Showing posts with label Friday fantasies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Friday fantasies. Show all posts

Friday, September 9, 2011

Friday fantasies

AnSome fresh events have been added this week for the delectation of the IPKat's conference- and seminar-going readers. Don't forget to check them out -- and have a lovely weekend!


The recording industry has
moved on since Cliff Richards'
youth, but dogs have remained
much the same ...
In case anyone still thinks he hasn't noticed it yet, the IPKat wants to record that, yes, he is aware of the acceptance in principle by the European Commission of the proposal to extend from fifty to seventy years the period for which sound recordings are copyright-protected.  You can read about it on the BBC here. If the Kat were not speechless, he would remind everyone of the oft-repeated British mantra that copyright reform must be evidence-based if it is to be accepted. Merpel says, don't be so silly -- it's perfectly logical: if the duration of copyright in authors' works had to be extended from death + 50 to death + 70 years in the European Union because authors and their heirs live longer than they used to, it's quite reasonable to suggest that copyright in sound recordings should be extended from 50 to 70 because they last longer than they used to.  There's another point to note: this extension is closely associated with one-time pop star Cliff Richard, whose initials also stand for copy right.  It's understood that the registered designs lobby is now planning to recruit Roger Daltry ...



One audacious plank in the TPP, the
affirmation of monopoly rights in functional
toy shapes, was dropped after Lego said
its next theme park was to be a full-scale
working model of the Pacific Ocean made
out of its own bricks ...

What with the US round of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) agreement underway in Chicago, intellectual property and information policy experts from around the world have released their Washington Declaration on Intellectual Property and the Public Interest.  This challenges the dominant direction of the negotiations on intellectual property in US trade agreements. The Declaration, created through a consultative process with over 180 experts from 35 countries in six continents, criticises an "unprecedented expansion of the concentrated legal authority exercised by intellectual property rights holders" through recent trade agreements, and calls for new efforts to "re-articulate the public interest dimension in intellectual property law and policy", which is quite a grown-up thing to do and requires both more thought and self-restraint than the popular position, which is that you can just help yourself to what you want, especially it's available online.  If you support the Declaration, there's a sign-on here. There's nowhere to sign if you don't disagree or are agnostic.  The Kat thanks his friend Ronan Deazley for the nudge and Aurelia J. Schultz for posting this piece so speedily on the 1709 Blog.



Sadly, the youth of today
just don't dress up for law
conferences like they
used to ....
If you want to get away from all the arguments about copyright term, you take take refuge in the far more glamorous company of the speakers' panel for the Handbags at Dawn: Intellectual Property Law and the Fashion Industry conference, which takes place in little less than a fortnight, on 22 September, in Central London:
An IPKat team blogger will be in the chair,
And lots of contention will be in the air --
Copy this style? If only I dare!
It's worth an attempt if my usage is fair.
Be sued for infringement? You get quite a scare,
And what colour soles for the shoes that I wear?
Of all these key issues you'll soon be aware
If you come to the conference. So, see you there?
This conference is supported by the Art & Artifice weblog, which was launched this year and attracting a bright and faithful following.


Turning stone into gold
was no problem -- except
when it came to repeating
the experiment in court
If you find fashion too pleasurable, hang around for a few weeks and you can sample the harsh realities of "International High-Tech Patent Litigation". If it's not actually coming to a Court near you, you can still sample it on 27 September in the wilds of Central London. The speakers include Mr Justice Arnold and Nokia's Richard Vary; you can find further details here. The venue is the DoubleTree Hilton, Central London.  Merpel adds, the name of this venue has a deep-seated pyschological impact: "DoubleTree" rhymes with "Trouble Free", thus sending out a message that the hotel is in no way connected with Fawlty Towers.

Friday, September 2, 2011

Friday fantasies

Friday has come around again so please, please check the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page for all the exciting things you can do once the kids are back at school, the dog has been collected from the holiday kennels and the realisation that Christmas is on its way has truly kicked in.


Nice. The IPKat has been pondering the following extract from a rather jolly document published by his friends at the World Intellectual Property Organization ("Special Union for the International Classification of Goods and Services for the Purposes of the Registration of Marks (Nice Union) Committee of Experts, Twenty-First Session, Geneva, November 22 to 26, 2010",  dated 11 January 2011).  The extract reads thus:
"The Committee agreed that amendments and other changes to the ninth edition of the Nice Classification should enter into force on January 1, 2012 [that's 121 days from now], which meant that, in accordance with Article 4(1) of the Nice Agreement, the notification of the decisions of the Committee should be sent by the International Bureau (IB) on July 1, 2011 [which, like so many fleeting pleasures, has been and gone ...], at the latest."
Now, no-one ever told the IPKat what happened next.  Has the 10th edition been prepared and notified to the International Bureau in all its glory, or has something happened to it? Can anyone advise this confused kitty?


The piece by Ben Collingwood on ownership of Twitter accounts and followers as between employers and ex-employees, which the IPKat recently hosted here, has attracted quite a bit of interest from readers. The Kat also thanks Gerry Gavigan for drawing his attention to the first blog post by Laura Kuenssberg for her new employer, here. It contains the following:
".. my departure from the BBC to become business editor at ITV News led to a sometimes frenzied conversation online, in diary columns, and even on the front page of one newspaper over the question of who “owned” the 60,000 or so people who had followed me on Twitter as @BBCLauraK. 



