Showing posts with label Book reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book reviews. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Book reviews


A Practical Guide to Working with TRIPS, by Antony Taubman, reminds the IPKat a little bit of the position that the ancient Greek mythological figure and blind seer Tiresias.  Having spent time both as a man and as a woman, he was asked by Greek gods Zeus and Hera which of the two derived more pleasure from a particular pastime which it it lies beyond the realm of merely fictional cats to discuss.  Tactlessly deciding that Zeus was right to say that it was the female of the species who had more fun, he was struck blind by Hera by way of punishment.  Now, Antony is in an analogous position, having worked for both the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the World Trade Organization (WTO), to say which has the more control over the destiny of intellectual property rights as embodied in TRIPS. What is his answer? Which is the more fun? Readers will have to read this book and decide for themselves.

Oxford University Press, which have had the good fortune to publish this handy little work (handy because it is easily handled, little because all the publishable practical guidance in the world can't add up to a whole lot more than the author reveals here), says this:
"This book is a concise and accessible guide to the practical workings of the TRIPS agreement ...  for policymakers and their legal advisers. The book offers a unique insider's account of how the international rules of IP function in practice within a broader legal framework that consists of WTO law and dispute resolution procedures. It clarifies how IP law and trade law must be dealt with in a coherent and sustainable manner, and provides practical guidance on how to read public policy objectives into the formulation and application of IP laws and related regulation, within the legal framework established by TRIPS. The book is concise and clear, and cuts through the textual clutter and complexity that afflicts policymaking and negotiation under the TRIPS regime. 
Readership: Policymakers in government, and their legal advisers, international organizations, civil society, industry, academia, government officials, trade negotiators, and legal practitioners operating in the international intellectual property field would all be interested in this book".
This blogger has been trying to interest legal practitioners in TRIPS for the past 15 years or so, with conspicuously little success, and wouldn't want to think that his pension fund somehow depended on the number of practitioners that would be running off (or clicking on) to their favourite bookshop to buy this book. However,judging by the number of academics in post and students writing their theses and dissertations who have chosen TRIPS as at least part of their subject, there should be no shortage of customers for it.  One point to note: European readers will know that TRIPS has developed a body of case law and accompanying commentary of its own within the European Union, where the extent to which TRIPS is part of EU law, is enforceable in European courts and so on.  That subset of TRIPS-related activity lies outside the scope of this book and, in the opinion of this blogger, awaits a little book of its own.

Bibliographic data.  xxi + 227 pages. Paperback. ISBN 978-0-19-957520-6. Price: £39.95. Rupture factor: trivial. Book's web page here.


Landmark Intellectual Property Cases and Their Legacy, edited by Christopher Heath and Anselm Kamperman Sanders, is an offering from Wolters Kluwer which scoops the content of one of the Institute of European Studies of Macau (IEEM)  international IP conferences. The publisher explains what this book's theme is all abou:
"This is a book dedicated to the significance and legacy of landmark cases in the field of intellectual property. Eleven well-known scholars offer in-depth commentary and analysis of cases that have made an impact on legal theory or critical thinking about the scope and purpose of the protection of intellectual and industrial creativity. All the cases covered have proven useful in developing doctrine, even though subsequent developments have made some appear ‘misleading’ rather than ‘leading’, and for some recent cases it is too early to say whether their approach will become mainstream. ...
The book concludes with an analysis of two case clusters remarkable for the worldwide dimension of the dispute. The authors show how litigation over Lego in about 30 jurisdictions and Budweiser in over 40 jurisdictions has enriched doctrine on such issues as contract, trade marks, trade names, geographical indications, property rights in general, human rights, and various international and bilateral treaties, all as they impinge on the protection of intellectual property rights. For scholars in the field, as well as for lawyers seeking a rich vein of doctrine to buttress a case, this unusual book will be of incomparable value. As a masterful clarification of salient doctrine, it represents a major contribution to the legal theory underpinning intellectual property law".
Some books which are compilations of works of individual scholars are described as publications in which the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. This book, I feel, is rather the other way round -- it is a little less than the sum of its parts.In the first place, I would personally have enjoyed a longer, more reasoned Preface than the very short (less than two sides) offering placed before readers, seeking to justify their "greatest hits" theme more rigorously, discussing some of the interesting issues of methodology that arise in the definition and selection of landmark cases and contrasting the validity of the concept in common law jurisdictions in precedent is binding, or at least highly influential, and those where it is said to be of less import. Secondly, since a not insubstantial quantity of case law is referred to in some of the chapters, a table of cases would have been appreciated.  Thirdly, I would have liked a clearer explanation of what Peter Yu's (excellent) chapter on Moral Rights 2.0 was doing in this collection, since it analyses a subject, not a landmark case, and the single sentence with which it opens is insufficient in my opinion to link it to the theme of the rest of the book: it's a bit like opening a jar of pickled herring and finding, in its midst, a chocolate truffle.

This apart, the book is an enjoyable read -- particularly the reviews of the global Lego and Budweiser litigation, which make one tremble to imagine what might have happened if the Danish brickmaker had ever picked a legal fight with Anheuser-Busch. Most of the cases are landmarks in the light of what happened after them, though in the case of eBay v MerceXchange this review remains convinced that its landmark status was conferred by what happened before the decision, like a hurricane that builds up its momentum, instills massive fear and then misses its supposed victims.


