Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Books again ...

Intellectual Property and Private International Law has now emerged in its second edition.  Under the scholarly aegis of University of Nottingham-based Professors James J. Fawcett and Paul Torremans, this work has been aided and abetted by a stellar team of "thanks-to" supporters which includes, gratifyingly, several regular readers of this weblog.

In the thirteen years that have elapsed since the first edition, the world of IP-PIL has changed beyond all recognition as international agreements, substantive intellectual property law, national and regional judicial rulings and the rules of civil procedure have all changed in responses to their own often overlapping constituencies.  What, one might ask, has remained the same?  Apart from the title of the topic, the one real constant in the ever-changing sea of legal solutions is the nature of the problems faced by litigants and their advisers in securing, protecting and enforcing their market positions where one or more national border must be crossed in order to achieve the desired aim.

Since this book is part of the Oxford Private International Law Series (it's a big series, with 22 titles already in print), it seems prudent to take a look at what the publisher, Oxford University Press, has to say about it:
"Intellectual property has traditionally been regulated on a territorial basis [True -- but most of the current generation of IP lawyers aren't old enough to remember a time when issues like cross-border injunctions have not been on the agenda, and it is arguable that quaint curiosities such as the Madrid Agreement's 'central attack' doctrine are referable to a supra-territorial view of how IP rights should be regulated]. However, the protection and commercial exploitation of intellectual property rights such as patents, trade marks, designs and copyright occurring across borders are now seldom confined to one jurisdiction. This book considers how the introduction of a foreign element inevitably raises potential problems of private international law, ranging from establishing which court has jurisdiction and which is the applicable law to securing the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments.

The Internet has brought a significant increase in the scale of this phenomenon and valuable new chapters have been added to this edition to reflect this [This is the book's selling point: a detailed and dispassionate application of private international law principles to the internet -- which is as much a moving target as the law itself]. Nationally protected trade marks are now used globally on websites and copyright material is distributed, communicated and copied in a world without borders [it doesn't have corners either, notes Merpel, struck by the connected nature of the little world we all inhabit]. Patents have already been licensed on a transnational basis for several decades. All this raises questions of jurisdiction and applicable law. The well-respected and expert author team address such questions as; which court will have jurisdiction to deal with the issues arising from intellectual property rights and their exploitation in an international context? And which national law will the court with jurisdiction apply? Private international law questions increasingly arise and the two disciplines that previously operated in different spheres are increasingly obliged to co-operate ...."
This Kat was profoundly impressed by this work, or at least by the bits he could easily understand -- since he is primarily an IP lawyer and reading private intellectual law is, for him, a bit like reading a foreign language. He is willing to bet that it won't be another 13 years before the next edition either, with exciting developments like the Court of Justice ruling in Case C-523/10 Wintersteiger ahead of us.

Bibliographic data: lxvii + 986 pages. Hardback. ISBN 978-0-19-955658-8. Current to June 2010. Rupture factor: severe.  Web page here.



While on the subject of book reviews, here's a book that can't easily be reviewed -- or even read -- since it's a big fat compendium of handy intellectual property laws at international, regional and national (UK) level. Yes, it's two whole years since the 9th edition of Butterworths Intellectual Property Law Handbook emerged, courtesy of LexisNexis, and now we have the tenth.  IPKat team member Jeremy is naturally far too modest to mention the name of this book's Consultant Editor, who is known to be something of an intellectual property enthusiast.  Merpel says, the best thing about the 10th edition -- apart from the newly-added content -- is the fact that it retails for £6 less than its predecessor.  £116 for over 1,900 pages of law isn't a bad deal these days, and the slender paper on which it is printed makes it relatively light to carry, even though "handbook" is perhaps a bit of poetic licence.  Two other things that made this reviewer's eyes light up when he espied the new edition for the first time on his desk at Olswang LLP were (i) the fact that the boringly plain cover of earlier editions has been replaced by a sort of polka-dot themed pattern and (ii) the appearance of the legend "10th edition" in big, clear type on the spine, which means that the risk of picking up an outdated edition and using the wrong version of a statute or set of regulations is thereby diminished.  Thank you, LexisNexis, for adding this small but vital piece of functionality.