Laura also speaks
For me, such talk of the BBC “losing” thousands of digital consumers as I “took” them with me as I moved to become @ITVLauraK was based on a misunderstanding of this new medium. Spend any time on Twitter and it is obvious that it is hardly a place where wallflowers linger, waiting silently and patiently for an invitation to participate in the debate. I didn’t choose the boisterous, diverse, direct and often delightful 67,000 who followed my account. They chose to follow me. And their reasons for doing so were many and varied.  So while the agreement with the BBC that I could transfer my Twitter name was entirely amicable, and I wish my successor, @BBCNormanS, well, I was, and still am, well aware that the followers of my account could, with just one click, switch off from the 140-character missives I write throughout the day. Indeed, with the tendency for full and frank disclosure that Twitter encourages, a small handful of followers did in fact get in touch to tell me they were checking out. Happily, though, the vast majority have stayed put...."
While the agreement between Laura and the BBC was obviously something between just the two of them and cannot be said in any meaningful sense to be a precedent, the Kat applauds the refreshingly realistic and commonsense approach reflected here.  But, Merpel warns, the ownership of copyright in the tweets remains a separate issue.





In the olden days, you
had to ask for money.
Now they just throw
it at you ...
Following Merpel's little rant earlier today about the arithmetic, and indeed more than the arithmetic, underpinning ICANN's gTLD regime, as well as Adam Smith's additional comments, the IPKat has learned that Australian broadcaster, journalist and organ donor ambassador Mark Colvin from the ABC's PM programme is hoping to do a story on ICANN and the gTLDs next week. Mark's interest in organ donations is not unique. Some brand owners will take heart at the fact that the new scheme will get some vigorous no-nonsense examination from this quarter, while others have already resigned themselves to having to pay an arm and a leg to buy the coveted word that follows the dot.  So why not keep an eye out for further developments? By the way, you can follow Mark on Twitter at @colvinius.


Late change.  The IPKat's disappointment that his friend Alice Gould (Wedlake Bell) has been lost to next week's Hardwicke sell-out seminar on Initial Interest Confusion on account of a pressing court commitment (an occupational hazard among litigation lawyers, alas!) has been tempered by his relief that an excellent replacement has been found in the person of Simon Bennett (Fox Williams). This seminar should be a fascinating and educative event, with not a little controversy: not everyone on the planet believes that initial interest confusion (i) is a good and useful legal doctrine or (ii) can already be found within European Union and UK case law.  The IPKat hopes to report on this seminar, all being well.  Meanwhile, you can get a little background reading on the subject here.


With what he describes as the "least surprising news of the year", Chris Torrero informs the IPKat that both of the warring factions in the Myriad BRCA breast cancer gene patent furore are separately appealing against the controversial recent ruling (which you can read in full here).

Friday, August 26, 2011

Friday fantasies

If you are young, gifted and good at writing intellectual property essays, it's almost but not quite too late to submit yours as an entry in the ATRIP Essay Competition 2011 for Young Researchers in Intellectual Property Law, the closing date for which is 31 August 2011 (that's next Wednesday). You can write on any IP topic, to a maximum length of 8,000 words inclusive of footnotes.  Young, in this context, is "no older than 33 years of age as of 31 December 2011". Just email it to the IPKat's friend Professor Jan Rosén, making sure that no-one reading it will know who you are -- and tell the good professor that the IPKat sent you. Good news it that
"The authors of the best three papers will be mentioned as such on the ATRIP website in an ad hoc section. In addition, the author of the best paper will be invited to give a presentation as a speaker at the 2012 ATRIP international annual conference to be held in Chicago".

If you are young, glamorous and choosy as to what you wear, you may not yet have one of these in your wardrobe, but the IPKat's friend and fellow blogger Lorraine Fleck has drawn the Kat's attention, via LinkedIn's Fashion+IP group, to this piece in the LA Times which suggests that the Hells' Angels are not best pleased with Hollywood fashion house Wildfox, or online sales facility Amazon, for making and selling these cute little T-shirts.

Of course, the first question any red-blooded European trade mark enthusiast will ask is whether the slogan constitutes trade mark use, or whether it is taken merely as a statement that one should take liberties with the T-shirt's wearer without weighing up the prospects of an unwelcome visit from a bevy of bikers.  The other interesting question, Merpel thinks, is what the generic or descriptive term for a Hell's Angel actually is.  Readers' uggestions are invited.





International Treats ...
If you're young, scholarly and like to dig around in important areas of intellectual property that hardly anyone else seems to have spotted yet, you may be a kindred spirit to Simon Klopschinski (Hoffmann Eitle, Munich), whose German-language PhD thesis "Der Schutz geistigen Eigentums durch völkerrechtliche Investitionsverträge" (The Protection of Intellectual Property under International Investment Treaties) has just been published by Kluwer's Carl Heymanns Verlag imprint. The book's home page is here; you can also read a short English-language explanation of what it's about on the IP Finance blog here.  All the Kats are sure that the book must be a good deal more exciting than its cover, here.  They do however recognise how difficult it is to illustrate the theme of "international treaties", which is why they've settled for the very similar, if slightly shorter, "international treats" (left) ...


