds a bit like an exercise in commodifying IP. Have humans and their feelings been eliminated somewhere along the line?]".
The IPKat remains committed to keeping an eye on Hargreaves. If anything exciting comes of it, he will do his best to let you know.

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Hargreaves in the wild: The Top 10 Recommendations

Drum-roll please: the Report that we have all been waiting for since a cold November morning on a roundabout in Shoreditch has entered the wild. Entitled “Digital Opportunity”, complete with a picture that Adobe tells me is “cover image showing digital studio” (although it fails to mention that this has been mixed with what looks like a photo of the inside of a PC - still, it beats a lightbulb), the Report weighs in at 130 pages, split into 11 chapters and four appendices.

The work of another Hargreaves –
which is the more apt descriptor of the report?
The choice is yours…
For those short of time, the Executive Summary begins on page 3 and ends on page 9. There are 10 recommendations (pages 8 & 9) running the gamut from International Priorities through Copyright issues to Patent Thickets and the Enforcement of IP.

The Executive Summary notes that:
“Taken together, the Review proposes a clear change in the strategic direction of IP policy direction designed to ensure that the UK has an IP framework best suited to supporting innovation and promoting economic growth in the digital age. This change is modest in ambition and wholly achievable.

The Review’s specific recommendations would support growth of the UK’s increasingly intangibles intensive economy. This requires:
  • an efficient digital copyright licensing system, where nothing is unusable because the rights owner cannot be found;
  • an approach to exceptions in copyright which encourages successful new digital technology businesses both within and beyond the creative industries;
  • a patent system capable of preventing heavy demand for patents causing serious barriers to market entry in critical technologies;
  • reliable and affordable advice for smaller companies, to enable them to thrive in the IP intensive parts of the UK economy;
  • refreshed institutional governance of the UK’s IP system which enables it to adapt organically to change in technology and markets.”
So what, I hear you ask, are these recommendations? Well, apart from a couple of rather bland statements that: the “Government should ensure that development of the IP System is driven as far as possible by objective evidence”, as opposed, for example, to simply making things up; and “The UK should resolutely pursue its international interests in IP, particularly with respect to emerging economies such as China and India, based upon positions grounded in economic evidence”, the unified EU Patent Court gets a significant endorsement – the Report stating that the Government should “attach the highest immediate priority” to achieving this aim.

Copyright is, as expected, singled out for more extensive developmental opportunity, to coin a phrase. Appointment of a senior figure to oversee the design and implementation of a “cross sectoral Digital Copyright Exchange” framework is suggested (nominations in the comments section please), as is Government support of moves by the European Commission to establish a framework for cross border copyright licensing.

The work of another Hargreaves –
which is the more apt descriptor of the report?
The choice is yours…
Orphan works are also included in the review, with suggestions that the Government should establish extended collective licensing for mass licensing of orphan works, and a clearance procedure for use of individual works. Copyright clearance clearly being the name of the game as far as the Report is concerned.

Continuing the Copyright theme, the Report also suggests that the “Government should deliver copyright exceptions at national level to realise all the opportunities within the EU framework, including format shifting, parody, non-commercial research, and library archiving. The UK should also promote at EU level an exception to support text and data analytics.” For those that are wondering, the wholly fictitious Parody Act of 1852 gets nary a mention (much to Merpel’s consternation).

In the Patent field, the problem of thickets and other obstructions to innovation are the focus of the Report’s ire. With this in mind, the Government is advised to take “a leading role in promoting international efforts to cut backlogs and manage the boom in patent applications by further extending “work sharing” with patent offices in other countries. It is also advised to be vigilant in ensuring that “patents are not extended into sectors, such as non-technical computer programs and business methods, which they do not currently cover, without clear evidence of benefit” – ‘not just for the sake of it’ is a theme running throughout the Report. Finally on the patent side of things, if the Government acts on the proposals then it looks like fees are to rise, as the Report advises the Government to:
“investigate ways of limiting adverse consequences of patent thickets, including by working with international partners to establish a patent fee structure set by reference to innovation and growth goals rather than solely by reference to patent office running costs. The structure of patent renewal fees might be adjusted to encourage patentees to assess more carefully the value of maintaining lower value patents, so reducing the density of patent thickets.”
Designs are not neglected either. The Report suggesting that the IPO should, in the next 12 months, “conduct an evidence based assessment of the relationship between design rights and innovation, with a view to establishing a firmer basis for evaluating policy at the UK and European level”.

The work of another Hargreaves –
which is the more apt descriptor of the report?
The choice is yours…
Despite coming at number 8 in the list, the section on Enforcement of IP rights is noted to contain some “urgent” recommendations. The enforcement regime set out in the Digital Economy Act 2010 (DEA), that much-beloved piece of legislation swept out of Parliament’s door in the wash-up just before its dissolution last year, is targeted for specific monitoring when it comes into force next year. Hargreaves noted that this is “urgent and Ofcom should not wait until [the provisions enter into force] …to establish its benchmarks and begin building data on trends.” The Report also suggests the introduction of “a small claims track for low monetary value IP claims in the Patents County Court” in order to support rights holders in enforcing their rights.