Bibliographic details: xvii + 1,914 pages. Paperback. ISBN 978-1-4057-6338-7. Rupture factor: moderate. Current to July 2011.  Web page here.

Thursday, September 1, 2011

One size fits all? Of IP rights and gefilte fish

The Structure Of Intellectual Property Law: Can One Size Fit All? Edited by Annette Kur (Max Planck Institute for Intellectual Property and Competition Law, Munich) and Vytautas Mizaras (University of Vilnius, Lithuania), this is the first in a series of annual themed volumes which Edward Elgar Publishing will be bringing out, featuring well-researched papers originating with ATRIP -- the Association for the Advancement of Teaching and Research in Intellectual Property.  As the publishers explain,
"... This well-researched and highly topical book analyses whether the ever-increasing degree of sophistication in intellectual property law necessarily leads to fragmentation and inconsistency, or whether the common principles informing the system are sustainable enough to offer a solid and resilient framework for legal development.

The expert contributors explore the legal tools that are available to adjust IP protection to different needs and circumstances and how much flexibility exists to employ these tools. In providing answers to these and other similar questions, the book helps to resolve the fundamental question of whether one size can really fit all in the domestic and international context.

Uncovering the general matrix of IP, The Structure of Intellectual Property Law will appeal to researchers in law, economics and business, students in intellectual property, competition law and economics, as well as practitioners and policymakers".
It would be invidious to pick out must-read chapters in this excellent book, but every reviewer is entitled to identify his favourites. Alexander Peukert's chapter, "Individual, multiple and collective ownership of intellectual property rights -- which impact on exclusivity?", if you can get past the clumsy and not entirely comprehensible title, makes some acute observations and asks some discomforting questions concerning IP, not omitting traditional knowledge from his analysis. Martin Senftleben's call for horizontal fair use defences ("Overprotection and protection overlaps in intellectual property law -- the need for horizonal fair use defences") also stirred the IPKat into one of his come-on-let's-legislate moods.

There is of course something wrong with this book. Although the authors cite a wealth of case law, statutes, treaties and so forth, there is no table of materials cited. Usually when the IPKat says this, it's more by way of gentle regret - but on this occasion he was genuinely inconvenienced. He actually wanted to see how -- or whether -- different contributors made reference to the same materials and also, for example, wanted to discover whether the ever-excellent Ansgar Ohly ("Free access, including freedom to imitate, as a legal principle-- a forgotten concept?") had cited any of Sir Robin Jacob's judicial utterances in the RoHo cushions litigation or L'Oréal v Bellure, but could not do so without a page-by-page hunt for them [Says Merpel: the IPKat won't tell you, but I will: Ansgar indeed mentioned both cases].

Overall, this book reminds this Kat of a Jewish culinary staple, the gefilte fish.  In its traditional form, you catch your fish and, having taken out its tasty bits, you mince them up together with onions and seasoning, then stuff them back into the skin of the original fish and cook it.  Here in this book, within the original skin of intellectual property right, the various authors have scooped out the subject's tasty bits, chopped them up with some logic and seasoned them with some sharp perspectives, then popped them back within the all-embracing framework of intellectual property. The result? A delicious concoction that you can even serve with decoration in the form of the sprig of parsley which mysteriously and unaccountably garnishes the book's front cover.  Well done, says the IPKat, this is an excellent venture; ATRIP has served its readers well [Ah, says Merpel, now I understand, with all this talk of serving and food, why it is students enroll for 'courses'].

Bibliographic data: xiii + 361 pages. Hardback. ISBN 978 1 84844 876 6.  Price £115 (but if you buy it from the publisher online, it's only £103.50. Rupture factor: small to moderate. Web page here.

Monday, July 18, 2011

IP Rights in a Fair World Trade System: a Review

Intellectual Property Rights In A Fair World Trade System: Proposals for Reform of TRIPS, edited by Annette Kur, is the book at the top of the IPKat's pile today, so he has been taking a good look at it. Annette, as readers of this blog will know, is to the Max Planck Institute for Intellectual Property and Competition Law in Munich what Lionel Messi is to Barcelona Football Club: a striking asset who attracts admiration from her supporters and respect from those who would oppose her.  In this book, aided by another formidable intellectual property scholar, Sweden's Marianne Levin, she has put together a collection of critical appraisals of the point of intersection at which IP rights -- which are designed in an ideal world to facilitate trade -- meet trade, which in an ideal world is designed to reward creation and investment in IP. A perfect marriage is one in which the partners must accept the principles of "give and take", but when IP is partnered with trade there is always a risk of "take and take", where one side holds more power and fails to recognise its responsibilities.