If you are old, nostalgic and patent-oriented, this piece of prose by Brookes Batchellor's Nick Dougan, celebrating the 50 years in IP practice which his colleague Roy Prentice has so far notched up, will give pleasure.  Apart from an unusual sortie into the world of IP enforcement via some "heavies" (already posted here on PatLit), there's a touching recollection of what life used to be life before the era of the internet:
"Early days – patent searching 
As a technical assistant, as trainee patent agents were called in those days, at first most of my time was spent searching. The Patent Office library was at 25 Southampton Buildings and D. Young & Co.’s offices at Staple Inn were next door. The library opened at 10.00 am. When I came in each morning, I would sort out the searches that needed to be done and then go over to the library at opening time. Now remember this was in the days before computers. Everything had to be searched manually and quite often the searches would take all morning [It seems to take some good folk considerably longer nowadays even with computers, notes Merpel, who guesses that there just wasn't so much prior art in the old days]. I would go back to the office at lunchtime and then had to report the searches in the afternoon. I remained responsible for most searches until another new boy started a couple of years later, when I was put in charge of the “search department”, as well as assuming responsibility for filing and prosecuting all of the registered design applications for the firm. Nowadays, with computers, what used to take over an hour can be done on the Internet in a few minutes and often in a few seconds [Ah, but thing that used to take a few seconds now take much longer -- like checking one's emails ...]".

If you're any age, love scientific data and are searching for something in your life, your interest may have been piqued by yesterday's post about Boliven's special one-month free trial offer for IPKat readers. Your excited expectations may then have tumbled when you spotted that, for a reason that the Kat has so far failed to blame anyone else, a key piece of information was missing: the url where free triallists are supposed to log on.  It has now been belatedly added but, in case you are not one of those readers who regularly revisits old blog posts, the Kat thought he'd better mention it here too:
"All you have to do is register for your free trial, using the special offer code -KATFREETRIAL - and then you can search for one whole month to your heart's content. The place to register is www.boliven.com/freetrials".

If you are young, beefy and likely to end up as a burger on someone's plate, you may belong to a Texas herd that is going to be branded -- in the original meaning of the word.  According to this fascinating news item, Texan cattle brands and marks -- like trade marks in many countries -- lapse after ten years if they are not renewed.  A subtle difference is that all registered marks lapse on exactly the same day -- 30 August. Happily, there is a six-month renewal period if you forget to renew, following which your brand will be up for grabs and someone else might be able to register it in your place.  The IPKat thanks his Mancunium IP correspondent Sang Nkhwazi for discovering this item.

Friday, August 19, 2011

Friday fantasies

Fridays in August are usually quiet, peaceful occasions. Inject a little excitement into your life by checking out the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page here.


Talking of forthcoming events, there's an intriguing one coming up to the north of Hadrian's Wall where a Law Society of Scotland seminar, "IP and the Law in a Digital Age", takes place at the Festival of Politics [the what! exclaims Merpel] next Friday, 26 August, in committee room 1 of what some might claim to be the ugliest building in Europe, the Scottish Parliament. If you want to be there (and you can't see the outside of the building when you're inside it), it's best to contact Emily Young on 0131 476 8204 or email her at emilyyoung@lawscot.org.uk and tell her the IPKat sent you.


Still talking of forthcoming events, the IPKat informs his readers that there's a change in the speakers' line-up for the Handbags at Dawn: IP and Fashion conference on 22 September. Stephanie Hutchinson (Arnold & Porter) will be speaking on import/export issues involving fashion brands. Although she continues to deny that she is Superwoman (the "S" on the illustration to the left stands for "Stephanie"), she has a very impressive profile and even knows how to write articles. Her details aren't on the conference web page yet, but you can read a little about her here.


If you have been following the Google Book Settlement (GBS) saga, it's best to keep a safe distance since there are grounds upon which one might infer that the GBS is about to be interred, whether there's still theoretically some life in it or not.  C.E. Petit's Scrivener's Error seems ready to officiate over the last rites, judging by his "GBS Update: Second Circuit Decision in Muchnick May Kill Class Settlement Chances", here.  And if you have an urgent need to visit the Laboratorium, you'll find plenty of reading matter in James Grimmelman's obituary for it, "Google Books Settlement, 2008-2011", here.


Around the weblogs.  In "NCC has its knuckles rapped over raids, seizures against collecting society", Nigerian IP lawyer and business consultant Ayo Solarin reviews the currently confused situation in Nigeria, where there seems to be more litigation between bodies that are concerned with copyright enforcement than there is against real infringers: read Ayo's piece on Afro-IP here.  If red soles are more to your taste, the recent ruling in Louboutin v Yves St Laurent is given a make-over by US fashion law expert Charles Colman in his Styleite blog here.


Tail end.  Merpel moaned on Wednesday about the neglect of cat genomes. It took a sleuth like Chris Torrero to track down Feline Genome Resources here.