The final two recommendations concern suggestions that the IPO seek to facilitate improvements in the accessibility of the IP system for small companies, and that it “be given the necessary powers and mandate in law to ensure that it focuses on its central task of ensuring that the UK’s IP system promotes innovation and growth through efficient, contestable markets”, including the power to provide “statutory opinions where these would help to clarify copyright law.”

If the recommendation is followed, we can also expect to see an impact report on the measures advocated by the review at some point in 2013.

Summary over, this Kat is now off to read the report in a little more detail.

Update: as the IPKat's friend Mary-Ellen Field has pointed out, the fictitious Act of 1852 is not the only thing to have nary a mention in the Report: she notes that "the words 'trade' and 'marks' are not mentioned" either.

Monday, February 28, 2011

The system's fine, but where's the money?

Much loved by innovative SMEs:
the Loan Arranger
In a thoughtful and much-commented piece hosted by the IPKat on Friday ("Pioneers, Pirates and Parvenus – IP v Innovation", here), Gwilym Roberts -- who attended one of the Hargreaves Review meetings last week -- made some valuable observations about the "problem" of the IP system being not so much the system itself but the failure of funding to back innovative projects. To this, Mary Ellen Field adds some highly pertinent comments of her own:
"It is very sad that there was little input from SMEs at the meeting last week, but not at all surprising. SMEs are trying to keep their heads above water when the banks won't lend and they are often fighting off attacks on their IP from counterfeiters and larger well funded companies with clever aggressive lawyers. They are in my opinion effectively excluded from the Hargreaves report by virtue of the makeup of the panel and the language used. It might also be because they think IP Law in the UK is fine and that they don't have the time nor the money to navel-gaze

I tried very hard to be allowed to attend that session this week and I believe I had a lot to offer. I am not a lawyer or an academic but I have been successfully managing, protecting and exploiting my clients' IP from a commercial perspective for thirty years, working with lawyers throughout the world. I wrote to my MP, to the IPO and to Prof Hargreaves himself but had no luck despite my MP writing to Baroness Wilcox on my behalf [The IPKat would love to see more involvement from MPs in general -- the All Party Parliamentary IP Group seems to have gone to ground again -- and from the IP Minister Baroness Wilcox]. I have finally managed to get a slot on Monday afternoon [today!] at the IP Review Surgery Event

The fact is that SMEs are not usually populated by lawyers and academics, the wording in the review document suggests that unless you are a lawyer or an academic, your opinions count for nothing. Professor Hargreaves states that the submissions must be "evidential", this word alone would put any hard working SME off. Perhaps as an academic Professor Hargreaves does not want case studies from SMEs who may well be able to shed great light on this issue. Perhaps SMEs are intimidated by the language of the Review document. Surely if the government or the panel wanted to know the problems facing innovators, they would have put an innovator on the panel. At least he or she would have spoken the same language as the SMEs, also I don't think there are any women on the panel

There are three major problems facing innovative individuals and SMEs in the UK and IP framework is not one of them.

1. The lack of people willing to invest in startups. Our banks won't consider lending to you and the turnover you need to attract Private Equity investors grows each year. Added to this is the fact that investors in this country usually require 100% security over the innovator's IP, and too often the founder finds himself removed from his creation if things don't move as fast as the investors require. As the banks have done away with the concept of bank managers who took it upon themselves to understand their client's business, there is no one to talk to at our banks who knows what you are talking about. If you doubt me, trying explaining the concept of a royalty stream to your local Barclays business branch [The IPKat entirely endorses this. He has been hearing it from small innovative businesses since the 1980s].

2. The catastrophic consequences of financial failure in the UK. Our laws relating to financial failure are so draconian that a failure when young can prevent you ever being able to raise funds in the future and even if you manage to start up again and be successful, whenever you are mentioned in the media no matter how successful you are even decades later you will be referred to as "Bill Smith the former bankrupt" In the United States failure is regarded as a part of the learning curve unless you have intentionally defrauded people. That is seen as capitalism in action [Strange how, at the bottom level, banks are so reluctant to take even the smallest of risks, while they seem to throw caution to the winds when it comes to buying subprime mortgage portfolios and investing in financial paper of which they have manifestly little understanding]

3. Predatory behaviour by larger British firms, particularly retailers with very scary lawyers. The costs to an SME to take on a large company that the SME believes has infringed his IP rights are simply out of the question for most SMEs. It is possible of course to arrange IP litigation insurance but that requires an opinion from counsel before the insurance company will commit. The cost of this can be prohibitive to a small company or individual. Even if you can force the big company to back down enforcement can become a full time job [If evidence is needed here, Hargreaves can speak to ACID, which can provide some real examples]

Perhaps it is because I am Australian but I get extremely annoyed when the British do whatever the Americans tell them to do. It drives me nuts. Who cares what Google wants? They don't care about innovation in the UK, they just want it made easier for them to make money here. This UK has never been short of innovators and it isn't now, it's just extremely bad at supporting its innovators, forcing many to move abroad or giving up their innovations for next to nothing because it's not polite to fight back. I have several innovative British SMEs as clients, they export throughout the world they use the Internet as an integral part of their businesses. Sadly most of them could not raise funds here and have raised them abroad from foreign investors who take a long term view".
The IPKat applauds not just the message but the manner of its delivery.  Members of the Hargreaves Review, please take note!