Bibliographic data: xxii + 247 pages. Hardback. ISBN 9041133437 and 13: 9789041133434. Price US$ $162. Rupture factor: low. Book's web page here.


Intellectual Property And Biotechnology, edited by Arti K. Rai (Elvin R. Latty Professor of Law, Duke Law School, Durham, US), is the latest in Edward Elgar Publishing's series of Critical Concepts in Intellectual Property Law.It's a difficult book to review in the round, like any compilation of previously published articles which were not based on the same theme or premise (cf the 'landmark cases' theme of the book reviewed above), where there is a broad spread of time between the earliest and latest studies.

According to the publishers:
"In this timely volume Professor Arti Rai brings together a wide range of articles that reveal the important role of intellectual property law in the formation and development of the dynamic and economically significant biotechnology industry.

The collection encompasses theoretical articles that present principles of patent economics important to the industry, articles that discuss the patent law doctrines most relevant to biotechnology and empirical studies on the ‘real world’ effects of patents and secrecy. These are resonant issues in an ever-expanding field, and will establish this book as an essential reference point for lawyers, researchers and students".
This is all true. It is a worthy collection which matches its description. There should however be a little notice somewhere to the effect that its contents are essentially United States-derived and United States-oriented. Without it, one might be forgiven for thinking that European scholarship and endeavour, whether in law, economics or biotechnology itself, is non-existent.

Bibliographic data: xxi + 561 pages. Hardback. ISBN 978 1 84844 261 0. Price £185 (or, if you buy it online from the publisher, £166.50).  Rupture factor: above average. Book's web page here.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

IP, fundamentals and human development: all in a day's reviewing work ...

The third edition of Fundamentals of US Intellectual Property Law. Copyright, Patent, Trademark, by the triumvirate of Sheldon W. Halpern, Craig Allen Nard and Kenneth L. Port, has recently come whizzing across the IPKat's desk. This book, which emerged from a companion study for the Kluwer International Encyclopaedia of Intellectual Property (here), has one endearing factor which caused him to warm to it before he even opened it, which is its sheer manageability. Anyone who has ever come close to getting to grips with US IP law will know that it is pretty well endless. Look at those footnotes: even case citations seem to run forever and nothing is so small and insignificant as to merit being omitted from the magnificent multi-volume works and menacing loose-leafs that are the best arguments in favour of (i) large and reinforced bookcases, (ii) bigger offices in which to house one's personal collection of essential texts or (ii) e-books.

Anyway, this book does us non-US folk a favour by helping us gain a reasonable and holistic perspective of the structure and function of the US IP law corpus without having to measure every molecule of it.  As the book's blurb says:
"This completely revised and up to date Third Edition of this well received work offers in one volume a comprehensive review of United States copyright, patent, and trademark laws. It provides thorough and sophisticated treatment of this complex material in a form both less cumbersome than a treatise and considerably deeper and more sophisticated than a study outline or “nutshell”. With its detailed citations, and readily accessible and complete subject coverage, this book will be a useful quick reference or desk book for intellectual property practitioners, students, law professors, and librarians, as well as for anyone interested in understanding American intellectual property law".
The Kat's not sure about the reference to librarians. Many are truly wonderful, but he has had some painful encounters with them in the course of his career -- particularly one who refused to provide him with a copy of one of his own articles on the ground that the library would be infringing copyright (his own copyright, it should be added).  Also, a special message to some of them could be printed at the bottom of each page, reminding them that while the law they quote back at him was almost certainly current at the time they read it, it does have a nasty habit of changing at some unspecified time in the future.

The team of three authors is spearheaded by Sheldon Halpern, who is personally known to this Kat as a good guy and a natural communicator of tricky IP concepts in a way that makes them interesting as well as accessible. He and his colleagues have done us all a favour with this little book, not that the more scholarly of us would ever admit to reading it ...


Bibliographic data. ISBNs 9041133429 and 13: 9789041133427. xxiv + 428 pp. The web page here says it's got hard covers but the Kat's copy is floppy. Rupture factor? No problem!




A totally different type of book is Intellectual Property and Human Development: Current Trends and Future Scenarios, edited by Tzen Wong (Public Interest Intellectual Property Advisors) and the IPKat's friend and one-time colleague at Queen Mary and the Jerusalem Tavern, Professor Graham Dutfield (University of Leeds). These two lead a cast of contributors which contains many names hitherto unknown to the Kat, who is pleased to encounter them in this volume.