Friday, August 12, 2011

Friday fantasies

For those of you who may not be day-aware, it's Friday! This means you are allowed to check the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page for all those exciting encounters with real and self-proclaimed experts, comfy and not-so-comfy venues, interesting and not-so-interesting topics ...


Page 9 of the PCT Newsletter is about eight pages further than the IPKat gets before he falls fast asleep, but he was alerted this time round by the vigilant Michelle Jones (Astex) to something that filled him with happiness -- news of an update to the WIPO anti-scam "warning page".  It reads as follows:
"Warning page concerning requests for payment of fees  
The “Warning” web page, which lists the invitations to pay fees that do not come from the
International Bureau of WIPO and are unrelated to the processing of international applications
under the PCT, is now available in French, Japanese and Russian, in addition to Chinese,
English, German and Spanish at, respectively:  
http://www.wipo.int/pct/fr/warning/pct_warning.html
http://www.wipo.int/pct/ja/warning/pct_warning.html
http://www.wipo.int/pct/ru/warning/pct_warning.html
The “Warning” page has also been updated to include two new invitations, as well as a copy of
the text, in Chinese, English, French, Japanese, Korean, Russian and Spanish, that WIPO has
provided to patent attorneys for use when informing applicants and inventors about such fee
requests, as well as the circular letter that has been sent by WIPO to patent Offices of PCT
Contracting States and regional organizations – see the “Practical Advice” in this issue for
details about those texts."
You can also read the MARQUES Class 46 collection of warning notices from national offices here.


Around the weblogs.  "Bingo for Binley's as fictional seeds bear fruit" is the intriguing title of a piece by Birketts LLP's Chris Sleep on how Judge Birss handled the evidential hot potato of databases seeded with fake names so you can see if the mailing list someone else is using is the one you compiled: you can read it on the 1709 Blog here.  Is freedom of expression guaranteed in the law of the Philippines? Yes, er, no, according to Art & Artifice, as Simone Blakeney explains here.

Friday, August 5, 2011

Friday fantasies

Friday has come round again and, with it, a priceless moment to contemplate the array of future attractions -- so check out the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page here and see what takes your fancy!


"IPTV for You & Me" was the exciting headline of this piece that caught the eye of Dr Kate E. Macdonald. Sadly, this was an acute case of initial interest confusion: the article to which this marvellous headline was attached was all about internet protocol television after all.  Never mind the disappointment, at least it makes the French happy, according to the BBC.


Wearing red soles ...!
... and talking of initial interest confusion, the Hardwicke seminar on that very subject on 7 September has now been signed up to by 58 whole people. This is good news for everyone who enjoys half-day seminars, buffet lunches, excellent networking and a chance to see what the AmeriKat will be wearing. Programme and registration details here.


The Federation Against Software Theft (FAST) is never out of the news these days. Its latest eye-catcher is an announcement that it is now an affiliate of Brand-i, the web-store where you can't buy fakes even if you want to, since it only lists genuine sellers and has the blessing of the Trading Standards Institute. Brand-i has that incredible Report-a-Site functionality, which enables shoppers to "shop" online sellers of counterfeits.  Customers actually have two options if they find a site offering infringing software. They can use Report-a-Site or they can tell FAST itself here. Now that's consumer choice for you, says the IPKat..


Discreet Australians do exist. One such soul has sent the IPKat this little tale and begs to be kept anonymous. And this is what she tells the Kats:
"Coles, a large Australian supermarket, has recently been going through an advertising war with its rival Woolworths. Coles' advertising campaign features a slogan and a terrible song called "Down down, our prices are down" and using giant red hands (here).  Recently a parody was made of the ad, titled "Colworths" and was placed on YouTube. The parody uses the footage from the Coles ad, with some changes (eg causing the big red hand to make a rude gesture, inserting pie charts on competition between retailers and amending the words). For instance, the parody says "Is that on special?" "Nope its down and staying down" When we say its staying down, we mean staying down long enough to lure you away from independent competitors. Then we crush them like despised $2 milk cartons. Up yours independent retail stores. As soon as we wipe out all the competition, we can give you a right royal roger." 
Dr Seuss: a leading
US authority on
parody, but the man
really could not
draw cats ...
A week or so ago, YouTube removed the video, stating that "This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited. The parody was shown in an Australian TV show, The Gruen Transfer, and is now available on YouTube here. 
The ColWorths video was clearly a parody that criticised the original and would likely have been considered a fair use of the Coles Ad under the Acuff Rose, Dr Seuss and subsequent case law principles. Coles likely doesn't care about the copyright issue, but has rather removed the ad due to the criticism of its trading practices.  On receipt of a notice from a company like Coles, YouTube will automatically take down a video. It is up to the video owner to reply with an opposition notice. However, with the threat of legal proceedings, what individual is going to take on a giant supermarket chain, even if it believes that their video was a fair use? The costs could be enormous. Even though Coles would likely (at least I hope) suspect that this parody would fall under fair use, they would also know that it is highly unlikely that the video owner will argue against the removal.
I am not sure about whether US law or Australian law applies in this case. Even so, under the Australian Copyright Act 1968, s 103AA states "A fair dealing with audiovisual item does not constitute an infringement of the copyright in the item or in any work or other audiovisual item included in the item if it is for the purpose of parody or satire." The legislation did not define the terms parody or satire and the Australian courts have yet to consider the exception, which was introduced in December 2006. However, including both parody and satire, the exception is notably broader than the US fair use exception".
Yesterday the Kat was bemoaning the way in which the honourable practice of ghostwriting has been besmirched by a small number of members of the medical profession and the pharma industry who have collaborated in the pretence that named authors have written articles endorsing certain medical products.   Today the very same Kat is pondering another bit of fakery, in which Damart -- the company which in his mind will ever be indissolubly linked with thermal underwear -- has been taking the finalists in a promotional prize draw.  Originally the UK's Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) condemned the company for sending out a direct mailing for a prize draw that included a list headed "official extract list of finalists". The finalists weren't real finalists at all but were "used for illustration purposes to highlight that a genuine selection process had taken place". Since the mailing falsely stated that the names on the list were those of finalists and did not make clear that fictitious names had been used to represent the names of genuine finalists, the ASA said consumers were likely to think these were the names of genuine finalists, so the advertisement was misleading under rule 3.1 (Misleading advertising) of the Code of Advertising Practice. But now the ASA has changed its mind.  In what is euphemistically described as a "revised adjudication" it now holds that, while the list falsely suggested that the names on it were real people, the real or fictitious nature of those names made no material difference to the recipient's chances of winning. Accordingly, while the mailing was false, it was not "materially misleading".

