Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Facebook. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

More than a polite poke: Shagbook courts trouble in date with Facebook

This Kat has been a user of Facebook since it was cool to use at Oxford -- when it was considered impolite not to respond to a 'poke' within 8 hours. She has never ever heard of Shagbook until writing this post. However, as this Kat quickly discovered, Shagbook is an adult 'dating' website. On the UK homepage of the its website it states:
"Hook up with hot UK singles looking for hot Casual Dating on Shagbook! Search millions of UK singles looking to date for fun, and meet local members near you. Get a date now! Share pics, swap stories, and meet up tonight!"
And when this Kat investigated further, by trying to join the site (the things she does for the IP community!), she was greet with this text:
"We've got thousands of sexy playmates all waiting to be contacted for naughty chat, filthy fun and erotic encounters. To kick start the action we suggest you complete your profile with as much information as possible and add a recent sexy photo. You can then search to see which hot members get your heart racing. And don't forget to send out some cheeky winks or naughty messages to get things going!"
But what could it possibly be that would lead any modest Kat into such unsavoury investigations? Let us explain. On 24 May 2010, SNRG Ventures LLC (a company incorporated in Wyoming USA) applied to register the mark SHAGBOOK in the US in class 45 for computer dating services. The mark was accepted an advertised on 25 January 2011. A representative for SNRG Ventures told Mashable that the name shagbook.com was conceived 'all perfectly innocently': when SNRG's American owner was living in the UK, he 'referred to his little black book as his little "Shagbook" ... He was amused with the word ‘shag’".

Given the nature of the Shagbook website, it is not surprising that acceptance of the mark would be of concern to Facebook. Facebook filed a notice of opposition on 25 May 2011 based on two grounds: likelihood of confusion and dilution of a famous mark.

As to the likelihood of confusion, Facebook (at [12]) alleged that the SHAGBOOK mark was similar to its own registered FACEBOOK marks in respect of 'appearance, sound, meaning and commercial impression'. Facebook (at [15]) also alleged that SNRG adopted the SHAGBOOK mark 'with knowledge of and the intent to call to mind and create a likelihood of confusion with regard to, and/or trade off the fame of Facebook and the registered FACEBOOK marks'. Accordingly, Facebook (at [19]) alleged that the SHAGBOOK mark is likely to 'cause confusion, or to cause mistake or to deceive'.

As for dilution of a famous mark, Facebook (at [25]) argued that, as a result of the enormous publicity afforded to the FACEBOOK marks, they enjoyed 'a high degree of consumer recognition, are widely recognised by the general consuming public of the United States as a designation of Facebook's services, and are famous'. For Facebook (at [34]), 'SNRG's use of the SHAGBOOK mark for online adult dating and social networking services that provides a platform for users to connect with other users for casual sexual encounters tarnishes the famous FACEBOOK marks and harms the reputation of the FACEBOOK marks to Facebook's severe detriment'.

SNRG lodged its response to Facebook's opposition on 25 July 2011 and argued eight distinct defences. First, (at [35]) Facebook did not 'have the exclusive right to use the term “facebook” as the term was in common use in the English language well before Facebook began using the term in connection with its services. Second, Facebook's opposition should 'be denied under the equitable doctrine of unclean hands. This was because, according to SNRG, Facebook had 'engaged in trademark misuse and trademark bullying by abusively usingoppositions, litigation, and threats of the same to maintain a competitive market advantage'. Third, in the alternative (at [37]), if Facebook does have rights to use the term FACEBOOK, there was no tarnishment or dilution because consumers would have understood it to be a reference to a parody and as such authorised by the First Amendment. Fourth (at [38]), the FACEBOOK marks were 'highly diluted already by others using identical or very similar marks, including numerous uses of the term "book" in connection with online networking'. Fifth (at [39]), Facebook should be estopped from arguing that the two websites provide similar service on the basis that Facebook has made 'public statements that its website at facebook.com is not a dating site and in fact has removed individuals from the siteupon discovering that said individuals had been using the site as a “dating site” to meet newpeople for sexual encounters'. Sixth (at [40]), there is no likelihood of confusion between the services provided by both websites. Seventh (at [41]), the registered FACEBOOK should be cancelled or the specification restricted to the goods and services which Facebook actually provides, namely online social networking. Eighth (at [42]), as Facebook has used the term "facebook" in a generic sense, it is estopped from now claiming that it is not generic.