The first hurdle this reviewer had to overcome was the title. The IP bit was fine, but what could the 'human development' bit be about? Was this something about embryos hatching out into the next generation of creators, competitors and consumers? The Cambridge University Press web-blurb came to his rescue with this explanation:

"This book examines the social impact of intellectual property laws. It addresses issues and trends relating to health, food security, education, new technologies, preservation of bio-cultural heritage and contemporary challenges in promoting the arts [is that all, wonders Merpel]. It explores how intellectual property frameworks could be better calibrated to meet socio-economic needs in countries at different stages of development, with local contexts and culture in mind [Ah -- a bespoke IP environment, in place of the one-size-fits-all which is so loved by tidy-minded treaty drafters and harmonisation addicts!]. A resource for policy-makers, stakeholders, non-profits and students, this volume furthermore highlights alternative modes of innovation that are emerging to address such diverse challenges as neglected or resurgent diseases in developing countries and the harnessing of creative possibilities on the Internet. The collected essays emphasize not only fair access by individuals and communities to intellectual property – protected material, whether a cure, a crop variety, clean technology, a textbook or a tune – but also the enhancement of their own capabilities in cultural participation and innovation".
This is actually one of the sort of books that this Kat reads only with reluctance, bracing himself for the onslaught on IP rights which he is sure is about to follow, only to be disappointed that there is no onslaught after all and little opportunity to deploy the righteous indignation he had been preparing -- just some constructive comments and well-made suggestions as to how the system (systems, really) could be improved and made, well, fairer. 


Bibliographic data. Paperback, l + 397 pages. ISBN: 9780521138284. Price £19.99.  l + 397 pages. Web page here. Rupture factor: minimal.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

IP and competition: some recent publications

Intellectual Property and Competition is the title of a collection of contributions edited by the affable Michael Carrier (Rutgers School of Law-Camden, US).  This volume belongs to the Critical Concepts in Intellectual Property Law series, which rolls out under the watchful eye of Berkeley's formidable Robert Merges.

According to the publishers,
"The intersection of the intellectual property and competition laws presents uniquely complicated legal issues. In this essential volume Professor Carrier brings together 14 of the most important works written about the intersection. The entries, from leading judges, government officials, academics, and economists, explore history, the ‘new economy’, and frameworks to resolve the tension between the laws. They also address refusals to license, patent pools, innovation markets, standard setting organizations, and pharmaceutical patent settlements. Alongside an original introduction, this book is an authoritative reference tool for attorneys, academics, and others interested in intellectual property and competition issues.".
This is all very well and true.  The IP/competition interface is confoundedly complex and is a great deal more frustrating for lawyers than it is for economists.  The economist 'only' has to explain, prescribe and analyse within the parameters of his discipline.  The lawyer, faced with the same intersection, must tell his client which path he must take when he reaches it, what risks he will avoid if he does and what consequences he will incur if he doesn't.  The lawyer gets it in the neck when his caution results in loss or diminution of market control; he also gets it if he steers his client into the one-way alley of anticompetitive practice from which there is no easy, dignified and discreet means of backing out.  This book tackles some of the most awkward issues full-on -- patent thickets and patent pools are two of the most intractable -- as well as the more malleable issue of standard-setting. The editor has chosen his contributors, and the contributions, with the skilled eye of the connoisseur, to the benefit of the serious student of this tricky topic.

Can this be a European economist
with an interest in the IP/competition
interface -- or is it just another Yeti?
What this book does not do is to warn the casual reader that it is confined to the experience, the history and the analysis of the United States.  Anyone reading it might be forgiven at times for thinking that Europe, whether as a continent or as an economic and increasingly political union which is twice the size of that of the US, simply does not exist.  What the publisher might wish to consider is the possibility of bringing out a companion volume, along similar lines to this one (which should not be difficult since the major problems faced in the US are faced in Europe too) but which focuses on the history and evolution of the European competition regime and its curious, ambivalent relationship with IP law and practice.  Unlike the Yeti and Father Christmas, European economists who write on IP do exist, and the primary sources generated by the European Commission and Court of Justice in their investigations under Articles 81/82, 85/86 and 101/102 of the relevant version of the Treaty make fascinating reading.

Bibliographical data. Hardback. xx + 753 pages. ISBN 978 1 84844 218 4. Price £220 (online from the publisher's website £198).  Rupture factor: severe. Book's web page here.


Oliver on Free Movement of Goods in the European Union (Fifth Edition), is still happily edited by Peter J Oliver, but with the support of a small army of contributors: Stefan Enchelmaier, Malcolm Jarvis, Angus Johnston, Sven Norberg, Christopher Stothers and Stephen Weatherill. The title has undergone a subtle change, 'Community' being changed to 'Union', and the book feels a little heavier, though that might be something to do with all those long, ponderous sentences in which the Court of Justice so enjoys couching its thoughts.  Writes the publisher:
"... whether advising clients or preparing for teaching there is no European lawyer who can afford not to have a copy of this book close to hand [Publishers always think academics can afford books.  Academics know they can't, which is why they review them and get to keep the review copy]. Concise, precise, and lucid, the book has become the first port of call [indeed, an 'essential facility' as we competition lawyers like to say] for anyone seeking answers to questions about the foundations of free movement of goods in the EU. With specialist chapters written by leading academic and practising lawyers, including Peter Oliver himself, this edition has been extensively rewritten to take into account recent judgments from the ECJ, including important cases such as C-110/05 Commission v Italy ("trailers") and C- 142/05 Mickelsson ("jet skis") [oh dear, the Kat didn't spot this one when it was decided, but it does mention the free movement of goods ... just], both of which relate to restrictions on the use of goods. It also takes account of all the recent European legislation and the impact of the Lisbon Treaty".
The Kat has taken a tour round this book and has to confess that it lives up to all the nice things the publisher's blurb says about it.  Books don't usually get to a fifth edition unless (i) they're pretty useful or (ii) the author pays to have them published.  This book is definitely in the first of those categories.