So what does the publisher say about this book:
"This important new book constitutes a serious examination of both the positive potential, as well as the deficiencies, of the TRIPS agreement. In the light of their analysis, the editors and their colleagues make a powerful case for wide ranging reforms.

Intellectual Property (IP) law – particularly in relation to international trade regimes – is increasingly finding itself challenged by rapid developments in the technological and global economic landscapes. In its attempt to maintain a responsive legislative system that is interacting successfully with global trade rules, IP is having to respond to an increasing number of actors on an international level. [But that's the strange thing, notes the Kat: we recognise that IP law lags behind event, yet its capacity to deliver new products, services, investment channels and the like seems to carry on quite unabated, regardless whether the law is current or not] This book examines the problems associated with this undertaking as well as suggesting possible revisions to the TRIPS agreement that would make it more relevant to the environment in which today’s IP mechanisms are operating. The overall aim is to find an adequate response to the ‘IP balance dilemma’. The theme is pursued throughout various topics, including a look at what this means in relation to the economy in a country like China, and also considering how IP is increasingly having to reconcile itself with human rights issues.

This book will appeal to academics, policy makers and post-graduate students in IP and international trade law, as well as related fields, such as development and human rights [Merpel says, what a pleasant change to see a book on IP which for once doesn't say that it is required reading for legal practitioners and patent attorneys -- though funnily enough there's plenty of real law in it which they'd probably enjoy] ".
The IPKat enjoyed the book, and particularly liked the chapter by Jens Schovsbo ("Fire and water make steam -- redefining the role of competition law in TRIPS"), not just because of its title but because, if TRIPS is to be truly trade-related -- as most of it isn't -- the role played by competition rules in channeling investment as well as in preventing market abuses is one which is played more effectively within the context of TRIPS than outside it. The author recognises the difficulties of identifying the problem areas as well as of dealing with them. Perhaps if TRIPS can make a better job of synthesizing IP and competition rules, the European Commission might one day do the same [this, says Merpel, sounds like the subject of another book ...].


Bibliographical data: xiii + 614 pages, hardback. ISBN 978 1 84980 009 9. Price £95 (but from the publisher's website £85.50). Also available as an e-book (ISBN 978 1 84980 958 0). Book's web page here. Rupture factor: moderate.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Something else to read: International Copyright (2nd edn)

Back in 2000, the first edition of Prof Paul Goldstein’s (Stanford) famous work International Copyright: Principles, Law and Practice was ground-breaking for providing a complete analysis of copyright worldwide. The text was well-structured, knowledgeable, accessible, and covered not only national laws, but international treaties and their practical application.

In the previous decade enormous changes have taken place to the law of copyright, such as the development of the internet and digital technology, which have (not surprisingly) necessitated a thorough revision of the work.This Kat notes that there are three main differences between the two editions. First, Prof Goldstein has brought Prof P Bernt Hugenholtz (Amsterdam) on board as a co-author in order for this edition to have a more expansive treatment of copyright in the European Union and its member states. Second, this edition contains updates on the case law and legislation in the principle jurisdictions of the United States, France Germany and the United Kingdom. Comparisons with other jurisdictions, such as Australia, Canada and The Netherlands are included when they make a useful contribution to the existing discussion. Third, this edition adopts a new format of twelve chapters instead of five together with an extensive bibliography in order to make the work even more accessible to advanced students and professional readers alike.