Both parties have indicated that they will vigorously defend their respective marks.

The IPKat will be watching developments with keen interest -- though he trusts that all the action will be in court, not under the covers.

Someone who finds the word 'shag' hilariously funny here
The shag: a poetical observation by Christopher Isherwood here
Popular shag on the floor here
Why shag is for dogs here and here

Merpel,ever modest, would like to make clear that she is not that kind of Kat!

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Plumber cleared of internet harassment

This Kat is always amazed at the opportunities, both for good deeds and for bad deeds, that are available due to advances in internet technology. It is on this basis that she was intrigued by the proceedings against Ian Puddick, a plumber from Enfield, North London, in Westminster Magistrates Court concerning claims of harrassing his wife Leena's millionaire lover, Timothy Haynes, over the internet.


Mrs Puddick met Mr Haynes when she joined the global insurance firm Guy Carpenter as a secretary where he worked as a director in 1997. The affair began after a Christmas party in 2002 and would continue for several years. It was alleged that Mr Haynes sent Mrs Puddick some 30 to 40 text messages a day. Some were sexually explicity such as 'Where do you want to have sex next — in the office, al fresco, at the flat, or all three? You greedy girl'. Others said Mrs Puddick was 'the most desirable girl in the world' and 'reassuringly expensive' because of her lavish taste in champagne.


The affair came to light when Mr Puddick discovered one such text whilst he was sunbathing in his garden and a message came through on Mrs Puddick's phone. The message was from Mr Haynes and included graphic references to a sex act he had performed on Leena, ­accompanied by a picture of him performing a sex act on himself. The pictures were accompanied by the words 'You are such a sensual girl'.

Mr Puddick decided publicise the affair. He contacted Mr Haynes’ boss, his clients and his wife to claim that Mr Haynes had abused his expense account to ­seduce Mrs Puddick. Next, Mr Puddick even spoke at Hyde Park’s Speakers’ Corner in London and camped for seven days outside ­Parliament to tell his story to anyone who would listen. Still enraged, Mr Puddick flooded the internet with evidence of the affair. He created numerous websites with his allegations against Mr Haynes (including videos and excerpts from Mr Haynes’ love letters). He detailed the affair on Twitter and FaceBook and created a fake page on LinkedIn in the name of Mr Haynes so that potential clients would learn of Mr Haynes' behaviour.


Was this harassment?


In the UK, the Protection of Harassment Act 1997 provides both civil and criminal remedies for harassment. In relation to civil provisions, section 1(1) provides that a person must not pursue a course of conduct (a)which amounts to harassment of another, and (b)which he knows or ought to know amounts to harassment of the other. According to section 1(2), the person whose course of conduct is in question ought to know that it amounts to harassment of another if a reasonable person in possession of the same information would think the course of conduct amounted to harassment of the other. In relation to the criminal provisions, section 2(1) states that a person who pursues a course of conduct in breach of section 1 is guilty of an offence. Under section 2(2), a person guilty of an offence under this section is liable on summary conviction to imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months, or a fine not exceeding level 5 on the standard scale, or both. These provisions are sufficiently wide to cover posting on the internet and 'anti harassment' injunctions have been granted in a number of cases to restrain the publication of material on Wikipedia and Facebook.


Ultimately Mr Puddick was charged with two counts of
harassing Mr Haynes and his family on Facebook and Twitter under the criminal provisions in the 1997 Act. After a three day trial in Westmister Magistrates Court, District Judge Elizabeth Roscoe delivered a verdict of not guilty. The judge ruled Puddick's actions did not form a 'course of conduct' and dismissed the charges.

In an interview, Mr Puddick told the Sunday Mirror: 'Haynes abused his position of authority to sleep with my wife, and then he thought he could use his money and influence to bully me all the way to jail. Well this is a ­victory for the little guy over the bullies and it is a victory for free speech'.

The IPKat ponders that in pursuing Mr Puddick for harassment, Mr Haynes gave his philandering such public exposure that it would otherwise have achieved. Indeed, Mr Haynes said in court that 'I think most of the country - thanks to the internet - is aware I had an affair'.