Friday, July 29, 2011

Friday fantasies

Friday has come round again and, with it, the usual reminder to check the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page to see what's looming up in the future. There are conferences, seminars, all sorts of attractions. Might we see you at any of them?


Youth opportunity of the week.  The IPKat is getting quite a few requests these days from young enthusiasts in search of that elusive first rung on the ladder of life in the IP field.  This week's eager youngster is Simon Graham, who writes:
"I am a highly motivated postgraduate looking for an internship with a patent firm or in-house patent team ideally in the UK, Europe or America. Having gained the Master in the Management of Intellectual Property and the certificate in Intellectual Property Law from Queen Mary [for the benefit of first-time readers, the Kat explains that Queen Mary is the college, not the ship or even the pub], I am part qualified and currently studying for the UK Patent Practice (P2) exam.

My technical background is in life sciences and computing gained in the pharmaceutical industry with some experience of working in an IP environment.
Please contact sgraham_ip@yahoo.com if you can help." 
Well, readers -- if you are interested, you know what you can do!


Around the weblogs. The Cyberleagle blog, authoritatively authored by the IPKat's friend Graham Smith, carries this eloquent piece on "10 essential points from Newzbin2".  Graham's very discreet about which law firm he works for, but it has four wings and plenty of feathers.  The jiplp weblog features a Current Intelligence piece by Kingsley Egbuonu and Chukwuyere Izuogu on the only case known to this Kat in which an injunction to restrain a patent infringement had repercussions for the conduct of a general election. PatLit's latest PCC Page investigates the often essential inconvenience of finding the right expert witness here.


Want to impress your friends?
Judicial fancy dress available
here
The IPKat wonders what fate is about to befall intellectual property litigation in England and Wales. Only a short while ago he was celebrating the elevation of two of the country's Patents Court judges to the Court of Appeal.  Now he has just read the following snippets:
  • The Queen has been pleased to approve the appointment of Robert Henry Thoroton Hildyard, Esq., Q.C., to be a Justice of the High Court with effect from 3 October 2011 on the elevation of Mr. Justice Lewison to the Court of Appeal.
  • The Queen has been pleased to approve the appointment of Rabinder Singh, Esq., Q.C., to be a Justice of the High Court with effect from 3 October 2011 on the elevation of Mr. Justice Kitchin to the Court of Appeal.

Like any well-mannered feline, the Kat welcomes the new appointments, who appear well qualified for the bench, and wishes them the best of luck. He is however a little anxious since, to his great embarrassment, he hasn't heard of either of the new judges before and has a trifling suspicion that they're not main-line IP-ers.  This leaves him wondering whether the vacancies in the Patents Court will be left empty, or filled by 'outsiders' (as has been done before, sometimes with notable success). Or maybe we'll be cutting down on those expensive High Court types and stocking up on cheap-and-cheerful Patents County Court judges instead, now that Judge Birss has made that court so popular.  Does any reader know?

Friday, July 22, 2011

Friday fantasies

Alfred, Lord Tennyson did not writs this ...
Friday, Friday,
It's your day and my day!
'Tis time to be sage
And to visit this page. 
There we will find
Great peace of mind
Amid the Events
Which make so much sense ...
Don't forget to check the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page!


Want to get published? The Indian Journal of Law and Technology (IJLT) is a law journal published annually by the Law and Technology Committee of the Student Bar Association, at the National Law School of India University, Bangalore, India. It's also "the first and currently the only law journal published in India specifically devoted to the interface between law and technology". Managing editor and SPICY IP team member Amlan Mohanty (left) is currently calling for submissions for Volume No. 8 of 2012. If you're interested, email him here or phone him on his mobile: 98807-23994.