In its marketing blurb, publisher Oxford University Press states that: 
International Copyright: Principles, Law and Practice, Second Edition surveys and analyzes the principal legal doctrines affecting copyright law and practice around the world. It provides a step-by-step methodology for advising clients involved in exploiting creative works in or from foreign countries, while also serving as a comprehensive treatise on international copyright for scholars and advanced students alike. Written by two of the most esteemed experts of copyright law in the United States and Europe, this volume is a unique synthesis of copyright law and practice, taking into account the Berne Convention, the TRIPs Agreement, the ongoing harmonization of copyright in the European Union, and the impact of the Internet. National copyright rules on protectable subject matter, ownership, term, and rights are covered in detail and compared from country to country, as are topics on moral rights and neighboring rights. Separate sections cover such important topics as territoriality, national treatment, and choice of law, as well as the treaties and trade arrangements that underlie substantive copyright norms.  
International Copyright is an indispensable reference work for professionals involved with international intellectual property transactions or litigation. It is essential reading for scholars and for intellectual property practitioners worldwide, yet is also accessible for advanced students of copyright law.
This Kat believes that this book will be tremendously useful as a reference work for anyone with international dimension to their copyright practice, whether it be foreign clients seeking copyright protection under national laws or local clients entering into copyright contracts with foreign entities. The new structure, whilst retaining much of the substance of the first edition, is very effective. Part II on ‘Substantive Copyright Law’ contains the usual headings one would expect with a copyright work, such as subject matter and neighbouring rights, authorship and ownership, term of protection, economic rights, moral rights, exemptions and enforcement. Accordingly, a reader can easily locate their particular issue in the detailed table of contents and find a detailed and well-written comparative answer in the main text. The copies of the international treaties in the Appendix are also helpful. This work makes a welcome addition to this Kat’s library and she looks forward to referring to it in her future copyright practice.

Merpel notes that on its website OUP suggests that the readership for this work is ‘IP practitioners who work with patents, in-house counsel, and members of the executive suite’. Practitioners who work solely in patents will (obviously) be disappointed by the content of this work, but Merpel hopes that, through encountering this fascinating exploration of copyright on the global stage, they can be persuaded to broaden their area of expertise!

Bibliographic data:
 paperback, xxii + 565 pages. ISBN 978-0-19-973710-9. Rupture factor: minimal. Price: £70 from OUP or £66.50 from Amazon.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Something to read, Part I

As a friend and fellow-blogger, Peter Groves can expect a kind review from the IPKat.  On the other hand, the selfsame Kat came quite close to publishing an IP dictionary of his own with the same publisher (Edward Elgar Publishing) -- but pulled out of the project after he became convinced that there was no need for a printed volume of definitions in an era in which it was quicker and easier to enter a term in a search engine than to put down one's comforting mug of tea and reach for the bookshelf.  Anyway, a copy of the book in question is before the Kat at this very minute and he has been curiously turning the pages.

But first let's look at the publicity material which attended its launch:
"From 1-click and the ActionAid Chip to zwart maken, Peter Groves’ Dictionary of Intellectual Property Law' (Edward Elgar, 28 February 2011, £70) provides IP professionals and other interested parties with over 1,000 definitions covering most of the expressions that they might encounter. ...
... [T]o say that there is widespread ignorance about intellectual property is a massive understatement. What is said and written on the subject is more urban myth than solid legal understanding. Ordinary people – those who aren’t IP professionals – often have a hard time telling patents from trademarks from copyright. Many lawyers don’t know the difference, either. There’s no dictionary of intellectual property law to tell them what the words and expressions mean… until now. Peter Groves, a solicitor with 30 years’ experience of intellectual property, several books and many articles to his credit, and hundreds of hours of lecturing under his belt, has spent much of the last few years putting one together. 
Intellectual property has a vast, perplexing and diverse vocabulary, and this enriching Dictionary provides a starting point for understanding new concepts and crafting precise definitions to meet the needs of a particular case. Not only are new words and phrases being coined as technology changes and the law follows, but also the international scope of intellectual property means that IP lawyers will encounter foreign words and phrases. 
With over 1,000 expressions defined clearly and entertainingly, this book should be the first reference point to understanding intellectual property terminology. It will be particularly helpful to practitioners when they encounter expressions they have not seen before which they need to understand the true meaning and definition of. Students finding unfamiliar terminology and concepts will also appreciate the instant explanation available from this essential resource. ...".
Naturally there are omissions. 'Nerd' fails to gain an entry, notwithstanding the consideration of this word by Lords Justices Jacob and Pill in the patent appeal of Rockwater v Technip (here).  This is a pity, since one noble judge has been heard to express the notion that the definition of 'nrrd' is "the sort of person who looks up the word 'nerd' in a dictionary".  Nor, despite its recent appearance in the Patents County Court, does 'numpty' feature.  The 'moron in a hurry' is there, of course, as is that design law chameleon 'the informed user'  (only in IP is there likely to be serious speculation as to who might be the 'informed user' of a toilet bowl).