Bilbiographical data. Hardback. xciii + 534 pages. 9781841138107 Price £95. Rupture factor: medium. Web page here.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Some copyright books, Part II

Copyright Enforcement on the Internet, a collection of essays edited by Irini Stamatoudi, is the latest in the excellent Information Law Series which Bernt Hugenholtz edits for Wolters Kluwer Law & Business. Given the current degree of interest in enforcing copyright online, as well as the huge evidential, jurisdictional and financial problems facing anyone who seeks to do so, it is no surprise that authors and publishers are united in their determination to produce saleable titles that address these issues. It also seems to this Kat that, where there are few or no reliable practitioners' manuals, even the most hardened and cynical of practitioners are more than happy to turn to a well-presented argument by an academician.  This book will undoubtedly be of use to them.  According to the publishers:
"Although copyright enforcement has always been a controversial issue, it took the advent of the Internet to raise a fundamental challenge to its very raison d’être. Legislative activity in this area during recent years clearly demonstrates the extent to which enforcement has been brought to the forefront of attention, as owners of copyrights find themselves trying to supersede the limitations of law in order to respond effectively to the reproductive power of new technologies. This timely collection of essays by European and international authorities in the field of copyright law presents a variety of valuable perspectives on the multitude of issues arising in respect of copyright enforcement on the Internet, including the following:
  • the collection of evidence for allegation of infringement;
  • identifying the infringer;
  • jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments;
  • liability of Internet service providers;
  • balancing copyright, data protection, and privacy;
  • considerations of social policy and human rights;
  • cost and efficiency of data availability on the Internet;
  • exchanges of information and mutual assistance among enforcement authorities;
  • criminal liability on the Internet;
  • combating piracy in the digital environment; and
  • prospects for a common regulatory framework. 
Most of the existing European Union and international policies are considered in some depth, and the authors also discuss a variety of national laws and initiatives, technical measures, and the soft law and hard law models that have been proposed. In the years to come, as more and more lawyers are confronted with issues involving copyright enforcement on the Internet, this book’s value as a springboard to the informed future development of this area of legal theory and practice will become more evident. For this reason, as well as for its richly detailed treatment of trends and current reality in the field, it is sure to be read and put to good use by business people, international lawyers, government officials, and interested academics in all parts of the world"
The IPKat wishes that this excellent book (and indeed all collections of essays) had an inter-chapter list of citations of treaties, statutes, conventions, cases etc so that there was a handy way (i) to find them in the first place and (ii) to see whether two or more authors, in their respective chapters, have cited or analysed the same sources.  He appreciates that this takes labour, but isn't that what computers are for?

Bibliographical data: hardback, xviii + 351 pages. ISBN 904 113 346 1; ISBN 13: 978 904113 346 5. Price $182.  Rupture factor: moderate (but the pointy corners are quite sharp). Web page here.


Collective Management of Copyright and Related Rights (second edition), edited by the eminent scholar Daniel Gervais (Vanderbilt University Law School), is also published by Wolters Kluwer, though not as part of its Information Law Series.  This Kat has found it difficult to focus on Gervais the Copyright Man rather than on Gervais the TRIPS Commentator since the Daniel Gervais brand is so closely associated in his mind with the patient embroidery of loose threads that constitute the bits leading up to and following on from TRIPS, as well as with the careful, close analysis of the TRIPS text itself.  It's a bit like watching a John Wayne movie in which the late JW, far removed from his military heroics, is playing the role of a bespectacled bank clerk.

Wolters Kluwer presumably has no such trouble, and indeed it is good to see that Daniel Gervais is (as this Kat already knew in his heart of hearts) a lot more than a one-trick pony.  While he doesn't play all the instruments in the orchestra, he certainly knows how to conduct it, since he has fused a number of distinguished soloists into a pretty useful band.

What's the book about? The title's a bit of a giveaway, but the publishers still have this to say:
"In the course of the last decade, collective management organizations (CMOs) have become the nerve centres of copyright licensing in virtually every country. Their expertise and knowledge of copyright law and management have proven essential to make copyright work in the digital age. This book, an extensively revised and updated edition of the only major work on the legal status of CMOs, offers an in-depth analysis of the various operating CMO models, their rights and obligations vis-à-vis both users and members, acquisition of legal authority to license, and (most important) the rights to license digital uses of protected material and build (or improve current) information systems to deal with ever more complex rights management and licensing tasks. All the chapters have been updated since the 2005 edition, and a new chapter on multiterritorial licensing has been added. Factors considered include the following:
• role of ‘families’ such as the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers (CISAC) and the International Federation of Reproduction Rights Organizations (IFRRO);
• cases where the unavailability of adequate licensing options makes authorized use impossible;
• growing importance of extended repertoire systems (also known as extended collective licensing);
• relationship among collective management, rights to remuneration, and the ways in which CMOs acquire authority to license;
• transnational licensing and the possible role of multi-territorial licensing; and
• threat of monopolies or regional oligopolies for the management of online music rights.
Legal underpinnings covered in the course of the analysis include the 1996 WIPO Copyright Treaties, the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act, the Napster case, the Santiago Agreement, relevant EU Papers and the Copyright Directive, and work done by the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. 
... Whatever the future of copyright holds, it is clear that users will continue to want access and the ability to reuse material lawfully, and authors and other rightsholders will want to ensure that they can put some reasonable limits on those uses. CMOs are sure to be critical intermediaries in this process. The second edition of this important resource, with its key insights into the changing nature of collective management, will be of immeasurable value to all concerned with shaping policy towards collective management or working with the ever more complex legal issues arising in digital age copyright matters".
The subject is an important one and this review still believes that collective management and/or online metrics for pay-per-use and pay-per-access are the most promising means of keeping copyright owners fed for foreseeable future.  The price reflects the fact that many organisations which manage rights will be obliged to buy it -- and they will not be disappointed, unless they like writing notes on the margins of the printed page, in which case they had better shrink their handwriting.