A British-based reader has emailed the IPKat with the following request:
Making off with the iSwag ....
"I have been developing a web portal which provides Law Enforcement with practical tools and resources to assist them in dealing with software IP crime. One of the aspects I would like to include is the ability to search for cases which may assist in considering matters for potential investigation. Considering your expertise and experience, I am wondering whether you might be able to suggest a free on line source for these public servants? I have a mind to consider http://www.bailii.org/." 
The IPKat has no better clue than BAILII and, as a civil Kat, he has rarely sought to root out materials on software IP crime. Do any readers have an idea where an accessible free online source of cases and presumably other useful material might be found?  Merpel adds: I hope this portal will be open for everyone to use, and not just law enforcement folk. After all, it would be a good place for people who develop, sell or work with software to be able to check whether what they want to do -- or have already done -- is (i) legal, (ii) illegal or (iii) possibly legal or illegal, depending on how, when or why ...


The closing date for the SPC Blog's "Bucknell Book" competition is this Sunday night -- so don't miss out on your chance to fill your bookshelf with something large, grey, heavy but smaller than an elephant.  You don't need to rush to enter the Art & Artifice handbag lcompetition though; the closing date's not till Sunday 31 July.


Hmm, she said, this wasn't
quite the sort of work
experience I had in mind
The IPKat and Merpel are both keen to help a damsel in distress. Well, actually she's not in too much distress. But she is a 2011 law graduate from the University of Surrey (First Class Honours in Law with International Studies). In September this year she is off to University College London to study for her LLM. No shrinking violet, she won this year's University of Surrey Mooting Competition, also picking up second prize in the 2010-2011 Bar Pro Bono Unit University Challenge. Our damsel is looking for some work experience in the legal field, particularly at the Bar.  If IP isn't available, she'll make do with Public International Law, International Criminal Law, Human Rights Law, Public and Administrative Law, Environmental Law, European Union Law, Contract Law and Criminal Law. She's ready to toil from 8 August to 23 September this year -- and also throughout the upcoming academic year if required. If you're interested, email the IPKat and Merpel here with the subject line "Damsel" and he'll forward serious offers to her.


Around the blogs. IP Matters and Business Solutions, composed by Nigerian and West African IP-watcher, lawyer and business consultant Ayo Solarin, is a blog which the IPKat only came across today; there's not much around in Africa so far as IP bloggers are concerned, so the Kat is delighted to see Ayo's interest.  The 1709 Blog has hosted two posts now on what has been a difficult week for online academic journal treasure trove JSTORE, both (here and here) by New York lawyer and blogger Christopher F. Meatto. WiseHarbor's Keith Mallinson offers more data-backed arguments in favour of collaborative standards for patent-based mobile technologies on IP Finance here, while on the same weblog leading barrister Nicholas Caddick QC asks questions concerning the cost of compensating phone hacking here.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Friday fantasies

Friday, the ideal day to check what's on in IP. Do check out the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page here for a quick look some attractive options, away-days and networking opportunities.




Very happy, a little embarrassed and not a little honoured, the IPKat informs readers that this weblog is mentioned as one of the 50 influential parties for 2011 in today's release from Managing Intellectual Property (here). The Kat is delighted to see some of his friends in the list too, and a little saddened by the absence of some of the others -- which probably suggests that the list is quite balanced.  Merpel's purring at seeing her name in print somewhere other than on the pages of this blog. And as for our AmeriKat, she got a special mention too. Says the IPKat, we promise to do our best to maintain and improve the standards we've set ourselves and to work hard to keep our readers happy!


After applauding the conference organised by the Norwegian Patent Office to mark its centenary, the IPKat has been roundly chided by Rán Tryggvadóttir for his inexcusable failure to tell his more adventurous readers of the one day conference planned on 18 August to celebrate the Icelandic Patent Office's 20th birthday. Says Rán, "Reykjavík is always worth a visit, especially now for those with an interest in geography aside from their IP interest". Indeed, murmurs Merpel: you never hear people say that when they organise events in Luxembourg ...


Handbags at Dawn: Intellectual Property in the Fashion Industry, the annual conference run by CLT in London, takes place this year on 22 September. It's sponsored by the Art & Artifice weblog and boasts two Kats on the list of speakers: Catherine Lee and Annsley Merelle Ward.  Team blogger Jeremy is in the chair, in between the refreshment breaks at any rate.  Art & Artifice is running a little competition for which the prize is complimentary admission and the delicious lunch that goes with it.  You can check it out here.


Life can be hard and there are some tough times ahead while we learn to live with what feels like a semi-permanent recession. Still, there's always something to smile about -- particularly if you can wait long enough for it to happen. One happy event that's still a long way off is the next World Intellectual Property Day -- Thursday 26 April 2012; the IPKat is already planning an exciting day with breakfast, lunch, afternoon and evening events in Central London.  As in previous years, all the IPKat's events are free to entrants, which means that he will be looking for sponsorships and venues. The IPKat will also be pleased to publicise events taking place elsewhere, so long as he knows about them.  If you are interested in sponsoring or hosting an event -- it might be a talk, a seminar, a debate, a party, a whisky-sampling, a cake-tasting or indeed anything else -- email the IPKat here with the subject line "World IP Day" and he'll get back to you in the autumn.