This reviewer found only one important error.  The entry under IPKat describes him has "the doyenne of intellectual property blawgs".  Doyen, if you don't mind, says the Kat -- Merpel's the doyenne!

Bibliographic data: hardback,  . ix + 336 pages. ISBN 978-1-84980-777-7. Rupture factor is not defined. Price: £70 £105.50-- but you can buy it for just £63  £94 from the Edward Elgar website here. (the publishers must have liked the review so much that they hiked the price!).


Published last year (also from Edward Elgar Publishing) is Beyond Intellectual Property: Matching Information Protection to Innovation, by IPKat team member Jeremy's old colleague William Kingston (School of Business, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland).  Having been quite merciful to Peter Groves' Dictionary on account of long and pleasant acquaintance, this Kat wondered whether he should be equally kind to the King: after all, while they have shared a number of affable conversations and pleasant events over the year, the Kat is a firm believer in the virtues of a patent system which the King would be quite willing to demolish in favour of something that works better. According to the publisher's promotional prose,
"Beyond Intellectual Property explores the many means by which information is protected. Based on thorough empirical research in the US and Europe as well as practical experience of economic innovation, it goes far beyond the traditional realm of intellectual property (IP). It also identifies the need for urgent reform of present arrangements and suggests practical ways of achieving this.

New instruments for protecting investment in information have been historically important for initiating long-wave economic cycles. William Kingston argues that although IP has been one such method, it is increasingly proving ineffective because its laws have been progressively shaped by the interests that benefit from them, rather than by visions of the public good. He demonstrates that repair will require such visions, which would also underwrite radically new forms of information protection.

This insightful book defines, describes and distinguishes between information, knowledge and meaning, and explains why information now needs changed forms of legal protection if it is to be of genuine economic value. As such, it will be of great interest to economic policy-makers, students of IP and innovation, patent agents and attorneys".
Professor Kingston's position that IP law has been "progressively shaped by the interests that benefit from them, rather than by visions of the public good" is one with which we can endlessly debate. If you take the utopian position that everyone benefits from those laws, the statement is true but meaningless -- yet if you don't, you have to define both what constitutes the interests in question and the concept of the public good.  This is no idle debating point either.  If you take trade mark law, for instance (and this book tackles information as well as innovation), it is correct to say that the law has not been progressively shaped by the interests of the consumer, but does the consumer benefit in informational terms from the same things that enable the mark's proprietor to benefit in commercial terms?  And has not IP law been more shaped by pressures of competition/antitrust law in the past few decades than by any considerations of self-interest?

Love it or loathe it, this book is well worth a read.  The author has been around the block a few times and knows how to state his positions and how to defend them.  If your definition of an interactive book is one you can respond to and, if you're a dyed-in-the-wool IP fan, have the occasional shout at, this is the book for you.

Bibliographic data:  hardback,. viii + 247 pages. ISBN 978-1-84844-992-3. Rupture factor: small. Price £65 (from the publisher's website £58.50).

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Book reviews

Apart from the light-bulb symbolism
on the cover, this book has much
to commend it to the busy reader
The IPKat has been perusing the second edition of Essentials of Intellectual Property, by Alexander I. Poltorak and Paul J. Lerner (both of General Patent Corporation).  Given the versatility and indeed the enthusiasm of the pair, it is unsurprising that the book's cover bears the subtitle 'Law, Economics and Strategy', these being but three of the many disciplines which the authors illuminate for the business reader (they can do algebra too, but 'Law, Economics, Strategy and Algebra' might be a bit too off-putting for the target readership).

