Showing posts with label German patent law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label German patent law. Show all posts

Friday, August 26, 2011

BGH: does an explanation make an invention?

It is well established in patent law that one can patent an invention even without understanding why it works the way it works. If I happen to be the first to discover that compound X cures cancer, I can get a patent on X for the treatment of cancer (provided the discovery wasn't obvious to the person skilled in the art), even when I have no clue whatsoever why X cures cancer.



So well, so good. As they say in the media business, "dog bites man is no news, man bites dog is news". The German Bundesgerichtshof (BGH) recently had the opportunity to consider the above tenet of patent law in reverse, so to speak. What if it is known that compound X is effective in the treatment of illness Y, but unknown why it works: can you get a patent on X for the treatment of Y if you are the first to find out how X works?



Defendant Merz & Co is the owner of the (expired) EP 392 059 B1 with a priority date of 14 April 1989. In 2006, Merz received a supplementary protection certificate (SPC) for "memantine, and its pharmaceutically compatible salts, namely memantinehydrochloride" for Germany based on EP 392 059 (given the CJEU's judgment in case C‑195/09 Synthon BV v Merz Pharma GmbH & Co. KGaA, this being a reference for a preliminary ruling from the Patents Court, England and Wales, the SPC is invalid anyway, but that is not the issue here). Two unnamed plaintiffs sought a declaration of nullity of Merz's SPC based on the nullity of the base patent. Both the Bundespatentgericht as well as the BGH sided with the plaintiffs (BGH, X ZR 68/08 of 9 June 2011).



Merz restricted its patent, in essence, to "use of 1-amino-3,5-dimethyl-adamantane and its pharmaceutically compatible salts for the manufacture of a medicament for treatment of damaged brain cells after cerebral ischemia after morbus Alzheimer". The plaintiffs argued that the use of adamantane for the treatment of the family of symptoms to which Alzheimer belongs had been known at the priority date of the base patent. Merz defended itself by arguing that while the use may have been known, the mechanism how adamantine worked was unknown before the priority date and disclosed in the base patent for the first time.



The base patent, in the words of the BGH, disclosed the scientific foundation for the use of memantine in the treatment of Alzheimer and allowed a "better justifiable choice of memantine" ("besser verantwortbare Indikation der Memantingabe", para. 43). This, however, does not amount to a technical teaching, it is only a discovery of a biological mechanism that is not patentable under art. 52(2)(a) EPC (para. 44). The base patent neither teaches a different dosage regime nor gives any other specific directions for using memantine in the treatment of Alzheimer that had not been known in the prior art. The "commendable" scientific explanation offered by Merz is a medical and pharmalogical advance but not patentable. The SPC is therefore invalid because the base patent is invalid.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

UNESCO World Heritage... IP

The label "UNESCO World Heritage" conjures up images of ancient ruins and medieval castles, picturesque villages and unspoiled land. Not necessarily of intellectual property, however.

But in addition to the well-known World Heritage Convention, which seeks to protect the cultural and natural heritage of the world, there is a lesser known program of the UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) called "Memory of the World", which seeks to preserve documentary world heritage. Its "Memory of the World Register" lists documents of unique cultural value.

One such document, and recent addition to the UNESCO Memory of the World Register, is the German patent for a "Vehicle with gas engine operation" granted to Carl Benz in 1886, which therefore may now be proudly referred to as a "UNESCO World Heritage Document". The 1886 patent "is of worldwide significance and documents the beginning of the emergence of
individual mobilization in industrialized countries and its spread throughout the world." Somehow, this Kat does not believe the preservation of this document depended on its inclusion in the UNESCO list, but rather on its use for the public relations department of Daimler, but who is to quibble.

Should you want to embellish your wall with a copy of a UNESCO World Heritage Document, you may do so courtesy of espacenet, previously known as patent database, but now also a World Heritage Document Distribution Site.

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

German Federal Court: bread crumbs navigation is not patentable

In a judgment of 24 February 2011, the reasons for which only became available recently, the German Federal Court (BGH) upheld a decision of the Federal Patent Court which invalidated Siemens' German patent DE 101 15 895 C1, which I take the liberty of referring to as the "bread crumbs patent".

Siemens' patent, filed in March 2001 and issued in December 2002, claims a method for navigating websites, comprising the following steps (unofficial and slightly abbreviated translation from German):

Method of generating a display for retrieval (Wiederfinden) of a page already visited from the home page of a content provider and subsequently left, which is accessible over the internet, an intranet or an extranet, which comprises the following steps executed on the server
a) registering the user when accessing the home page,
b) registering the pages visited immediately or subsequently from the home page by the user,
c) generating a display which shows the sequence of the pages visited by the user.

The patent explains that the registration of the user may occur, for example, by placing a "Cookie" on his access device. It is evident that the patent claims the very popular bread crumbs navigation.

Someone - the judgment is anonymous - took issue and filed for a declaration of nullity, citing lack of patentable subject matter, lack of novelty and lack of inventive step. The Federal Patent Court agreed with the plaintiff and declared the patent null for lack of patentable subject matter.

On appeal, the BGH confirmed. The claimed method was technical in nature, since it concerned the storage, retrieval and transmission of data by technical means (para. 16). However, since computer programs "as such" are not patentable, case law requires that the claimed method comprises instructions for the solution of a technical problem by technical means (para. 17). Here, the claimed method merely taught to register and display the information entered by the user. The usability of the navigation method depended on the interaction of the user and the visual display of the information. Merely implementing this method by technical means known in the state of the art did not make it technical in nature (para. 23).

Since the claims lacked patentable subject matter, neither court needed to address the issues of novelty and inventive step. For website owners in Germany, the nullification of the bread crumbs patent is certainly good news. This is one of those patents that must have been infringed by thousands of people. Whether Siemens ever tried to enforce the patent is unclear.