Biblographic data: hardback: xxii + 495 pages.  ISBN 9041127240, ISBN 13: 978 904112 724 2. Price $257.  Rupture factor: moderate. Web page here.

Some copyright books, Part I

Global Copyright: Three Hundred Years Since the Statute of Anne, from 1709 to Cyberspace, is a collection of essays edited by the academic triumvirate of Lionel Bently (Herchel Smith Professor of Intellectual Property Law, University of Cambridge), Uma Suthersanen (Professor in International Intellectual Property Law, Queen Mary, University of London) and Paul Torremans (Professor of Intellectual Property Law, School of Law, University of Nottingham). The IPKat holds all three in great esteem for a variety of reasons and begs to remind his Queen Mary colleague Uma that either she owes him a drink or vice versa ...

Edward Elgar Publishing -- which is becoming an integral part of the IP publishing environment these days -- has this to say about the book:
"This innovative book celebrates the tricentenary of modern copyright, which began with the enactment of the Statute of Anne by the British Parliament in 1709, and was soon followed by other copyright legislation abroad. The Statute of Anne is traditionally claimed to be the world’s first copyright statute, and is thus viewed as the origin of a system of national laws that today exists in virtually all countries of the world. However, this book illustrates that while there is some truth in this claim, it is also important to treat it with caution.

Written by leading experts from across the globe, this comprehensive (historical) analysis breaks new ground on modern copyright issues such as digital libraries, illegal downloading and distribution, international exhaustion and ‘new formalities’. The expert contributors consider what lessons can be learnt from the achievements made during the last 300 years, and whether they can be used to overcome the new challenges facing copyright".

This in-depth scientific analysis of the legacy of the Statute of Anne 300 years on from its origins will provide copyright practitioners, academics, policy makers and postgraduate students with a unique and fascinating read.".
The IPKat is amused by the contrast between copyright's past, which we are coming increasingly to understand and to appreciate, and its future, which appears as a succession of economic, commercial and technological uncertainties to which the 18th and 19th century solution (private monopolies, individually enforced) and its 20th century successors (collective licensing and management) are struggling to adjust.

The cast of contributors is almost a reflection of the history of modern scholarship itself: diverse in its legal and philosophical roots, and perfectly capable of challenging long-held assumptions.  Of particular interest to this author is Christophe Geiger's essay on the past and present influence of the Statute of Anne on France which, together with Joris Deene's little piece on Anne's influence on Belgium, show that the minds of lawyers and policymakers in civilian Continental Europe are far from closed to foreign thought.

This volume makes for a most enjoyable and thought-provoking read.  This Kat hopes he doesn't have to wait another 300 years for the next such themed collection.

Bibliographic data: paperback, xiii + 522 pages.  The rest is a bit hazy.  The website lists the book's hardback details, which are ISBN 978 1 84844 766 0 and a price of £125 (online price £112.50 from the publisher). Rupture factor: mild.


Moral Rights: Principles, Practice and New Technology, by Mira T. Sundara Rajan, has been recently published by the US branch of Oxford University Press. Mira, who now occupies the Canada Research Chair in IP Law at the University of British Columbia, has also been touched by the magic wand of Queen Mary, where she was all-too-briefly a colleague of this reviewer.  Mira's is the second book on moral rights to emerge within the recent past, the first being the magisterial reference work by Gillian Davies and Kevin Garnett which was published by Sweet & Maxwell late last year (reviewed here). About this book the publisher explains that this is an entirely different sort of book so, if you thought that by spending £165 on Davies and Garnett you wouldn't want to buy another book on the topic, you'd be wrong:
"The doctrine of moral rights is based on the idea that authors have a special bond with their own creative work. At present, the legal status of moral rights demands clarification and assessment as never before, as the international expansion of moral rights occurs in the new environment of digital technology. Just as the survival of copyright law depends on its capacity to adapt effectively to the new technological environment, a new approach to moral rights is also necessary.

Moral Rights: Principles Practice and New Technology is the first work to comprehensively address the role of moral rights in an environment of digital technology, identifying the challenges and confronting moral rights in a digital environment. The challenges are addressed in both practical and theoretical terms, and examples drawn from the legislation and practice of key jurisdictions around the world. Moral Rights concludes with a consideration of how the concept of moral rights can contribute to the re-shaping of copyright law in a digital context."
The book builds from the foundations of moral rights in France and Germany, where their pedigree was quite respectable, and in the United Kingdom, where their legitimacy was not so widely accepted, before projecting them on to the larger canvases of Canada and the United States.  Mira also conducts a particularly interesting investigation into the points of intersection of the inherently personal concept of the moral right with the collaborative, more self-denying open source movement and other digital collectivities. Unlike some commentators who proclaim the death of moral rights, which they welcome on account of its obsolescence, Mira takes a more constructive approach: why jettison an old concept if you can find a new use or application for it?