Since this book has emerged nearly a decade after the first edition, it has been treated to a major update. Considering that the years since 2002 have seen such momentous activity -- the death or obsolescence of many classic business models, the rise of trollism, the combined opportunities and threats of the internet, the Doha dilution of pharma patent expectations, direction-changing Supreme Court rulings like eBay v MercExchange as well as shifts in legal and commercial perspectives resulting from Bilski and the current raft of litigation over false patent marking, to name but a few -- it would have been impossible to avoid a big rethink.

But whatever the changes, the things that remain the same have to be rammed into the reader's consciousness and it is the virtue of this book that it does just that.  Go where the money is, be prepared to share in order to grow, check how much protection you need in order to fulfill your objectives, watch out for your own liability as well as that of others -- these are among the messages that the author transmit.  For the record, this new edition includes
• Latest changes to patent law and IP best practices;
• Two all-new chapters, one on recent patent reform legislation and a second on precedent-setting lawsuits;
• Basics of patents, trade marks, copyrights, trade dress and trade secrets, specifically written for busy executives
• Methodologies of patent valuation;
• DOs and DON’Ts of patent enforcement;
• Samples of useful documents, eg a non-disclosure agreement, invention assignment form, invention disclosure form and IP audit questionnaire.
It's not a law textbook -- but it is a fun read and a very informative one. In the olden days this Kat would have taken it to read cover-to-cover on a long flight, but nowadays it takes so long to get through security that he could probably read most of it then.  The algebra is near the end, so you can pretend it isn't there ...

Bibliographic data.  Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Paperback. xxviii + 292 pages. Price: US$ 45. ISBN 978 0 470 88850 6. Available also via Amazon.com in Kindle format and via Barnes & Noble as a NOOKbook. Rupture factor: no problems.


From Bloom to Bloomsbury -- it's IP in Ireland
Not a second edition this time but a third, and also not a moment too soon, is Intellectual Property Law in Ireland, crafted by a talented trio of the IPKat's friends -- distinguished academic Bob Clark, plus that amiable pair of practitioners from FRKelly, Shane Smyth & Niamh Hall.

Only six years after its predecessor, this edition has had to run very fast to keep up with events.  The rapid unfolding of developments in the European Union and its Court of Justice, the Irish version of the "three stripes" saga and some bonny battles over fashion design have provided some of the reasons for this need. Anyway, according to the publisher's blurb, 

"This is your single-source expert guide to intellectual property law. fully updated to the key changes that have taken place in this area of law since the publication of the 2nd Ed in 2005, together with all relevant case claw. 
This unique book deals with intellectual property law in its entirety, providing a single, practical and all-embracing information source covering the main aspects of intellectual property law. The expert coverage includes copyright, trade marks, patents and design law".
The IPKat feels that the publishers could have done a bit better than this.  They could have pointed out that there is an increasingly significant body of reported Irish IP law these days. They could have added that, while much of the past tense of Irish is made up of British precedents, and an even larger proportion of its future tense is European, Ireland is very much its own country with its own style and tempo of dispute resolution, its own approach to administration and official procedures, its own interpretative nuances, its own professions and its own domestic market.  The authors have worked hard to provide a reference work which is readable, accessible and -- for the reader who frets over whether European norms of protection and enforcement are adequately implemented -- increasingly reassuring.

Bibliographic data:  Hardback.clvii + 1080 pages. Price  €180/£150. ISBN 978 1 847 66366 5. Book's web page here. Rupture factor: severe (particularly for leprechauns ...)

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

More trade mark practice laid bare

This Kat has been reviewing Amanda Michaels' (and Andrew Norris') book "A practical approach to Trade Mark Law". Already in its fourth edition the book offers 417 pages of UK trade mark law for the reader's delectation. In earlier editions called "A Practical Guide" the book is now part of OUP's 'A Practical Approach' series, which explains the change of title. The book's author Amanda Michaels is a barrister, who is, inter alia, known for her trade mark expertise. She is also an Appointed Person hearing appeals from the UKIPO. Contributing author Andrew Norris is also a barrister as well as an IP tutor - and all this knowledge and practical experience is reflected in the clear layout of the book and its non-fussy writing style.