Around the blogs. In addition to Emma Beverland and Sam Bardon's summary of the Big Debate on whether we come to bury copyright or to praise it for the 1709 Blog here, there are further words from James Firth (Slightly Right of Centre) and debate partiipant Crosbie Fitch (Cultural Liberty). Over on the jiplp weblog, Australians Mark William and Tim Golder review the position regarding trade mark use on the internet here.

Friday, July 8, 2011

More Friday Fantasies

A sign of the times?
Initial Interest Confusion is the title, and indeed the subject matter, of a half-day seminar to be hosted by barristers' chambers Hardwicke in the lovely setting of Lincoln's Inn, London.  The date is 7 September and it's one of those lovely little 11-to-3 seminars with a tasty buffet in the middle of it.  Participants in the seminar, which tackles initial interest confusion in its US, UK and European guises, are barrister Mark Engelman (Hardwicke), solicitor and Kat team member Annsley Merelle Ward (Collyer Bristow) and fellow solicitors Ben Allgrove (Baker & McKenzie) and Alice Gould (Wedlake Bell). IPKat team member and Olswang LLP's IP Consultant Jeremy will be in the chair.

Following an explanation of the doctrine's origins in the US, particular attention will be given to the implications of initial interest confusion for the use of trade marks as keywords, Mr Justice Arnold's groundbreaking judgment in Och-Ziff and the pre-trial and evidential issues which it raises.

You can get there and enjoy a coffee from 10.30am onwards. If you miss the morning coffee you can still collect the 3 CPD Points which are on offer -- and the cost, even including the eat-all-you-can-manage buffet lunch -- is a thoroughly modest £70.00 per person (inclusive of VAT).

To book your place, do get in touch with Lisa Pick by email or give her a call on +44 20 7242 2523.


Can you spot the genuine product?
If so, you're imagining things!
Another event -- this time one which is heavily backed by the Art & Artifice (AandA) weblog -- is this year's Handbags at Dawn: Intellectual Property in the Fashion Industry.  The date is 22 September and it's an all-day affair which is slated for Central London.  The brochure reveals that AandA bloggers Simone Blakeney (Clifford Chance LLP) and Rosie Burbidge (Olswang LLP) are speaking -- as is the IPKat's duo of the AmeriKat (Annsley Merelle Ward) and Cat the Kat (Catherine Lee). Fellow IPKat and AandA team member Jeremy is again in the chair.  AandA will be launching an IP and Fashion competition next week, so watch this space for future developments. Note for conference sceptics: this is the severalth time that this conference has run and each year it has been really enjoyable for speakers and registrants alike.  It's very interactive and is quite apt to stretch the imagination too.


IP scammers be warned:
we want justice now!
Those scammy so-and-sos who write letters to patent and trade mark applicants, masquerading as the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) or regional or national offices and seeking fees for non-existent services or valueless listings, have caused the IPKat to spring into action this week.  Faced with a letter demanding payment and giving details of a bank account which was held with a reputable and well-known bank, the Kat contacted the legal department of the bank concerned and asked what could be done about it.  The bank's legal department informed him that it had previously contacted various offices and  government departments.  One felt that, while they could issue notices to raise awareness of the problem, it was for the IP applicant to be vigilant. Another agreed, adding that you can't just take enforcement action at will: there are jurisdictional issues involved. A third made no response at all.  The bank in question, rightly conscious of its responsibilities, has commenced its own fraud investigations, for which it should be commended.  If this procedure bears fruit, this Kat promises to keep his readers informed.


In their cunning disguise, Bunglewart and
Muddleby could go about their daily job
of finding out whether IP is actually
worth anything without attracting the
attention of the business community
Two new reports, 'The Role of Intellectual Property Rights in the UK Market Sector' and 'Film, Television & Radio, Books, Music and Art: UK Investment in Artistic Originals', have been published today.  You can access them here.  Commissioned by the United Kingdom's Intellectual Property Office (IPO), they purportedly show that "investments made by businesses in products and services that are protected by intellectual property rights are worth £65 billion a year".  The IPKat is monumentally unimpressed with these reports, not because they are in any way flawed or inadequate [he leaves that sort of criticism to his readers, who generally always know better than he does on matters like this ...] but because they are at base irrelevant.  Whether the amount is £10 billion, £25 billion, £65 billion or £100 billion makes no difference at all to the decision of investors to invest, of innovators to innovate, of consumers to consumer or of entrepreneurs to entrepren.  Nor does it make any difference to two of the most important of factors to take into account: the decision of infringers to infringe and of consumers to consume.  Since (i) the amount spent on the administration of justice in the court, customs and police sectors and (ii) the amount invested in the institutional functionality of the IPO, the Office of Fair Trading, the Competition Commission etc is not affected by the aggregated national sum invested, what do we need these figures for? Surely it can't be to persuade ourselves, for the 8,967th time, that intellectual property is important and that we have to -- what's that phrase, again? -- oh, yes, "do something about it"!

nb More serious, detailed and respectful reviews of both reports will be forthcoming in due course.