Merpel poses the question: would you have used the internet like Mr Puddick if you found yourself in similar circumstances?

Thursday, June 16, 2011

FaceBook face-off continues

This Kat watched the film The Social Network for the dramatic story of the creation of and ownership claims to FaceBook, the world's most famous social networking site. The film concluded with FaceBook CEO Mark Zuckerberg settling claims in 2008 with twins Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss and with Eduardo Saverin.

Although the film ended (and Academy Awards were collected), the legal wrangling continues. The Winklevoss twins now allege that the settlement which they reached in 2008 with FaceBook should be voided on the basis that it was procured by fraud. In the Federal Courts in San Francisco (California) and in Boston (Massachusetts), they particularly contended that FaceBook and Mr Zuckerberg did not provide an accurate valulation of the company shares before they agreed to settle their claims for US$65 million cash and stocks.

On 11 April 2011, the 9th US Circuit Court in San Francisco (at 4911) found the agreement between the Winklevosses and Facebook barred future lawsuits and was 'quite favorable' to the twins in relation to market activity at the time: The Facebook Inc v ConnectU Inc. The Court concluded (at 4912) with the prophetic words 'At some point, litigation must come to an end. That point has now been reached'.

Despite the forceful position of the lower court, the twins are fighting on. On Monday 13 June 2011, the US Court of Appeals in San Francisco agreed to suspend litigation related to the Winklevosses’ lawsuit until they file a petition with the US Supreme Court to reverse the dismissal of their claims by the 9th US Circuit Court in San Francisco. That means Facebook and Mr Zuckerberg cannot attempt to dismiss the separate lawsuit in the Boston court.

The IPKat thinks that enough is enough. The Winklevoss twins made their agreement in 2008 with the assistance of qualified advisers. They should not be able to avoid an agreement merely because they now want a bigger slice of the pie (or perhaps FaceBook's proposed public float in 2012).

With the parties again firmly entrenched in their positions, Merpel wonders whether someone should line up Aaron Sorkin for The Social Network 2. This one looks like it is set to go on for some time more ...

Friday, May 6, 2011

Now Styles Facebook Photos Children

Thus styles Children Photos Facebook Now .. They no longer think if the pictures they are so vulgar attention.
they seemed to want to show all their body shape .. no longer concerned with the importance of modesty .. vulgar photo as if it was normal for teens right now ..
just yesterday I heard the news about the father of the president's speech Sby on twitter ..
sby feel proud that one of Indonesia's largest state twitter users.
maybe our president does not know what the negative effects of things like this.
president actually feel proud .. should not we kwatir adolescents with behavior-behavior Indonesia today ..? more and more restrictions on sex .. it will be the more behavior is sex in Indonesia.
ironic when I hear a president proud of things like this.
ttp if Indonesia signed the largest state that has no new coruptor dech gw .. .. Salud!




























Klik Gambar Untuk Memperbesar

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Damsel in distress and loss of Facebook

The IPKat, being an inherently gallant Kat, is always moved by entreaties from damsels in distress. One such damsel has emailed him in some anxiety, seeking his advice. She writes:
"My client's business Facebook page has just been removed. When my client asked why, she was told that her page had been "reported for Trade Mark reasons". The Facebook User Operations message went on to say that, when Facebook receives a proper claim of IP infringement, it promptly removes or disables access to the allegedly infringing content --- and, if they believe that the claim has been made under false pretenses, they contact a lawyer etc to discuss the issue with them.

Facebook refuses to talk to me, even though I'm my client's trade mark representative, since it claims that it will only talk to the people responsible for the page. A request was made to see the "proper claim for IP infringement" in order to address this problem, but none was forthcoming.

I believe that a competitor of my client is responsible.

Have you any ideas as to how to address this issue, since my client is losing a considerable amount of business as a result of this".
The IPKat has already listed some legal and practical steps which, he thinks, might be worth pursuing -- but since he hasn't advised on one of these problems before it struck him that it might be a good idea to invoke the combined brainpower of his readers. The distressed damsel agreed -- so do let us know what you think!

Facebook terms and conditions here
Damsels in distress here
Damsons in distress here
Loss of Face here