Bibliographic data: paperback. xxi + 549 pages. ISBN 978-0-19-539031-5.  Price £95. Rupture factor: low. Book's web page here.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Something to read, Part II

There was once a law firm called Hammonds, but now we have learned to call it Squire Sanders Hammonds: that's the name on the cover of E-Commerce and Convergence: A Guide to the Law of Digital Media, the 4th edition of which has recently been published by Bloomsbury Professional under the general editorship of Mike Butler, who heads the firm's media team. As a former in-houser at what used to be Sun Microsystems (now Oracle), he must know a few things about the topic -- particularly the convergence bits of it which, while often exhilarating for consumers and exciting for salesmen, can be a real pain for others. Just imagine how you'd feel, as a car manufacturer, if a maker of fridges came up with a new model that cruised at a comfortably 120 kph on the local Autobahn. That's the sort of thing makers of phones, cameras, computers, printers, scanners, televisions and more besides have had to worry about.

Anyway, this is what the publisher has to say about it:
E-commerce and Convergence: A Guide to the Law of Digital Media recognises that electronic convergence – the coming together of the internet, broadcasting and content – has at last arrived [it would be difficult not to ...]. This book is the first text of its kind to bring together the disparate laws relating to digital content and online commercial activity [not quite. There is, for example, this Kat's E-Commerce and IT Law Handbook, here -- but Mike Butler's book is the first to seek to explain them in some sort of meaningfully converging context]. It explains the laws relating to issues as diverse as user generated content, video-on-demand, cookies and paid for searching.

The book is a practical guide aimed at both commercial executives and in-house counsel. It highlights issues not always immediately familiar to those who work with digital content including in particular laws relating to data. However, it is also a useful guide for any business starting or growing its on-line presence, especially with chapters relating to on-line contracting and branding.
With thick paper. plenty of charts and things, plus a useful glossary, you can actually get through this book much more quickly than the subject matter suggests. The text-in-boxes bits are sometimes too long to be elegant, since boxes in this Kat's opinion should never be allowed to stray over a page-turn. However the team, which includes the ever-insightful Chris McLeod, has done an admirable job.  Well done!

Bibliographic data: hardback, xxxiv + 240 pages.  ISBN 978-1-84592-452-2.  Rupture factor: low. Price £125, even if you buy it directly from the publisher here.


The IPKat kept putting off the review of this book because it looked, frankly, a bit too earnest and serious and he always had other books to read which had more enjoyable-sounding titles. Let's face it, if you're faced with Innovation, Competition And Consumer Welfare In Intellectual Property Law, you know it isn't going to be a light read.  There is however a well-known maxim about not judging a book by its cover; the same should be recognised with regard to not judging a book by its title, since this work, by the eminent Italian academic Gustavo Ghidini (Professor of Intellectual Property and Competition Law, University of Milan, among other things), is neither difficult nor dull. It is not however expected that the next edition will be called Harry Potter and the Consumer Welfairies.

Now what does the publisher, Edward Elgar Publishing, have to say about this work?
"This authoritative book provides a comprehensive critical overview of the basic IP paradigms, such as patents, trademarks and copyrights. Their intersection with competition law and their impacts on the exercise of social welfare are analysed from an evolutionary perspective.

The analyses and proposals presented encompass the features and rationales of a legal field in constant evolution, and relate them to increasingly rapid technological, economic, social and geo-political developments. Gustavo Ghidini highlights the emerging trends that challenge the traditional ‘all-exclusionary’ vision of IP law and its application. The author expertly combines holistic, evolutionary and constitutionally oriented approaches, with the search for a rebalancing of the IP rights holders’ positions with citizens’ and users’ rights.

This book will appeal to academics, scholars and lawyers specializing in the realm of intellectual property, competition and comparative law".
While there is some commonality of subject matter and perhaps even of purpose between this book and that of William Kingston (reviewed here), both the style and the substance of their critical appraisals of IP differ in many respects. If you go for the one, be sure to read the other.

Bibliographic data: hardback, xix + 279 pages.  ISBN 978-1-84720-970-2. Rupture factor: low.  Price £75, but you can get it for only £67.50 from the publisher's website here.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Patents: some light reading for a rainy day

This post features four very different recent publications in the field of patents.  If you are going on (i) a long journey, (ii) a short journey on the London Underground system or (iii) any journey at all which involves you having to pass through any British Airport Authority air terminal when all flights in and out of London have been grounded by the turbulent effect of butterflies flapping their cute little wings in Tuvalu, you may want to read them all, one after the other.  If you are more selective, discerning or (as we lawyers like to say) specialised, one or two only will suffice.  The four books are:


* Figures of Invention: a History of Modern Patent Law, by academics Alain Pottage and Brad Sherman and published by Oxford University Press.  Based in London but presumably not stuck in transit, Alain Pottage is a Reader in Law at the London School of Economics and Political Science, just down the road from this Kat's Holborn office, while Brad Sherman, now Professor of Law at the Griffith University, Brisbane, was formerly attached to the same institution.  According to the publisher,

"Taking the invention as its object of study, this book develops a radical new perspective on the making of modern patent law. It develops an extended historical and conceptual exploration of the invention in modern patent law. Focusing primarily on the figures that make inventions material, and on how to overcome the intangibility of ideas, this intellectually challenging book makes explicit a dimension of patent law that is not commonly found in traditional commentaries, treatises and cases.