A reader who endearingly describes this weblog as "admirably British" -- written as it is by a team of seven, of whom the preponderant majority are, er, non-Brits by origin -- has a request for information.  Although he is apparently a lawyer than an editor, he calls himself "Ed", but he has already been forgiven.  Anyway, Ed writes:
"Are any of you aware of any cases as follows? 
(1) Party A gives requisite consent for party B to register party A's name as a mark;
(2) Party B receives registration for mark consisting of party A's name;
(3) Party A later revokes consent for Party B to use Party A's name as a mark;
(4) Party A seeks to have registration for Party's A's name invalidated. 
I'd be interested in any such scenarios regardless of jurisdiction)".
The scenario has much in common with Edwin v OHIM, Elio Fiorucci and is not so very far from Safariland v OHIM, DEF-TEC -- but if readers can pinpoint any 'direct hits' our reader (who is not actually a Kat but does have the letters k, a and t in his surname) would be massively grateful.

Friday fantasies

There are lots of fresh events on the IPKat's Forthcoming Events page, specially added for your education, erudition and electrification. Don't forget to check them out here!


The IPKat checks out the acquis commautaire
before deciding how ACTA might affect it
This Kat has kept meaning to write about this, but has been distracted by the momentous events of, er, the moment.  The 'this' in question is the European Commission's proposal for a Council Decision on the conclusion of the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (a.k.a. ACTA, the text of which is appended to the proposal).  The proposal's explanatory memorandum reflects the Commission's view that ACTA will not ruffle the European Union's acquis communautaire [Merpel explains: this is the French term for "the legislative and judicial baggage we have to carry around with us whether we like it or not"] and that, since the EU's commercial (trade) policy powers apply here, its own powers are exclusive as regards the whole treaty.  The only exception here is the bits of ACTA that deal with criminal sanctions which, says the Commision require ratification by the individual Member States.  Professor Steve Peers (thanks, Steve, for spotting this item, by the way) tells the Kats that there are reports afoot that the European Parliament might refer ACTA to the Court of Justice in order to ascertain whether it is compatible with EU law.  If anyone gets to hear more about this, do please let us know.


Readers of this weblog will recall the IPKat's interest in the APP STORE trade mark, claimed by Apple but vigorously resisted by some of the other large beasts that roam the Applications Jungle (see earlier post from the European battlefront, here).  Now here's some more news: Gerry Gavigan has alerted the Kat to Apple's failure to gain preliminary injunctive relief in infringement proceedings against Amazon's Appstore after a fruitless attempt to persuade the judge that it had a chance of success at trial. The IPKat really doubts whether the efforts that are made to colonise generic and quasi-generic terms such as App Store generate anythings other than annoyance, resentment and disrespect within the wider community of human beings who don't know what to call an App Store if not "App Store" and don't want to be taught to change their ways.


The Cocos Islands prefer
fish to phish ...
Cull in the Cocos.  The Register reports that Google is ejecting more than 11 million websites based on the .co.cc domain from its search results on the ground that their contents are predominantly spam and phish.   The .cc domain is that of the Cocos (or Keeling, if you prefer) Islands, which are somewhere in the Indian Ocean (climate change permitting).  The .co.cc space is not an official second level domain; it happens to be owned by a Korean which, acting as a sort of registry, offers single sub-domains at no cost but lets customers bulk-register 15,000 addresses at a time for just US$1,000.  The IPKat is heartened by this. He has no appetite for spam or phish, but had no idea that an inanimate search engine might get sick of these unpalatable dishes too.


Ready for the rain --
but no-one mentioned
the gale-force wind ...
Next week's star attraction. On Monday and Tuesday next week the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) is holding a summer party hosting a conference to address "the role of innovation and technology in the development and diffusion of green technologies to provide solutions to the challenges posed by climate change". The WIPO Conference on Innovation and Climate Change (as it is to be known) brings together major stakeholders – international organizations, government, industry, and civil society – to focus on innovation partnerships between the public and private sector to develop and diffuse relevant technologies. Says WIPO: "Registration is required for this event, which is open to general public".  Says the IPKat, if climate change is an issue, be sure to bring an umbrella.


Not so much to smile at?
Brazil lags behind Chile
and Costa Rica in
the LA innovation list
Around the blogs.  Should we go back to the principles of unfair competition law when protecting designs, ask the editorial on today's jiplp weblog here. 1709 Blogger Ben Challis explains latest developments in the US on "inform and alert" cooperation between copyright owners and internet service providers.  The SPC Blog is running a competition for which the prize is an amazingly heavy two-volume work, Pharmaceutical, Biotechnology and Chemical Inventions: World Protection and Exploitation, which is edited by the Kat's Australian friend Duncan Bucknell. The SOLO IP blog asks if the new Bribery Act provisions in the UK make any difference to the lives of small and sole IP practitioners.  Writing for IP Tango, Patricia Covarrubia notes how poorly the Latin American nations, including the fabled wonderland of Brazil, score in the INSEAD Global Innovation Index.  Anyone who was bored or intimidated by the admittedly long IPKat post on Edwin v OHIM, Elio Fiorucci can read a shorter, more accessible account on Class 46 here.