In its 9 chapters the book covers the major trade mark law issues in a logical order: information about the trade mark system and the functions of trade marks in Chapter 1 is followed by a discussion of registrability in Chapter 2 and relative grounds of refusal in Chapter 3. Chapter 4 covers the procedure before the UKIPO in some detail as well as the procedure before OHIM and it also includes a brief overview of the Paris Convention, TRIPS and the Madrid Protocol. The book does not however discuss the Madrid System in detail. Chapter 5 sets out revocation and invalidity procedures before the UK IPO and OHIM, Chapter 6 informs the reader about the assignment and licensing of trade marks. Chapter 7 explains the UK provisions relating to trade mark infringement and the relevant defences. Chapter 8 is a definite highlight of the book with its precise and logical explanation of passing off, covering everything from the "classic form of passing off" as defined in Jif Lemon to Spalding v Gamage, as well as perennial issues such as "foreign","residual" and "shared" goodwill, celebrity endorsement and providing an understandable(!) explanation of "reverse passing off" on just half a page. Equally succinct is the discussion of "innocence, fraud or a decision to live dangerously" - again set out on just about one page of the book but feeding the reader all the relevant "sound bites". The last chapter (Chapter 9) then turns to "remedies and procedures for trade mark infringement and passing off", including the criminal provision of the Trade Marks Act and the related court procedures: this chapter provides a good overview of the main issues without going into too much detail. The information on the Company Names Tribunal is equally short but alerts you to the main points.

This being a book for practitioners, the authors have intentionally kept the book compact and digestible. Case law is included until early 2010 (including Comparative Advertising/L'Oreal Bellure and everyone's favourite: "AdWords"- albeit not the very latest cases for obvious reasons); and while the book reports about the relevant case law handed down by the ECJ, GC and the UK courts and distills the most important points, it rarely (and I would assume intentionally) discusses or criticises these decisions in much detail. And of course, there are other books readers can revert to for a more in-depth discussion and review of the case law. The book also incorporates the latest round of renumbering of Articles, such as those of the CTMR.

So what is missing or could be bettered? Given its practical approach the authors could consider including "checklists" concerning matters such as trade mark strategies, the question of likelihood of confusion, what to include in an assignment or licence document, etc. Perhaps some more information could be provided on co-existence agreements (what should be covered, is it always a good idea to have one) and the related issue of granting consent. The book also includes rather extensive appendices: the Trade Marks Act 1991, Directive 2008/95/EC, Council Regulation (EC) 207/2009, and the Trade Mark Rules 2008 are all printed in their entirety. This Kat is not quite certain that these texts add much value to the book, in particular since she herself likes to have the law text next to the reference book rather than having to thumb back and forth. Others, however, may be delighted to have all relevant information in one handy book: a matter of personal taste.

Now, is it the book for you? This book works on several levels and for readers with different backgrounds: whether you are trainee trade mark attorney who is trying to find his/her way, a part-qualified trade mark attorney or a qualified trade mark practitioner - you will find the book useful. As one of this Kat's friends has put it, the book has an understandable "non-pompous" writing style so that you can pick it up at different points in your career and be comfortable with it. Having "road tested" this book for quite some time, this Kat believes that for trade mark practitioners this is the kind of book you will use if you come across a problem in your day-to-day practice and need a quick refresher to remind you of the most important points. Sometimes further reading will be required to get to the nitty gritty details but the carefully researched footnotes will make this an easy endeavour. For students and trainees it will serve as a very solid and surprisingly comprehensive reference (and revision) book which - at a prize of under £45 - will give you a sound grounding in and understanding of UK trade mark law and practice. It might also work as basis for students' revision notes for the (current) ITMA exams. Indeed, its handy size makes it ideal for revising during your daily commute and it is affordable enough for students to be able purchase it without having to think twice. If you are a trade mark practitioner and/or trainer, or a patent attorney/lawyer (who perhaps only deals with trade mark matters on occasion) then this book is certainly a book worth having on your shelf in the office. The book may also be of interest to foreign trade mark professionals that have UK connections.

Bibliographic information: publication date 2010, 4th edition, 464 pages, paperback, ISBN 978-0-19-957968-6, Oxford University Press. More details here.

Rapture factor: relatively high - but this is a book that wants to be used.