The story is told from the perspective of the material media in which the intangible form of the invention is made visible; namely, models, texts, drawings, and biological specimens [This makes it conceptually stimulating to read, which is what the authors intend, but correspondingly a bit tricky to use as a conventional patent reference work]. This approach brings to light for the first time some essential formative moments in the history of patent law. For example, Figures of Invention describes the central role that scale models played in the making of nineteenth-century patent jurisprudence, the largely mythical character of the nineteenth-century theory that patents texts should function as a means of disclosing inventions [hang on there, some readers still believe this theory -- and it's more credible than Santa existing or Elvis still being alive ...!], and the profound conceptual changes that emerged from debates as to how to represent and disclose the first biological inventions [this has repercussions even now: we can ask whether the Budapest Treaty on the Deposit Microorganisms is still fit for purpose]. At the same time, this historical inquiry also reveals the basic conceptual architecture of modern patent law. The story of how inventions were represented is also the story of the formation of the modern concept of invention, or of the historical processes that shaped the terms in which patent lawyers still apprehend the intangible form of the invention.

Although the analysis focuses on the history of patent law in the United States, it develops themes that illuminate the evolution of patent regimes in Europe [In this regard, the US is the sun to Europe's moon. Europe reflects events and debates which are earlier and usually more articulately expressed in the US]. In combining close historical analysis with broad thematic reflection, Figures of Invention makes a distinctive contribution both to the field of patent law scholarship and to emerging interdisciplinary debates about the constitution of patent law and of intellectual property in general. ".
The IPKat enjoyed this book, and its approach, which he happily commends to anyone who already knows a bit about patent law and wants a book that will enhance his understanding without in any sense intimidating him.  The book is almost too short, since it almost leaves the reader wanting to know what happens next. Some of the footnotes are naughtily long and contain content which might, on reconsideration, be of sufficient importance to promote above the line, but that does nothing to detract from the pleasure of reading this work.

Bibliographic data: Hardback, xi + 212 pages.  ISBN 978-0-19-959563-1. Price: £70. web page here.  Rupture factor: none.


* Rules of Patent Drafting: Guidelines from Federal Circuit Case Law, by Joseph E. Root, is also published by Oxford University Press but, unlike Pottage and Sherman, this tome emanates from OUP's busy, bustling, practice-oriented New York desk.  The author set up his own company, QualiPat, to develop an innovative programme for teaching patent drafting and has had the personal satisfaction of being able to implement that programme with UnitedLex, a legal consulting, technology and outsourcing firm, where he created a team from a group of engineers.  But does this book give personal satisfaction too?  Says the publisher's blurb:

"Patents are invalidated every day for reasons often stemming from avoidable error [Isn't that what judges are for?]  Rules of Patent Drafting: Guidelines from Federal Circuit Case Law helps patent drafters avoid such errors with a set of patent drafting rules derived from Federal Circuit decisions. By focusing on drafting principles, instead of abstract legal concepts, the reader gains a coherent, integrated understanding of what the Federal Circuit requires. The rules point the way to confident drafting.

Rules of Patent Drafting: Guidelines from Federal Circuit Case Law addresses a major development in patent law over the last two decades - the Disclosure Revolution. Claim construction now depends more on support from the specification than any other factor, and other determinants of validity have followed suit [Can this be the "the largely mythical character of the nineteenth-century theory that patents texts should function as a means of disclosing inventions" to which Pottage and Sherman allude?] Written description, the doctrine of equivalents, and definiteness, all look to the specification to determine the application of each of these doctrines, and others as well. This book guides the drafter in meeting all the requirements that the Federal Circuit has set out for patent validity. Beyond demonstrating how to ensure bare validity, the book goes further to illustrate techniques for achieving desired coverage through rules teaching breadth in drafting, claiming, and prosecuting [Breadth is not for the faint-hearted -- woe to the applicant whose claims run wider than his invention!]

The rules-based approach to patent drafting provides a clear framework to assist both the beginner and the experienced practitioner [and you have the comfort of telling your client, if anything goes wrong, that it's not your fault because you kept to the rules]. A learner is guided through the facets of a rule piece by piece, looking to the Federal Circuit rationale for each clause. Seasoned drafters can quickly update themselves or clarify specific points with precision. For either reader, the clear exposition communicates essential information rapidly and thoroughly".
Says the IPKat, this helpful book saves the best bits for the end.  The last 100 pages or so are taken up with an extensive section on Avoiding Problems which is worth a read on its own, both for its functional utility and for its practical and realistic appraisal of the specific issues of inventorship and priority regarding which the unique provisions of US law are apt to seem so puzzling to the rest-of-the-worldies who might be reading it.  The author also reminds readers that the appropriate time to address problems is before they happen -- a piece of advice that readers might do well to carry with them beyond the portals of patent law and into the great wide world that lurks beyond it.

Bibliographic data: Paperback, xxxvi + 477 pages. ISBNs 13: 9780199734924 and 10: 0199734925. Price: $225. Book's web page here.  Rupture factor: none.


* DON'T File a Patent! is a book of passion, enthusiasm and of an unquenchable determination to persuade the reader of the virtues of the author's case.  The author, John D. Smith of Orlando, Florida, is no admirer of the patent system.  He is witty, knowledgeable and quick to identify faults in the ponderous patchwork of bureaucratic and professional practices which is the US patent system today.  While the comments contained in this self-published book are directed at the US system, readers from other jurisdictions may easily recognise the applicability of the author's barbs to targets nearer home.


How does the author characterise his book?  He explains in his own words:

"DON’T File a Patent! is the first and only book that shows you why NOT to file a patent application on your invention. In this book, you will learn that the Patents Office wants the inventor’s money, not their invention. You will see the roadblocks the Patents Office uses to discourage inventors with their repeated Patent Office patent application rejections. These Patent Office patent application rejections require inventors to continually re-submit their patent application and pay thousands in additional government filing fees, before their patent application are ultimately turned down.

Inventors who create innovative intellectual property like patents, trademarks and copyrights are told by their patent attorney or patent lawyer that they should protect their intellectual property rights and secure patent protection by doing a patent search and then file a patent application and a trademark application.

In this book, I’ll give you over 10 reasons why you should NOT file a Patent Application on your invention. You’ll learn that Utility Patents and patent protection are worthless and does not stop someone from copying your invention. You’ll learn that a patent attorney or patent lawyer will encourage inventors to file patent infringement lawsuits for the patent attorney benefit, not
to benefit the inventor or his invention. You’ll learn that infringement lawsuits are very expensive and the only one that will make money in a patent infringement lawsuit will be your patent attorney. You’ll see that Judgments gained as a result of expensive patent infringement litigation are worthless, as they are impossible to collect. You’ll understand that if you are a successful inventor or inventors and you have a successful invention or inventions, you will get ripped off by copycat competitors, as this is a sign of your invention success.

In addition to the truth about the terrible way you’ll be treated by the Patent Office, I’ll also share with you many experiences I have had over the last five years. I’ll describe and give you contact information for several other inventors and entrepreneurs that got a trademark on their brand name and are making and selling their products themselves, as you should be doing. ..."
The author's weapons do not consist solely of rage and indignation. He is no stranger to humour, as "A day at the Patent Office with Elaine Patenthosen (No patent examiners were harmed in the making of this parody video)" testifies. A successful inventor in his own right (details here), his words go straight to the heart.  The approach which he advocates is, the IPKat hastens to add, not one which is equally applicable to all inventions under all circumstances --  it may be particularly unsuitable for processes and for inventions that have no independent life of their own but are merely incremental add-ons to existing products.  However, for the one-patent-product scenario his advice makes a lot of sense and will be welcomed by small and some medium-sized enterprises which either can't afford patents at all or, if they get them, lack the financial and emotional resources to enforce them.


Bibliographic data: Book's website here. No risk of rupture, but don't read this if you're a patent attorney who is susceptible to apoplexy.  Price: US$ 24.95 plus packaging and posting which, as the author observes, "will cost you less than 10% of a 1 hour consultation with a patent attorney or patent lawyer" (available at the same price as an e-book).


* Terrell on the Law of Patents (17th Edition, 2011), is now edited by Richard Miller QC, Guy Burkill QC, His Honour Judge Birss QC and Douglas Campbell (all from Three New Square).  This book has been through the doldrums in its time, but successive editions since the 1970s have made it a much more useful book.  a tendency to paraphrase the relevant statute and then footnote the paraphrased provision has given way to some genuinely instructive guidance on the operation of the UK's Patents Act 1977 (as frequently amended), the most important decisions of the European Patent Office's variously-shaped Boards of Appeal and the indigenous judicial rulings and practice directions of the British courts and the UK Intellectual Property Office. 

It's difficult to introduce to readers a title which has been going since 1884 and which is familiar even to many folk who have never read it, so let's investigate the state of the current edition.  According to publishers Sweet & Maxwell, this edition has some new features:

"* Thoroughly revised and updated, with new or expanded discussion throughout of numerous current topics and recent developments in the law of patents;
* New chapters dedicated to Entitlement, to Supplementary Protection Certificates, and to the Person Skilled in the Art;
* Extensively expanded discussion of Validity issues, including major chapters now separately dedicated to Novelty, Obviousness, and Insufficiency:
* Incorporates discussion of all significant recent case law including the House of Lords decisions in Lundbeck v Generics and Conor v Angiotech, and the EPO Enlarged Board cases G2/08 and G3/08".
The IPKat couldn't bring himself to read this tome from cover to cover -- and noone would believe him if he said he did.  Has however found himself doing some sampling while using Terrell for some recent research, and found it to be crisp, current and accurate in all material respects.  He can predict with confidence that, like its ever-improving competitor The Modern Law of Patents (here), this title will run and run.

Bibliographic data: Hardback, with more Latin and Arabic pagination than this Kat can wave a paw at. ISBN: 9781847039033. Price £325 (nb there is no missing decimal point in that figure, but local delivery is free).  Web page here. Rupture factor: severe.